Rereading Dylan.
Dang it. I just reread everything twice and the only thing I come away with is a slight town read on Eevee. #105 seems like something scum would probably not say since bringing up flavor claiming is clearly not good for town. I think that was more likely confused/careless/distracted!town. Other than that, I've just seen a whole bunch of null. At one time I had a reason for voting for Jimmmmm, but I've since forgotten what it was and couldn't remember on the reread. I didn't see anything that made me want to move it now though.
If I had to pick someone to be suspicious of, right now it might be LL for the joke/not joke thing, although for unspeakable reasons I'm not putting much stock in that; and I might be a freckle suspicious of harbinger, purely for openly suggesting ignoring evidence prior to better evidence being available. Once better evidence is there, yeah, I agree with his logic, but until it shows up, just discarding it because "all the other clues will probably overshadow it" isn't the best idea. This isn't really enough for me to scum!read them yet; it's just enough to read them closely.
I thought and think this post is quite Towny, particularly "At one time I had a reason for voting for Jimmmmm, but I've since forgotten what it was and couldn't remember on the reread." It strikes me as a Town train of thought that could be difficult to replicate as scum. However Dylan was immediately (well you know, 6 hours later) voted for for this post:
vote: Dylan
Why? For trying?
The emotion in that post doesn't seem genuine. It seems too over the top.
This seems strange. The extent of the emotion I can find in the post is "Dang it." But then Dylan apologises for it.
Sorry. The disappointment expressed in that post sort of bled through from other events, not this particular game.
Nothing else really stands out except gkrieg's certainty of his scum read on him. Which would lead me to wanting to reread gkrieg, but his Townslip was pretty convincing.
I think Dylan is Town. I'll look elsewhere.