And I did already say. The MiX wagon was scummy as fuck. He was clearly just an enthusiastic newbie, which makes me confident that (experienced) scum just jumped on the wagon to help the mislynch
As I think the wagon was super scummy, I think it's likely to have more than 1 scum on it. I don't think 6 town could actually have found him scummy rather than just a newbie
I'm trying to understand why this looked scummy as
F. I also, don't think the question about how one can conclude there are two scum on MiX is answered or at least the analysis is substandard.
1. The mason who is an experienced player and their likely partner voted for MiX. My newb understanding is they get to talk in private about what they are seeing, engage in cooperative analysis, among other things. So respected town voted for MiX. You are ignoring this
~fact when stating "at least 2 scum are on MiX... and aserting it's scummy as
F."
2. In my assessment at least 3 people on MiX are town so why can't there be more. Only scum would know how many town where on MiX.
3. I thought the constant questions, flip-flopping the votes, jumping from newly forming wagon to wagon, the IRL FoS, etc. where highly suspect for a non-newb. He claimed to have played online mafia in a quicker format, he claimed to read previous games and know players meta, he had the right vocabulary of someone who shouldn't be treated as a newb, and yet you are overselling his newbness. If one does not code MiX newb, then it is
~reasonable to see why his behaviors could be interpreted as scum. I can see if one gave him newb status why one would view this behavior as less scummy on the spectrum, but not scummy at all? I mean scummy as
F is like it is obvious to all that there is a near zero percent chance MiX is scum.
I am actually the only newb in this game (Ari played IRL) meaning I have never played in any form, I did not read any games, I did not read mafia strategy [sans to look up a couple words], my only experience is an explanation of how to play the game from my IRL partner, and discussion with them about some of their previous games at the time they were being played.
IF one is town
AND there is a chance all or all but one of the people on MiX are town
AND ignoring the fact that mason(s) were on MiX
WHILE saying the MiX wagon was scummy as
FTHEN this is a dangerous/careless position for a town to take.