vote: mcmc
I strongly prefer the Mcmc lynch to Gkrieg, and for the following reason more than anything else:
f.ds has a bad meta that those who talk the most and participate more are far more likely to be suspected. In a game thread such as this, which has been as dead as it's been (and yes, I've been a contributor to this), scum have very little incentive to participate. They can't go non-existent either mind you, but why draw attention to themselves when there is simply no reason?
And of course, there's the WIFOM that if we "always let those that are participating get a pass" then scum will just post more - but if that's the end result I think we come out with a much better chance of catching them in the long term without having to rely on PR's to get lucky.
Further, in regards to Mcmc, this isn't just a "lynch all lurkers" lynch. He was definitely off D1 - I liked my case on him then, but I'll also admit I liked his defense. Problem I have is that... well, he was the 2nd leading wagon D1 - and it's reasonable to assume that he would come into today taking some heat for avoiding the lynch at LaLight's expense. From that perspective, as scum, I would've done exactly what he's done - meld into the shadows hoping to avoid that heat, but be ready to come up fighting if the pressure gets applied. From a town perspective though, I think I would've come into today with a little extra effort to right the ship, knowing that I was a possible "next-in-line-mislynch".
Gkrieg, on the other hand, is fighting the iguana case, even without a lot of votes (they're building a little bit now, but he's been active since the case was made). He's been active for most of D2, and the primary point against his lynch (that two other players appear townie to iguana) is something I just don't agree with. I think Datswan is scum. His thoughts D1 weren't well thought out or complete, and he's been making statements that to me have felt like he's trying to stay "in-meta" rather than find scum.
Moving down the list, I also think Eevee is scum. AFAIK he has like, no scum reads, and has been town reading almost everybody - a pretty telling scum!Eevee trait in my experience.
I'm also highly (highly) suspicious of Hydrad for reasons that I'm not going to go into right now.
Want to lynch:
Mcmc (Between him and Gkrieg, this is the better lynch)
Datswan (scum scum)
Eevee (scum scum)
Hydrad (scum scum)
Won't lynch:
Space (town tell - not going into more detail)
Iguana
Will lynch to get a lynch through:
Anybody
Don't want to lynch:
Gkrieg (reasons above, plus 2/3 on wagon I believe to be scum (Datswan/Hydrad)
Don't know what to make of:
Robz888 (Bad!Robz usually = Town!Robz though)
IDPTG (Is he even playing this game?)
Awaclus (Hell if I know)
EFHW (She was a stronger presence D1, and I think she'll be later on too - at least enough to get a better read than I have now)