Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[IDontPlayThisGame]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

This seems awful. If we follow your plan (and Joseph is telling the truth) we don't lynch him today, scum NKs someone else, and we mislynch him tomorrow.

[Roadrunner7671]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

No! Think about that for a second.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

From the few historical games I read a lurker lynch ended up being pretty random. I would be more inclined to go for RR (he had some stuff in the past that I found suspicious) or Robz if we are choosing to keep Joseph alive.

And I don't like if/then statements. I feel like they are too easy for mafia to manipulate.

[Roadrunner7671]

I would be more inclined to go for RR (he had some stuff in the past that I found suspicious)

Oh yeah, we've never played before! I play differently, and I used to get lynched a bunch for it because different = scummy. I've grown a bit as a player, but mostly I can get away with weird stuff because I'm RR. Sort of like Joseph, except less extreme.

[IDontPlayThisGame]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

From the few historical games I read a lurker lynch ended up being pretty random. I would be more inclined to go for RR (he had some stuff in the past that I found suspicious) or Robz if we are choosing to keep Joseph alive.

And I don't like if/then statements. I feel like they are too easy for mafia to manipulate.

This is my third game and all three have been with both Jake and RR. In the previous two, they both seemed really scummy and they were both town.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

From the few historical games I read a lurker lynch ended up being pretty random. I would be more inclined to go for RR (he had some stuff in the past that I found suspicious) or Robz if we are choosing to keep Joseph alive.

And I don't like if/then statements. I feel like they are too easy for mafia to manipulate.

This is my third game and all three have been with both Jake and RR. In the previous two, they both seemed really scummy and they were both town.

I'm always town but seriously for all the people who think my idea is terrible or don't want to lynch Joseph, Then who? Make some cases on others so we have a actual lynch pool. I'll make one for one of my preferred lynch's. Mcmc is total lurker and should be lynched. He hasn't posted in almost 3 days. Come on lurkers shouldn't get a pass.

[Calamitas]

Can someone unvote Joseph please, this L-1 is insanity.

[Robz888]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

From the few historical games I read a lurker lynch ended up being pretty random. I would be more inclined to go for RR (he had some stuff in the past that I found suspicious) or Robz if we are choosing to keep Joseph alive.

And I don't like if/then statements. I feel like they are too easy for mafia to manipulate.

This is my third game and all three have been with both Jake and RR. In the previous two, they both seemed really scummy and they were both town.

Maybe my perspective is warped because my first experience with Jake was in 87, where he acted just as crazy has he's acted in every subsequent game, and he was scum.

[Roadrunner7671]

Make some cases on others so we have a actual lynch pool.

You can do this if you want!

[EFHW]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

From the few historical games I read a lurker lynch ended up being pretty random. I would be more inclined to go for RR (he had some stuff in the past that I found suspicious) or Robz if we are choosing to keep Joseph alive.

And I don't like if/then statements. I feel like they are too easy for mafia to manipulate.

Why Robz?

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Make some cases on others so we have a actual lynch pool.

You can do this if you want!

There are cases on my strongest lynch candidates how about you make one Calm if you don't want a Joseph lynch that bad?

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

From the few historical games I read a lurker lynch ended up being pretty random. I would be more inclined to go for RR (he had some stuff in the past that I found suspicious) or Robz if we are choosing to keep Joseph alive.

And I don't like if/then statements. I feel like they are too easy for mafia to manipulate.

This is my third game and all three have been with both Jake and RR. In the previous two, they both seemed really scummy and they were both town.

Maybe my perspective is warped because my first experience with Jake was in 87, where he acted just as crazy has he's acted in every subsequent game, and he was scum.

I think I acted crazier that game.

[Roadrunner7671]

Make some cases on others so we have a actual lynch pool.

You can do this if you want!

There are cases on my strongest lynch candidates how about you make one Calm if you don't want a Joseph lynch that bad?

Here's a case: Due to the fact that no one counterclaimed Joseph, he is an IC.

[Calamitas]

Make some cases on others so we have a actual lynch pool.

You can do this if you want!

There are cases on my strongest lynch candidates how about you make one Calm if you don't want a Joseph lynch that bad?

Here's a case: Due to the fact that no one counterclaimed Joseph, he is an IC.

Not IC but pretty pretty close to it, certainly enough to not bot lynch him today!

