Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Vote Count 4.2


silverspawn (1): faust
faust (1): silverspawn

Not Voting (5): Debatepro, arishipshape, EFHW, raerae, Uncleeurope

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.
Day 4 ends March 03, 2019, 04:00:00 pm.

[silverspawn]

So the biggest shift has been to move silver into that second group, so I am more likely to read a compelling case against him with more neutral eyes. Whereas prior to this day I viewed him as towny.

Why is that? Aren't all the things that made me town yesterday still true?

[Debatepro]

So the biggest shift has been to move silver into that second group, so I am more likely to read a compelling case against him with more neutral eyes. Whereas prior to this day I viewed him as towny.

Why is that? Aren't all the things that made me town yesterday still true?

Fair enough, I can’t think of anything, just trying to re-examining my assumptions.

This is an ass kicking, so part of me is thinking there may be two very good players on team scum and there are only so many of those around. If there is only one their doing some good coaching.

I asked this question before and no one answered, what is the rough win percentage for town in a closed setup, because this looks imbalanced.

[silverspawn]

Between 40 and 45% I'd guess, but I don't think anyone has gone and actually counted. It's definitely not intended that it's under 50% if there are only two factions.

(If there are three factions, it should be 33-33-33, so the overall winrate should be below 50%).

[Uncleeurope]

Well, I'm ready to vote as soon as debate and Ari answer my questions.

This the question you talking about?

Ari, can I get your lunch order, please?

If so, for my last meal I shall have seafood. Like, pretty much any halveway decent seafood.

Vote: Arishipshape

Ok, yesterday and the day before that, I was a lot more chill with my lynch. I kinda gave up proving my townieness as a lost cause, and figured you could lynch me and have it over with. Now, that has changed. We are now at Lynch right or Lose. Therefore, i'm going to have to demand a better case than "you were fake at the start of day 2". Why, in exact and excruciatingly glorious detail, are you voting for me?

She meant your lynch order, as in ranking all of us in the order you would lynch them.

[raerae]

Well, I'm ready to vote as soon as debate and Ari answer my questions.

This the question you talking about?

Ari, can I get your lunch order, please?

If so, for my last meal I shall have seafood. Like, pretty much any halveway decent seafood.

Vote: Arishipshape

Ok, yesterday and the day before that, I was a lot more chill with my lynch. I kinda gave up proving my townieness as a lost cause, and figured you could lynch me and have it over with. Now, that has changed. We are now at Lynch right or Lose. Therefore, i'm going to have to demand a better case than "you were fake at the start of day 2". Why, in exact and excruciatingly glorious detail, are you voting for me?

She meant your lynch order, as in ranking all of us in the order you would lynch them.

Seconded.

@Ari, I think it's cute you pretending like you didn't know what I was talking about like my phone hasn't been autocorrecting lynch to lunch all game. Just. F-ing. Adooooorrrrrrable.

[arishipshape]

Well, I'm ready to vote as soon as debate and Ari answer my questions.

This the question you talking about?

Ari, can I get your lunch order, please?

If so, for my last meal I shall have seafood. Like, pretty much any halveway decent seafood.

Vote: Arishipshape

Ok, yesterday and the day before that, I was a lot more chill with my lynch. I kinda gave up proving my townieness as a lost cause, and figured you could lynch me and have it over with. Now, that has changed. We are now at Lynch right or Lose. Therefore, i'm going to have to demand a better case than "you were fake at the start of day 2". Why, in exact and excruciatingly glorious detail, are you voting for me?

She meant your lynch order, as in ranking all of us in the order you would lynch them.

Seconded.

@Ari, I think it's cute you pretending like you didn't know what I was talking about like my phone hasn't been autocorrecting lynch to lunch all game. Just. F-ing. Adooooorrrrrrable.

I thought lunch was a running gag, and I was trying to take part in it. I would lynch faust, then uncle, then probably efhw. I have no idea whats roles are in this game, and with the dozens upon dozens of role possibilities it seems like fakeclaiming one of them is a pretty smart move.

