Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Swowl]

Could someone - you know just for the sake of trying to win - try to come up with a case for someone else? Idk if i am just tunneled or what but these are the only options i am seeing.

I mean, I'm voting for you.

I mean I doubt it will end in me voting for myself... but if you wanna share your case I am not going to try and stop you.

I don't really want to share it. Do you want to share why I shouldn't have a case on you?

Because I am Town. I mean I don't really wanna go through and do every bit piece of everything so if you come up with something lmk because sure as heck got nothing else to do this game.

Main point would be that end of day 2 TWM voted for me to make it 3-3 flip when he could of voted for SS instead (still making it 3-3, just not with me). Seems like a specific point, but it is oddly large and important. If I am his partner, why would he risk flipping with me instead of flipping with SS?

[Swowl]

huh.... actually just think I stumbled on something. love our little talks.

unvote

[Swowl]

OK someone find the fault in this logic, as I am sure it is there somewhere. Both points are regarding when we lynched skum (TWM at end of day 2):

The time in which I am finding specifically interesting is starting this post:

The_Wine_Merchant (3): theorel, joseph, Space
DatSwan (2): schadd, Robz
Awaclus (1): silverspawn
silver (2): awaclus, DatSwan
IDPTG (2): RR, Wine

Well I guess I have to vote: datswan

He said that he HAS to vote for me. Not true as SS also had 2 votes on them. Normally the argument could be made that my vote would not matter as it had to of been on TWM by now, but actually this wasn't the case. He could of gone SS just the same as he went for me and been in the exact same situation. Skum had to of assumed either TWM would grow over me (for reasons like - I wasn't voting him yet) or decide to go for a slip. Think about it. How skummy does TWM voting for me, then partner moves to me, then (assumingly) I move to TWM to tie it. They both would look horrible in that construct and we are still flipping! If it flips TWM then same spot except "hey thats weird that other guy also jumped over last minute" and if it flips me the lynch pool for the next day would be EXACTLY those 2 players.


Only other point I have is that the thing that is the simplest explanation is that his partner did not save him because they couldn't (meaning they were already on me). So that would be Robz. The only thing I can say on top of that is that as suspicious as everyone has been of him as the mime this game... it is odd he hasn't been shot yet.

[Joseph2302]

I'm completely lost. I should really  re-read.

Ditto I need to do this

[IDontPlayThisGame]

OK someone find the fault in this logic, as I am sure it is there somewhere. Both points are regarding when we lynched skum (TWM at end of day 2):

The time in which I am finding specifically interesting is starting this post:

The_Wine_Merchant (3): theorel, joseph, Space
DatSwan (2): schadd, Robz
Awaclus (1): silverspawn
silver (2): awaclus, DatSwan
IDPTG (2): RR, Wine

Well I guess I have to vote: datswan

He said that he HAS to vote for me. Not true as SS also had 2 votes on them. Normally the argument could be made that my vote would not matter as it had to of been on TWM by now, but actually this wasn't the case. He could of gone SS just the same as he went for me and been in the exact same situation. Skum had to of assumed either TWM would grow over me (for reasons like - I wasn't voting him yet) or decide to go for a slip. Think about it. How skummy does TWM voting for me, then partner moves to me, then (assumingly) I move to TWM to tie it. They both would look horrible in that construct and we are still flipping! If it flips TWM then same spot except "hey thats weird that other guy also jumped over last minute" and if it flips me the lynch pool for the next day would be EXACTLY those 2 players.


Only other point I have is that the thing that is the simplest explanation is that his partner did not save him because they couldn't (meaning they were already on me). So that would be Robz. The only thing I can say on top of that is that as suspicious as everyone has been of him as the mime this game... it is odd he hasn't been shot yet.

What's the your point with the first bit?

As for Robz, why would mafia kill mime!Robz rather than try to leave him alone and use his mimeread status to ensure he doesn't get lynched?

[IDontPlayThisGame]

OK someone find the fault in this logic, as I am sure it is there somewhere. Both points are regarding when we lynched skum (TWM at end of day 2):

The time in which I am finding specifically interesting is starting this post:

The_Wine_Merchant (3): theorel, joseph, Space
DatSwan (2): schadd, Robz
Awaclus (1): silverspawn
silver (2): awaclus, DatSwan
IDPTG (2): RR, Wine

Well I guess I have to vote: datswan

He said that he HAS to vote for me. Not true as SS also had 2 votes on them. Normally the argument could be made that my vote would not matter as it had to of been on TWM by now, but actually this wasn't the case. He could of gone SS just the same as he went for me and been in the exact same situation. Skum had to of assumed either TWM would grow over me (for reasons like - I wasn't voting him yet) or decide to go for a slip. Think about it. How skummy does TWM voting for me, then partner moves to me, then (assumingly) I move to TWM to tie it. They both would look horrible in that construct and we are still flipping! If it flips TWM then same spot except "hey thats weird that other guy also jumped over last minute" and if it flips me the lynch pool for the next day would be EXACTLY those 2 players.


