Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[LaLight]

I am indeed one of the most active mafia players, but I rarely am the most active D1. M90, M99, are examples of it

[LaLight]

holy crap i botch quotes so frequently.

I can read them, nevermind

[O]

Awaclus is still the best lynch. I have no good read on whether he's a bad townie/scum, but all percentages being equal I'd rather have lynched someone whos vote is essentially going to be RNG in a serious situation than someone who is actively playing.


6-7/22 (23 minus me) chance that he's scum/survivor i guess, 15-16/22 chance he's an essential RNG vote townie, which is still a negative utility townie practically.

[iguanaiguana]

What? How exactly did I try to control anything? May you give relevant qoutes please?

Well, when O accused you of being controlling, you tried to shut him down by saying:

What? How exactly did I try to control anything? May you give relevant qoutes please?

To shut him down? People, I don't follow your thoughts

Well, it was half way a joke - your post responding to him calling you controlling sounded... a little... controlling!

But overall I don't agree that you've been driving the game.

And I think I prefer

Vote: Galzria

I don't want to let this guy Sherlock town into the dirt.

Cue the hordes of people who will join me on this sensible quest.

[LaLight]

O, what do you think about Eevee and his reason for voting me?

[O]

O, what do you think about Eevee and his reason for voting me?

I don't recall Eevee being so serious and cognizant 5 years ago, he was quite a bit sillier.

I have legitimately no clue what eevee was saying when he voted for you, and it's probably the most poorly written thing he's done so far.

But I put very little into shitty reasons to vote day 1 as a scumtell.

[O]

unvote

I've changed my mind on LaLight.

Awaclus > Faust > J Reggie/Roadrunner > Jimmmm/AndrewisFTTW/Galzria//Gkrieg> neutral others > Mcmc > cuzz/TWM

[LaLight]

unvote

I've changed my mind on LaLight.

Awaclus > Faust > J Reggie/Roadrunner > Jimmmm/AndrewisFTTW/Galzria//Gkrieg> neutral others > Mcmc > cuzz/TWM

I am neutral others?

[O]

pretty much

[Awaclus]

Awaclus is still the best lynch. I have no good read on whether he's a bad townie/scum, but all percentages being equal I'd rather have lynched someone whos vote is essentially going to be RNG in a serious situation than someone who is actively playing.

By that logic, you should want to lynch anyone but me, really.

[Cuzz]

Awaclus is still the best lynch. I have no good read on whether he's a bad townie/scum, but all percentages being equal I'd rather have lynched someone whos vote is essentially going to be RNG in a serious situation than someone who is actively playing.

By that logic, you should want to lynch anyone but me, really.

very logic. such reason

[Awaclus]

Awaclus is still the best lynch. I have no good read on whether he's a bad townie/scum, but all percentages being equal I'd rather have lynched someone whos vote is essentially going to be RNG in a serious situation than someone who is actively playing.

By that logic, you should want to lynch anyone but me, really.

very logic. such reason

That meme was funny for a day, and that day was years ago.

[Galzria]

I think the thing to decide is, who do you trust less: Lalight, or Galzria?

Cause that dude is controlling the whole game right now.

Why would anybody trust either of us? People should be making up their own minds and cases. I hate being called "controlling" in a game like this, but it's my playstyle to be engaging. I wish more people engaged at a greater level. One, I personally find it more fun and two, I think the more interactions there are the better chance town has to win.

[O]

O, what do you think about Eevee and his reason for voting me?

is there a reason you stopped exploring this after I unvoted you?

Though you might have just become busy.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Fixed some unvotes I had missed.

Way to ruin my plan to fake hammer.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

And, since TWM didn't really react, I do still like the Reggie wagon better.  Back to Vote: J Reggie.

That seems odd.

[LaLight]

O, what do you think about Eevee and his reason for voting me?

is there a reason you stopped exploring this after I unvoted you?

Though you might have just become busy.

Yeah, it's 1am in my place. I go to bed after this post.

I am actually waiting on eevee to return and explain it, because it's really nonsense.

PPE: 2

[The_Wine_Merchant]

So the 4 that got off the wagon are: Eevee, Sudgy, TWM and me.

Reads on all 4 please.

TWM who was very active and doing some scummy stuff as I mentioned previously and then disappeared seems scummy

If by disappear you mean went to sleep and then had work and actually worked, then sure I disappeared. But sleeping and a job shouldn't be considered scummy.
And I still want to vote for JReggie but am trying to not be an idiot and end the day early, can't be too careful.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

I'm not a big fan of the fact that LaLight supports the idea that scum were the ones responsible for "derailing" the Reggie wagon, regardless of Reggie's alignment - but when asked specifically about the 4 (only FOUR!) people to have left the wagon he doesn't have strong reads on any of them.

It feels... fabricated.

Actually. Vote: LaLight. His responses just don't ring genuine to me.

I strongly disagree. You asked for something and he gave it. They felt perfectly genuine and plausible for the third day of Day 1.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Err... what? LaLight is town.

I am with Faust. Suspicious of the quick joiner-owners here. O, eevee and pps. Two of which were more townier reads before so maybe not and I am projecting?

[The_Wine_Merchant]

unvote

I've changed my mind on LaLight.

Awaclus > Faust > J Reggie/Roadrunner > Jimmmm/AndrewisFTTW/Galzria//Gkrieg> neutral others > Mcmc > cuzz/TWM

Ok. Back to town on O. I think this goes both ways for lalight's alignment. Awaclus I think you should consider voting elsewhere.

[Galzria]

I'm not a big fan of the fact that LaLight supports the idea that scum were the ones responsible for "derailing" the Reggie wagon, regardless of Reggie's alignment - but when asked specifically about the 4 (only FOUR!) people to have left the wagon he doesn't have strong reads on any of them.

It feels... fabricated.

Actually. Vote: LaLight. His responses just don't ring genuine to me.

I strongly disagree. You asked for something and he gave it. They felt perfectly genuine and plausible for the third day of Day 1.

It's a correlation in my mind. In a two scenario world (Reggie is scum or town), he said:

"If A, then X"
"If B, then X"
but when asked about X, there was no relationship to A or B. In fact, two of the four people that fall into the "X" category, he had townish reads on. And the other two were only slightly scum.

I guess in my mind, if in a two scenario world A and B both lead to X, then I'm intently focusing on X - since that's the constant. Having soft feelings on X feels weird to me, and leads me to feel like he made a statement (in this case that he believed scum tried to derail the wagon on Reggie, regardless of Reggie's alignment), without following the thought process through. Hell, when O first asked who it was that "bailed", he didn't even know exactly!

I don't really remember, there were sudgy and TWM and I think someone else

Maybe I'm crazy. You seem to disagree with me here, as does faust. PPS voted LaLight. O voted and then backed off. Eevee sheeped again - that's a little weird. Does town!Eevee sheep a lot these days? I don't know. I like LaLight better than J Reggie.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

without following the thought process through.

That is more town than scum, IMO. Most scum, and I think LaLight is one that would fit that bill, would think that out beforehand. What I saw from LaLight was working through the problems, just musing out-loud and not fully going through the whole exercise. And I don't think town needs to or necessarily always should on Day 1.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

And I don't think you are crazy. I see what you are doing and I appreciate it. But I disagree with your conclusion, but don't find that you are scummy for it.

[Eevee]

Eh, guess I wasn't reading very carefully, I don't know what I was thinking. Pretty triggerhappy with my vote because I don't like the leading wagons very much. Unvote anyways, I feel silly.