[Debatepro]

Well, I'm ready to vote as soon as debate and Ari answer my questions.

This the question you talking about?

Ari, can I get your lunch order, please?

If so, for my last meal I shall have seafood. Like, pretty much any halveway decent seafood.

Vote: Arishipshape

Ok, yesterday and the day before that, I was a lot more chill with my lynch. I kinda gave up proving my townieness as a lost cause, and figured you could lynch me and have it over with. Now, that has changed. We are now at Lynch right or Lose. Therefore, i'm going to have to demand a better case than "you were fake at the start of day 2". Why, in exact and excruciatingly glorious detail, are you voting for me?

She meant your lynch order, as in ranking all of us in the order you would lynch them.

Seconded.

@Ari, I think it's cute you pretending like you didn't know what I was talking about like my phone hasn't been autocorrecting lynch to lunch all game. Just. F-ing. Adooooorrrrrrable.

I thought lunch was a running gag, and I was trying to take part in it. I would lynch faust, then uncle, then probably efhw. I have no idea whats roles are in this game, and with the dozens upon dozens of role possibilities it seems like fakeclaiming one of them is a pretty smart move.

Why not silver, you are high on his list, shouldn't town!ari scrutinize and be skeptical of him. If you are not, why?

[arishipshape]

Well, I'm ready to vote as soon as debate and Ari answer my questions.

This the question you talking about?

Ari, can I get your lunch order, please?

If so, for my last meal I shall have seafood. Like, pretty much any halveway decent seafood.

Vote: Arishipshape

Ok, yesterday and the day before that, I was a lot more chill with my lynch. I kinda gave up proving my townieness as a lost cause, and figured you could lynch me and have it over with. Now, that has changed. We are now at Lynch right or Lose. Therefore, i'm going to have to demand a better case than "you were fake at the start of day 2". Why, in exact and excruciatingly glorious detail, are you voting for me?

She meant your lynch order, as in ranking all of us in the order you would lynch them.

Seconded.

@Ari, I think it's cute you pretending like you didn't know what I was talking about like my phone hasn't been autocorrecting lynch to lunch all game. Just. F-ing. Adooooorrrrrrable.

I thought lunch was a running gag, and I was trying to take part in it. I would lynch faust, then uncle, then probably efhw. I have no idea whats roles are in this game, and with the dozens upon dozens of role possibilities it seems like fakeclaiming one of them is a pretty smart move.

Why not silver, you are high on his list, shouldn't town!ari scrutinize and be skeptical of him. If you are not, why?

Silver stayed under my radar by not giving literally any reasons for voting for me. Thats actually way way scummier than uncle, who at least has a halve baked one.

arishipshape

Silver, why the heck do you find me scummy? This is lylo, the town has to get it's act together

[Debatepro]

Why not silver, you are high on his list, shouldn't town!ari scrutinize and be skeptical of him. If you are not, why?

Silver stayed under my radar by not giving literally any reasons for voting for me. Thats actually way way scummier than uncle, who at least has a halve baked one.

arishipshape

Silver, why the heck do you find me scummy? This is lylo, the town has to get it's act together

This response is rubbish. The case is stronger against you on this day than the previous days. I suspect people believe it isn't very informative to lynch you. Your degree of newbness and feigned ignorance fluctuates wildly.

[arishipshape]

This response is rubbish. The case is stronger against you on this day than the previous days. I suspect people believe it isn't very informative to lynch you. Your degree of newbness and feigned ignorance fluctuates wildly.

What case?

[Debatepro]

This response is rubbish. The case is stronger against you on this day than the previous days. I suspect people believe it isn't very informative to lynch you. Your degree of newbness and feigned ignorance fluctuates wildly.

What case?

Dude you hammered a town without announcing your intent to hammer.

[arishipshape]

I swear, on the last shred of honor that I may or may not have preserved in this train wreck of a game, that that hammer was completely un-intentional.

