Next: Eevee
Vote: sudgy
As I said earlier, I just pushed the "looks like scum caught for the wrong reasons" argument as scum myself, good enough for me.
^ If I'm correct and sudgy is scum, this looks right.
I thought he was a superior option to TWM/mcmc.
^ At this point it looks like anyone would have been a better option that those two, so correct there.
Isn't Reggie being too erratic for scum?
Vote: awaclus
^ Correct on Reggie, seems likely to be wrong on Awaclus.
Just assuming Reggie is going to flip scum seems like a reach.
Like, if that happens, mcmc is totally justified in what he did, of course. Still more likely than not he is town, though, must be? Feels crazy you are doing analysis expecting a scum flip.
This was in twilight. Seems more sure than most that JR was flipping town.
I'm pretty sure I never voted for mcmc or gkrieg. I was trying to start awaclus or andrew wagons, but didn't get much support, and i joined the reggie train for a bit and then abandoned it after the claim.
*or tmw
I would assume at least one scum would to be off town wagons to look like their reads are good. With a team of 5 people, you would probably want to divide up so that some people are pushing early mislynches while others are setting up future lynches while getting towncred early for being right.
One thing that's bugging me about mcmc is that his reaction to hammering town is not "oh man, my read was wrong, sorry town!", it's "oh, the people who got off this town wagon are scummy". That does not seem like a town mindset to me, there is no doubting himself. The situation IS confusing, I know I'm not very confident I could pick even one scum, let alone four person scum teams. And mcmc is just doubling down on his reads, not pausing at all after hammering a town player last night. I could see this as a distraction for his own hammer, basically the scum narrative of "town wouldn't be this confident in their reads after just being wrong -> it's scum going aggressive.
Throws suspicioun at mcmc, then:
Just checking in, no new reads apart from the obvious ones. Mcmc's plan/claim seem fantastic for us.
Mcmc played the virgin role very similar to this, I had a hunch he he might be some sort of an unusual pr.
He acts like he thought mcmc was a PR the whole time. This last point isn't much, but it is something.
I lean scum on Eevee playing the scum who was in the right places all the time until it's too late for town role.
PPE 1