Only other point I have is that the thing that is the simplest explanation is that his partner did not save him because they couldn't (meaning they were already on me). So that would be Robz. The only thing I can say on top of that is that as suspicious as everyone has been of him as the mime this game... it is odd he hasn't been shot yet.

What's your point with the first bit?

As for Robz, why would mafia kill mime!Robz rather than try to leave him alone and use his mimeread status to ensure he doesn't get lynched?

Edit

[Swowl]

OK someone find the fault in this logic, as I am sure it is there somewhere. Both points are regarding when we lynched skum (TWM at end of day 2):

The time in which I am finding specifically interesting is starting this post:

The_Wine_Merchant (3): theorel, joseph, Space
DatSwan (2): schadd, Robz
Awaclus (1): silverspawn
silver (2): awaclus, DatSwan
IDPTG (2): RR, Wine

Well I guess I have to vote: datswan

He said that he HAS to vote for me. Not true as SS also had 2 votes on them. Normally the argument could be made that my vote would not matter as it had to of been on TWM by now, but actually this wasn't the case. He could of gone SS just the same as he went for me and been in the exact same situation. Skum had to of assumed either TWM would grow over me (for reasons like - I wasn't voting him yet) or decide to go for a slip. Think about it. How skummy does TWM voting for me, then partner moves to me, then (assumingly) I move to TWM to tie it. They both would look horrible in that construct and we are still flipping! If it flips TWM then same spot except "hey thats weird that other guy also jumped over last minute" and if it flips me the lynch pool for the next day would be EXACTLY those 2 players.


Only other point I have is that the thing that is the simplest explanation is that his partner did not save him because they couldn't (meaning they were already on me). So that would be Robz. The only thing I can say on top of that is that as suspicious as everyone has been of him as the mime this game... it is odd he hasn't been shot yet.

What's the your point with the first bit?

As for Robz, why would mafia kill mime!Robz rather than try to leave him alone and use his mimeread status to ensure he doesn't get lynched?

bc mafia is only one player and if we were to end up lynching him then mafia loses along with us.

I did say that was my weaker of the two points.

And I don't know how to better explain the first part. he said he has to vote for me. he didn't it makes me suspicious.

[IDontPlayThisGame]

OK someone find the fault in this logic, as I am sure it is there somewhere. Both points are regarding when we lynched skum (TWM at end of day 2):

The time in which I am finding specifically interesting is starting this post:

The_Wine_Merchant (3): theorel, joseph, Space
DatSwan (2): schadd, Robz
Awaclus (1): silverspawn
silver (2): awaclus, DatSwan
IDPTG (2): RR, Wine

Well I guess I have to vote: datswan

He said that he HAS to vote for me. Not true as SS also had 2 votes on them. Normally the argument could be made that my vote would not matter as it had to of been on TWM by now, but actually this wasn't the case. He could of gone SS just the same as he went for me and been in the exact same situation. Skum had to of assumed either TWM would grow over me (for reasons like - I wasn't voting him yet) or decide to go for a slip. Think about it. How skummy does TWM voting for me, then partner moves to me, then (assumingly) I move to TWM to tie it. They both would look horrible in that construct and we are still flipping! If it flips TWM then same spot except "hey thats weird that other guy also jumped over last minute" and if it flips me the lynch pool for the next day would be EXACTLY those 2 players.


Only other point I have is that the thing that is the simplest explanation is that his partner did not save him because they couldn't (meaning they were already on me). So that would be Robz. The only thing I can say on top of that is that as suspicious as everyone has been of him as the mime this game... it is odd he hasn't been shot yet.

What's the your point with the first bit?

As for Robz, why would mafia kill mime!Robz rather than try to leave him alone and use his mimeread status to ensure he doesn't get lynched?

bc mafia is only one player and if we were to end up lynching him then mafia loses along with us.

I did say that was my weaker of the two points.

And I don't know how to better explain the first part. he said he has to vote for me. he didn't it makes me suspicious.

Ah, okay. I wasn't sure if you were intending to use it as an argument for mafia!ss (in which case the hole is that it relies on TWM being careless/going for WIFOM) or just stating your suspicion.

