Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[EFHW]

In the Neighborhood, teamlyle said he was a Vanilla Sidekick and then seemed to say he didn't know what that was.  The wiki gives a couple different meanings to sidekick, but both involve targeting.  Not sure how they go with Vanilla or what gkrieg intended by the name, but perhaps teamlyle should clarify.  Sidekick is also a superhero term, like Batman and his sidekick Robin, so maybe it's just flavor.

[faust]

The other flavor names so far haven't been very close to offcial nomenclature, so it might be just flavor. It's kinda specific though.

[EFHW]

How do you know teamlyle does not have a targeting role?  I haven't finished my reread, so maybe I missed something.

He claimed it.

It's still strange that Haddock would accept that claim as fact.

[faust]

How do you know teamlyle does not have a targeting role?  I haven't finished my reread, so maybe I missed something.

He claimed it.

It's still strange that Haddock would accept that claim as fact.

Well there's some flavor stuff going on and Seprix said he has confirmation that teamlyle is town.

[faust]

EFHW: How open are you to lynching someone who isn't J Reggie or Haddock?

[EFHW]

How do you know teamlyle does not have a targeting role?  I haven't finished my reread, so maybe I missed something.

He claimed it.

It's still strange that Haddock would accept that claim as fact.

Well there's some flavor stuff going on and Seprix said he has confirmation that teamlyle is town.

I don't have the impression that teamlyle has been considered an IC.

[EFHW]

EFHW: How open are you to lynching someone who isn't J Reggie or Haddock?

Who do you have in mind? 

Haddock set up the "it's him or me today" thing.  I don't think that's necessarily so.

[J Reggie]

EFHW: How open are you to lynching someone who isn't J Reggie or Haddock?

Who do you have in mind? 

Haddock set up the "it's him or me today" thing.  I don't think that's necessarily so.

I mean, it's possible that you or teamlyle targeted those people. If it was you you would know and would probably be getting to get a mislynch through. I strongly doubt it's teamlyle.

[faust]

EFHW: How open are you to lynching someone who isn't J Reggie or Haddock?

Who do you have in mind? 

Haddock set up the "it's him or me today" thing.  I don't think that's necessarily so.

Not sure. Just let the thing sort itself out. I think silver and iguana are worth investigating. My strongest scumread is Cellovix.

[faust]

I think I'm voting iguana? Yeah, that is mostly me being pissed. But he did somehow not get lynched that last day, and we lynch town instead.

But Vote: Cellovix is still something I'm more comfortable with.

[EFHW]

Oh, you have "magic" you want to do.  What makes that better than lynching him to find out if he's scum?

PPE: Cellovix is a strong townread for me!  She (?) has been scumhunting more than anyone, though I guess not around much recently.  Iguana looks totally scummy, but he also said he's not taking the game seriously, so is he daring enough to do that so blatantly as scum? I could go either way on silver.

[EFHW]

faust, you seem very reluctant to lynch Haddock.

[silverspawn]

Lynching outside of Haddock and J Reggie seems pretty unintelligent to me.

[J Reggie]

I think I'm voting iguana? Yeah, that is mostly me being pissed. But he did somehow not get lynched that last day, and we lynch town instead.

But Vote: Cellovix is still something I'm more comfortable with.

This makes sense to me. You don't want to be on my wagon since I will be IC if haddock flips scum or if I flip town. And you don't want to bus. That's why you're pushing a lynch that's not me or haddock. I strongly doubt the existence of this magic.

[faust]

Oh, you have "magic" you want to do.  What makes that better than lynching him to find out if he's scum?

PPE: Cellovix is a strong townread for me!  She (?) has been scumhunting more than anyone, though I guess not around much recently.  Iguana looks totally scummy, but he also said he's not taking the game seriously, so is he daring enough to do that so blatantly as scum? I could go either way on silver.

Cannot say. Sorry. It will be clear tomorrow, if it works.

The townread on Cellovix is interesting. I admit that I may have been lead by confirmation bias in that case. But he was scummy with his Jan interactions IIRC.

[faust]

faust, you seem very reluctant to lynch Haddock.

Yes. It's just, if Haddock is scum, then what I can do is much better than lynching one of the two now.

[faust]

I think I'm voting iguana? Yeah, that is mostly me being pissed. But he did somehow not get lynched that last day, and we lynch town instead.

But Vote: Cellovix is still something I'm more comfortable with.

This makes sense to me. You don't want to be on my wagon since I will be IC if haddock flips scum or if I flip town. And you don't want to bus. That's why you're pushing a lynch that's not me or haddock. I strongly doubt the existence of this magic.

Right. Because outing myself and Haddock as scum is such a clever move, especially if there's a Serial Killer prancing about.

[EFHW]

faust, you seem very reluctant to lynch Haddock.

Yes. It's just, if Haddock is scum, then what I can do is much better than lynching one of the two now.

Even if you are nk'd, roleblocked or redirected?

[faust]

Lynching outside of Haddock and J Reggie seems pretty unintelligent to me.

But why? Like, this is RMM. Even if you don't believe me, it's pretty likely that someone can do something that will give us more to work with tomorrow.

[faust]

faust, you seem very reluctant to lynch Haddock.

Yes. It's just, if Haddock is scum, then what I can do is much better than lynching one of the two now.

Even if you are nk'd, roleblocked or redirected?

There are scenarios where it might not work. But if it does not work, then you'll know. And frankly it might be best if scum just kills me off and I don't have to do the "How is it that faust is still alive?" dance. How is it that silver is still alive? Noone ever seems to ask that.

[silverspawn]

Lynching outside of Haddock and J Reggie seems pretty unintelligent to me.

But why? Like, this is RMM. Even if you don't believe me, it's pretty likely that someone can do something that will give us more to work with tomorrow.

the evidence seems too clear for a delay to be worth it. like, why would you even survive the night?

[faust]

Lynching outside of Haddock and J Reggie seems pretty unintelligent to me.

But why? Like, this is RMM. Even if you don't believe me, it's pretty likely that someone can do something that will give us more to work with tomorrow.

the evidence seems too clear for a delay to be worth it. like, why would you even survive the night?

Plusses if I don't. Saves you from a stupid mislynch.

[silverspawn]

also your information isn't even valuable, because, unless we hit another scum now, we're at super LyLo tomorrow, so we can't rely on your word anyway. So even if you are town, can do magic, and don't die, still meh.

[EFHW]

I disagree.  Scum could interfere with you to try to frame town!Haddock.  They will certainly interfere to protect scum!Haddock, so now that you have said you have magic, you are not likely to get to use it on Haddock.  He's the best lynch candidate we have, and lynching someone else who is a weaker case doesn't seem good.

[EFHW]

Disagree with faust, agree with silver.