[Roadrunner7671]

Make some cases on others so we have a actual lynch pool.

You can do this if you want!

There are cases on my strongest lynch candidates how about you make one Calm if you don't want a Joseph lynch that bad?

Here's a case: Due to the fact that no one counterclaimed Joseph, he is an IC.

Not IC but pretty pretty close to it, certainly enough to not bot lynch him today!

Sure, not an IC because of Mason stuff.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

From the few historical games I read a lurker lynch ended up being pretty random. I would be more inclined to go for RR (he had some stuff in the past that I found suspicious) or Robz if we are choosing to keep Joseph alive.

And I don't like if/then statements. I feel like they are too easy for mafia to manipulate.

Why Robz?

It was revealed that Robz had pushed for and achieved a lynch on a claimed PR Day1 previously as mafia in M88.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Sorry M89

I refuse to lynch Joseph without a counterclaim. Like I would hope that I died in the night if that happened so I didn't have to talk again about how horrible of a lynch it would be.

Why would it be so horrible?

Well because right now he should be IC. And switching the UB to an IC isn't that bad. There is also a chance that a PR dies that he could inherit. We lynched Jake in a game a few games ago when he was a vanilla cop and we shouldn't have. Actually Robz had the same argument that game as well

Can you source that game?

Looks like M89 is the one you were referring to. Robz was scum that game.

[faust]

faust: Why did you vote Robz?

I wanted to vote for someone who is not Joseph, and Robz hadn't been townie.

[faust]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

From the few historical games I read a lurker lynch ended up being pretty random. I would be more inclined to go for RR (he had some stuff in the past that I found suspicious) or Robz if we are choosing to keep Joseph alive.

And I don't like if/then statements. I feel like they are too easy for mafia to manipulate.

The issue with lurker lynches: Yes they are somewhat random. But they will still be somewhat random on D2, D3 etc., since lurkers won't give much to determine their alignment. It's better to have active players in the game that can be read. A lurker is always a blank and needs to be lynched at some point unless the game goes really well.

[faust]

And vote: Robz again.

I cannot imagine this sentiment (lynching a claimed UB without counterclaim) coming from town!Robz unless he is UB or Mason.

[Joseph2302]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

This seems awful. If we follow your plan (and Joseph is telling the truth) we don't lynch him today, scum NKs someone else, and we mislynch him tomorrow.

[Joseph2302]

Vote: Jake

You have been yelling at people all game for voting me saying it was a easy mislynch but then you vote me when your backed into a corner trying to find some one else to lynch so you survive... OK

You're so insistent on such a bad lynch (wanting to lynch an uncontested PR), that screams scummy to me.

[Awaclus]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

I have been posting actively.

[Calamitas]

And vote: Robz again.

I cannot imagine this sentiment (lynching a claimed UB without counterclaim) coming from town!Robz unless he is UB or Mason.

I agree, but I still not see a narrative that makes sense for robz. If he is actually a UB he is going to get killed due to his behavior anyways, in that regard it's identical to a claim. If we actually lynch Joseph and he flips town, robz is going to be under heaviest suspicion. Neither scum!robz nor non-mason/UB!robz would want that.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

How about this. We don't lynch Joseph today but if he's still alive tomorrow we lynch him. If he dies during the night the n we know he was being truthful. Does that satisfy everyone? If so who are possible D-1 lynchs for us. I say one of the lurkers like Mcmc or Awa

From the few historical games I read a lurker lynch ended up being pretty random. I would be more inclined to go for RR (he had some stuff in the past that I found suspicious) or Robz if we are choosing to keep Joseph alive.

And I don't like if/then statements. I feel like they are too easy for mafia to manipulate.

The issue with lurker lynches: Yes they are somewhat random. But they will still be somewhat random on D2, D3 etc., since lurkers won't give much to determine their alignment. It's better to have active players in the game that can be read. A lurker is always a blank and needs to be lynched at some point unless the game goes really well.

Yeah. That makes sense. I guess my supposition was based on the idea that the players were inactive or lurking for a short period of time and would become active at a later date, especially with much of this game taking place during the western holiday season.

I happen to have been able to be more active because of the holidays, but that is because I was mostly sitting at home in warm pajamas next to a heater alternatively drinking coffee and cider. But sadly , that lurxury is coming to an end.