Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[mcmcsalot]

This post from lalight sounds way more like scum who didn't want to have to join the wagon now being worried it's going to go away completely. Though this isn't a great theory because again, it's a huge game, scum could just pivot toward a different town wagon. (Though I'm town and lalight was trying to get that going to limited success).

Mcmc - Does scum care all that much about rushing to a lynch? Assume Reggie is town - do they jump to keep pushing a wagon that is showing signs of coming apart? That is,  are they really "worried about it going away completely " as you say?

Note that I did say I'm not quite sure how good my theory is because I'm not sure scum does want to rush to a lynch. There are plenty of other townies they could pivot towards rather than risk looking scummy as lalight does trying to re-push the jreggie wagon through. However as I also said lalight was trying to get my wagon going for a while to limited success so maybe he was getting paranoid and just decided to go for it.
Ppe: written about an hour ago

[LaLight]

for me personally You and Faust seem scummy as all hell every time you two post but I think it might just be playstyle choices.

I'd probably lynch either of you before J Reggie but after Awaclus

"you" being me or Galz?

[O]

for me personally You and Faust seem scummy as all hell every time you two post but I think it might just be playstyle choices.

I'd probably lynch either of you before J Reggie but after Awaclus

"you" being me or Galz?

You being you, LaLight, sorry.

Galz is slightly scummy but mostly neutral to me

[Eevee]

Awaclus hasn't posted reads on anyone but O. I don't think he is at the bottom of the post count, but his postcount-to-content ratio is very low.

[Galzria]

I'm not a big fan of the fact that LaLight supports the idea that scum were the ones responsible for "derailing" the Reggie wagon, regardless of Reggie's alignment - but when asked specifically about the 4 (only FOUR!) people to have left the wagon he doesn't have strong reads on any of them.

It feels... fabricated.

[LaLight]

for me personally You and Faust seem scummy as all hell every time you two post but I think it might just be playstyle choices.

I'd probably lynch either of you before J Reggie but after Awaclus

"you" being me or Galz?

You being you, LaLight, sorry.

Galz is slightly scummy but mostly neutral to me

Why after Awaclus? OMGUS? What exactly don't you like about him?

[LaLight]

I'm not a big fan of the fact that LaLight supports the idea that scum were the ones responsible for "derailing" the Reggie wagon, regardless of Reggie's alignment - but when asked specifically about the 4 (only FOUR!) people to have left the wagon he doesn't have strong reads on any of them.

It feels... fabricated.

I don't have strong reads on anyone, how in the world would i? oO

[Galzria]

I'm not a big fan of the fact that LaLight supports the idea that scum were the ones responsible for "derailing" the Reggie wagon, regardless of Reggie's alignment - but when asked specifically about the 4 (only FOUR!) people to have left the wagon he doesn't have strong reads on any of them.

It feels... fabricated.

Actually. Vote: LaLight. His responses just don't ring genuine to me.

[O]

for me personally You and Faust seem scummy as all hell every time you two post but I think it might just be playstyle choices.

I'd probably lynch either of you before J Reggie but after Awaclus

"you" being me or Galz?

You being you, LaLight, sorry.

Galz is slightly scummy but mostly neutral to me

Why after Awaclus? OMGUS? What exactly don't you like about him?

I voted for him first. That said

1. Policy lynch
2. He's posted literally no content.
3. You seem to think that letting "post no content and singularly focus on one person" is a town-read when its literally the easiest thing in the world to fabricate.

[O]

if Eevee will hop on my Awaclus wagon i'll stay there, otherwise I'm going to join Galzria on the LaLight wagon.

[Galzria]

I'm not a big fan of the fact that LaLight supports the idea that scum were the ones responsible for "derailing" the Reggie wagon, regardless of Reggie's alignment - but when asked specifically about the 4 (only FOUR!) people to have left the wagon he doesn't have strong reads on any of them.

It feels... fabricated.

I don't have strong reads on anyone, how in the world would i? oO

I would think with your belief that scum derailed that wagon would lead you to have a somewhat shady view of the small pool of people who got off the wagon (4 of us). It hasn't though. That strikes me as rather odd. Like you've made a statement of idea (scum bailed), but haven't really thought it through.  I dunno. Just doesn't feel right.