[Swowl]

OK someone find the fault in this logic, as I am sure it is there somewhere. Both points are regarding when we lynched skum (TWM at end of day 2):

The time in which I am finding specifically interesting is starting this post:

The_Wine_Merchant (3): theorel, joseph, Space
DatSwan (2): schadd, Robz
Awaclus (1): silverspawn
silver (2): awaclus, DatSwan
IDPTG (2): RR, Wine

Well I guess I have to vote: datswan

He said that he HAS to vote for me. Not true as SS also had 2 votes on them. Normally the argument could be made that my vote would not matter as it had to of been on TWM by now, but actually this wasn't the case. He could of gone SS just the same as he went for me and been in the exact same situation. Skum had to of assumed either TWM would grow over me (for reasons like - I wasn't voting him yet) or decide to go for a slip. Think about it. How skummy does TWM voting for me, then partner moves to me, then (assumingly) I move to TWM to tie it. They both would look horrible in that construct and we are still flipping! If it flips TWM then same spot except "hey thats weird that other guy also jumped over last minute" and if it flips me the lynch pool for the next day would be EXACTLY those 2 players.


Only other point I have is that the thing that is the simplest explanation is that his partner did not save him because they couldn't (meaning they were already on me). So that would be Robz. The only thing I can say on top of that is that as suspicious as everyone has been of him as the mime this game... it is odd he hasn't been shot yet.

What's the your point with the first bit?

As for Robz, why would mafia kill mime!Robz rather than try to leave him alone and use his mimeread status to ensure he doesn't get lynched?

bc mafia is only one player and if we were to end up lynching him then mafia loses along with us.

I did say that was my weaker of the two points.

And I don't know how to better explain the first part. he said he has to vote for me. he didn't it makes me suspicious.

Ah, okay. I wasn't sure if you were intending to use it as an argument for mafia!ss (in which case the hole is that it relies on TWM being careless/going for WIFOM) or just stating your suspicion.

I mean it is and isn't.
From TWM perspective - if they do not go for Skum!SS and goes for me then they create a situation where obv they proc SS bc its a tie or he dies.
From the TWM perspective - if they do go for Skum!SS and does not go for me he makes even wagons on both himself and SS.
Either way a Skum is lynched.

The thing that plays into whatever - is that SS did NOT come and vote for me after he chose me.

[Swowl]

guys can someone do something. like a lynch order list or something?
just so we can move this along more than anything.
The argument "it is early" doesn't really matter if we aren't using the time.

[Awaclus]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

[Joseph2302]

guys can someone do something. like a lynch order list or something?
just so we can move this along more than anything.
The argument "it is early" doesn't really matter if we aren't using the time.

I'll reread today and give an answer to this

[Swowl]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

[Awaclus]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

[Swowl]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

lol I am fairly confident that is not happening.

[Awaclus]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

lol I am fairly confident that is not happening.

Why?

[Swowl]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

lol I am fairly confident that is not happening.

Why?

idk I feel lucky

[Robz888]

I will have more time for this tomorrow.

[IDontPlayThisGame]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

Do you think scum!TWM moved to partner!DatSwan in self preservation over silverspawn?

[Awaclus]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

Do you think scum!TWM moved to partner!DatSwan in self preservation over silverspawn?

Let DatSwan come up with his own defense.

[Swowl]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

Do you think scum!TWM moved to partner!DatSwan in self preservation over silverspawn?

Let DatSwan come up

with his own defense.

Defense to what?

[Awaclus]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

Do you think scum!TWM moved to partner!DatSwan in self preservation over silverspawn?

Let DatSwan come up

with his own defense.

Defense to what?

The fact that you're scum.

[Swowl]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

Do you think scum!TWM moved to partner!DatSwan in self preservation over silverspawn?

Let DatSwan come up

with his own defense.

Defense to what?

The fact that you're scum.

How can I be skum if you are skum?

[Awaclus]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

Do you think scum!TWM moved to partner!DatSwan in self preservation over silverspawn?

Let DatSwan come up

with his own defense.

Defense to what?

The fact that you're scum.

How can I be skum if you are skum?

You can't, but I'm not scum so therefore you can.

[Swowl]

Here's a lynch order list:

DatSwan

Helpful

So why aren't we lynching DatSwan?

Do you think scum!TWM moved to partner!DatSwan in self preservation over silverspawn?

Let DatSwan come up

with his own defense.

Defense to what?

The fact that you're scum.

How can I be skum if you are skum?

You can't, but I'm not scum so therefore you can.

but I am not skum... therefore you can be skum.