Will reread Dylan because he's the person I did not yet reread.
gkrieg honestly scares me because he plays such a good town game that I really want him alive, but I just know the game I decide to not be suspicious of him and fully trust him will be the one that he is scum and it bites me in the butt. would not lynch today.
First post. This is interesting in that it offers an explanation for gkrieg's kill. But I think many players would kill gkrieg, so meh.
Notably, he does not give any reads on players who are still alive now in that post. That's slightly towny; scum usually feels compelled to have an opinion on their partner.
Defends Jake a fair bit. White knighting? Maybe. Considering that the main lynch alternatives were all townies, not even unlikely. In his last D1 post, he states that he's more not willing to vote for Jake out of sympathy. Town points for that.
On D2, starts out pushing a Calamitas case.
Calamitas/idptg team seems legit.
What about IDPTG makes you think he's the other half of the scum team?
Intruiging. It's not easy asking a question like that about your partner. So that makes Dylan/Idplay less likely.
I don't like his insistence on "I would have voted Jake if given the time", which reads a bit like "I'm caught for the wrong reasons!" Scum points are due here.
This post is lenghty and I won't quote, but it reads towny to me.
Also IDPTG, I'm glad someone has been following my logic so far, but as a matter of improving your play, just because someone is saying what you are thinking doesn't always mean they are town. It can help you clarify your reads sometimes, but sometimes scum will overly agree with you or take sensible stances that you agree with just to get you on their side to help prevent wagons on them. I've been duped by scum who was doing that before and it sucks, so in the future maybe don't use that as your sole reason for town reading someone.
This is interesting. I find it somewhat unlikely that Dylan would give out advice on how to form reads to his partner in the game threads. Further detracting from a Dylan/Idplay team.
Also notable in this post is that a couple of reads are given, but Joseph is just stuck into the scum-to-town list witout explanation. Not sure what that means.
Although, having said that, I guess the two of the vets still alive weren't on the wagon, so Joseph and faust's just slid a little bit in my book. Also, was anyone on the wagon besides Jake himself technically a newb?
LaLight, what about Joseph always looks scummy and what has he done to look towny to you?
unvote because I'm actually not sure if I'd rather lynch Joseph or Calamitas now.
This is an important point during D2. Dylan has been solidly pushing Calamatis for most of the day, now he's backing off and considering Joseph. Will he you for it? The suspense...
Well, the only two newbs that were off wagon were IDPTG and myself, and I already told you why I wasn't on it. If I remember correctly IDPTG also logged in before the deadline and but after the hammer, so I assume their reasoning would be pretty much the same. Of course I'm still not sure IDPTG is town, so it is technically possible for you to be right if IDPTG is actually scum.
That's not that important in terms of reads, but it is somewhat unlikely for both scum to be off the Jake wagon. I mean that thing he did may have been considered a scumslipped, but the people on Jake were already voting for Jake before that, so I except a scum there.
Yeah, I would have let you hammer if the case on Joseph hadn't become so interesting. I think I would rather vote: Joseph than Calamitas for today.
Dylan moves from Calamitas to Joseph, putting them at L-1. The question is, did he decide to bus? It seems possible. At least I never see a real reason for why Joseph is suddenly more scummy than Calamitas. On the other hand, I feel that scum may be afraid of bussing with both PRs still around.
Ok, so my lynch pool for today is either Calamitas or Joseph. I think there's a pretty good chance one of them is scum, but at this point I'm not sure which one actually is. I would consider IDPTG, but I do believe their reason for being inactive so I really don't want to see us mislynch due to inactivity when there are better options anyway.
So I don't like the treatment of Idplay in this... but still, there have been instances earlier that make me think this is not the team.
Also, I'm not sure that scum would threaten to never play again if they are lynched. Maybe, but this seems like real frustrated!town. Vote: Calamitas This is L-1 I think.
And Dylan backs off Joseph again. Actually I think Dylan is rather towny in this. But it's a reasonable move for Joseph's partner; just not sure Dylan could pull it off.
So overall I still feel mild town on Dylan, and partners would be Joseph > Idplay.
Author
Topic: Newbie Mafia 9: Grown-up Mafia (Game Over!) (Read 121853 times)