[raerae]

EFHW, Uncle, how about Debate?  You guys want to make that lynch happen? 

[Uncleeurope]

I would probably prefer doing him later rather than sooner.

But I am definitely willing to lynch him overall.

That being said, I am suspicious that you asking me and EFHW suggests that you are not asking what you appear to be asking, and my opinion will sway you negatively.

[raerae]

I would probably prefer doing him later rather than sooner.

But I am definitely willing to lynch him overall.

That being said, I am suspicious that you asking me and EFHW suggests that you are not asking what you appear to be asking, and my opinion will sway you negatively.

1) Why later?
2) What do you think I'm asking? 
3) I'll explain everything, I promise this time I'm not just asking to ask. 

[EFHW]

EFHW, Uncle, how about Debate?  You guys want to make that lynch happen?

I want a silver lynch.

[raerae]

EFHW, Uncle, how about Debate?  You guys want to make that lynch happen?

I want a silver lynch.

Cool, I don't think you're wrong but just hear me out.  After Eddie comes back.

[Uncleeurope]

I would probably prefer doing him later rather than sooner.

But I am definitely willing to lynch him overall.

That being said, I am suspicious that you asking me and EFHW suggests that you are not asking what you appear to be asking, and my opinion will sway you negatively.

1) Why later?
2) What do you think I'm asking? 
3) I'll explain everything, I promise this time I'm not just asking to ask.

1. I think Lynching other people enables a higher chance at another day.
2. You are asking your scumreads who to kill as a way to then do the opposite.
3. Okay

[raerae]

I would probably prefer doing him later rather than sooner.

But I am definitely willing to lynch him overall.

That being said, I am suspicious that you asking me and EFHW suggests that you are not asking what you appear to be asking, and my opinion will sway you negatively.

1) Why later?
2) What do you think I'm asking? 
3) I'll explain everything, I promise this time I'm not just asking to ask.

1. I think Lynching other people enables a higher chance at another day.
2. You are asking your scumreads who to kill as a way to then do the opposite.
3. Okay

Naw, you two cool.  I'm pretty sure it's you, me, EFHW, and faust.  I'm pretty sure they're (Ari and silver) protecting Debate (notice how he's getting about as much suspicion as me and EFHW?) so I think that means he's got the PR, or at least the one they want to protect the most.  Which is why I'd prefer his lynch today.  You game?

[Uncleeurope]

Well that’s a switch from your previous beliefs.

Interesting theory about him being the PR... There comes a point where their power role doesn’t matter, though, but I don’t know.

If he is Ninja then that kicks EFHW’s influence up a lot.

Ehhhh, I would still probably push one of the other’s first to be safe. Ehhhhhhhhh...

[raerae]

Well that’s a switch from your previous beliefs.

Interesting theory about him being the PR... There comes a point where their power role doesn’t matter, though, but I don’t know.

If he is Ninja then that kicks EFHW’s influence up a lot.

Ehhhh, I would still probably push one of the other’s first to be safe. Ehhhhhhhhh...

Yeah, definitely a switch but you know I'm town so you know it's genuine.  I think silver's a slamdunk but I'll be dead tomorrow and EFHW won't have a result again.  If we kill Debate today EFHW has a better shot at a result but may not survive the night.  I think it's the right thing to do and, sorry I'm gambling with your life, EFHW, I think it's worth the risk.

[raerae]

And, for what it's worth, when I suggested an EFHW lynch at the beginning of the day I was fishing, hoping scum would see it as an easy lynch since the IC suggested it.  Clearly they are clever devils.  That is highly disappointing.

[Debatepro]

If you lynch me we will have extra free time to join a new game. This game is not being powned by a team that includes Ari and Debatepro with a coach.

We are losing in an epic way, this will be a perfect scum win, new players can’t pull this off.

[raerae]

And consider what a silver lunch does re: faust. Does it make him town? Do we consider a faust lunch tomorrow? I think it hurts us to kill one of them today IF we're willing to entertain the thought of them being a team.