Two reminders. I still don't like the Andrew lynch. I was ready to give town points to anyone who asked "why" but no one has bothered.
Second. I am basically gone starting Friday morning. I will be at work then hitting the road. Access will be very much up in the air and my destination has no internet nor great phone access. If you want me to participate in the lynch it needs to be tomorrow night. So we basically have 24 hours.
Why
Ok.
So here is why I think Andrew is a poor lynch. From what I understand Andrew is considered a good lynch for the following reasons:
1. Tunneling known town members - I don't see this as scummy. Let's actually look at other games and see if that adds up. Looking at M96 where I was mafia with him, he didn't tunnel. He bounced around and more importantly lightly buss. You can't buss someone who ends up being town.
2. Getting into an argument with Cuzz - Cuzz seems like an easy guy to get into an argument with and Andrew I think is slightly more likely to argue than others. That is personality.
3. Buddying me - Andrew and I have been involved with each other for a bit here. I have said this before. We have been partners, he modded a game with me in it and superbly townread each other last game (M98). He can read me and I think I can read him.
4. lurking - when Andrew is scum he posts more often.
People who have been pushing the Andrew wagon are on the suspicious end to me (Cuzz, PPS, Eevee, 2.7, sudgy) I don't know why PPS and Cuzz are getting general passes here. They might not be the best lynches right now, but I am seeing too many people declare them to be town when that isn't based off anything worthy of that read at all.
What it boils down to is that the reasons for the Andrew wagon aren't very good, the people pushing it are suspect and I have a strongish town read coming from someone that is nearly confirmed town and I think I have an above average ability to read him.
That is all.