[pingpongsam]

I'm not a big fan of the fact that LaLight supports the idea that scum were the ones responsible for "derailing" the Reggie wagon, regardless of Reggie's alignment - but when asked specifically about the 4 (only FOUR!) people to have left the wagon he doesn't have strong reads on any of them.

It feels... fabricated.

Actually. Vote: LaLight. His responses just don't ring genuine to me.

Vote: LaLaight

For all those reasons but the zinger was all the 4 who got off the wagon were scum smear reads. There's some anti-confirmation bias here as all the ones he named and painted scum were slight town reads for me.

[LaLight]

I'm not a big fan of the fact that LaLight supports the idea that scum were the ones responsible for "derailing" the Reggie wagon, regardless of Reggie's alignment - but when asked specifically about the 4 (only FOUR!) people to have left the wagon he doesn't have strong reads on any of them.

It feels... fabricated.

I don't have strong reads on anyone, how in the world would i? oO

I would think with your belief that scum derailed that wagon would lead you to have a somewhat shady view of the small pool of people who got off the wagon (4 of us). It hasn't though. That strikes me as rather odd. Like you've made a statement of idea (scum bailed), but haven't really thought it through.  I dunno. Just doesn't feel right.

Again, imo it feels like J Reggie is scum, not all 4 of you. I mean, yeah, unregarding the alignment some of you are scum in my opinion. But he's just more scummy. After the flip it will be easier to analyze you 4 to see who exactly is scum among you

In a nutshell, you all are scummy, but J Reggie is also scummy, more than any of you. I can't spread my vote out to everyone I think scummy, I need to vote one person

[Galzria]

if Eevee will hop on my Awaclus wagon i'll stay there, otherwise I'm going to join Galzria on the LaLight wagon.

Can I get some detail on that wagon? And why Eevee specifically if I may ask?

[pingpongsam]

if Eevee will hop on my Awaclus wagon i'll stay there, otherwise I'm going to join Galzria on the LaLight wagon.

Can I get some detail on that wagon? And why Eevee specifically if I may ask?

That's easy. It's a clash of personalities wagon.

[O]

if Eevee will hop on my Awaclus wagon i'll stay there, otherwise I'm going to join Galzria on the LaLight wagon.

Can I get some detail on that wagon? And why Eevee specifically if I may ask?

Eevee just posted pointing out Awaclus's behavior before I could. it's not really him specifically.

The details are in the 30s pages but the short of it is that he's quite rude and even more unhelpful, which is ridiculous to have as a "town read" by LaLight and others when all he's done is OMGUS me and poorly argue semantic points that aren't "logical" while pretending that everyone else is doing "pseudoscience".

[Galzria]

quite rude and even more unhelpful

Exactly how I always used to feel about you!

I'll look him over in detail when I get home.

[faust]

Eevee, if you join me on sudgy, I would be ever so happy.

What exactly do you find so scummy about me?

Your TWM read looks disingenuous, especially with referring to the "caught for the wrong reasons" thing. Like you're just making up reasons so that your vote doesn't look as sheepy as it really is. Then you hop on the other major wagon. No opinions beyond that. And despite all that, nobody seems interested in putting any pressure on you.

[O]

quite rude and even more unhelpful

Exactly how I always used to feel about you!

I'll look him over in detail when I get home.

i literally said this tho, you must have ignored my posts 

[Eevee]

Vote: LaLight

For reasons faust just so concisely outlined.

[faust]

I'm not a big fan of the fact that LaLight supports the idea that scum were the ones responsible for "derailing" the Reggie wagon, regardless of Reggie's alignment - but when asked specifically about the 4 (only FOUR!) people to have left the wagon he doesn't have strong reads on any of them.

It feels... fabricated.

Actually. Vote: LaLight. His responses just don't ring genuine to me.

He reads a lot more genuine to me than you do.

[O]

aight,

vote: Lalight and FOS galz for pretty clearly ignoring anything I said earlier in the game.

[faust]

Like you've made a statement of idea (scum bailed), but haven't really thought it through.  I dunno. Just doesn't feel right.

Like, is this not the exact thing town would do?

[faust]

Vote: LaLight

For reasons faust just so concisely outlined.

[faust]

Oops. My reply was lost. I meant to say:

Err... what? LaLight is town.