I don't really know what to make of my strongest scum read protecting my second strongest scum read. If they're both off the table, I don't have anyone I really want to lynch. Maybe Faust or Fontisian, but they aren't actually scum reads, just not as strongly town as some others.
I think my inclination is to distrust it, because it's too similar to the Seprix/Teamlyle thing where Seprix softed that Lyle is town. I could see it being a desperation play where Haddock/JReggie are scum, and they feel the need to swing for the fences, maybe.
If Haddock is town, JReggie is probably always town here unless Haddock is misinterpreting his information, which seems unlikely.
If Haddock is scum, JReggie is almost certainly scum, because it'd mean Haddock was trying to save one of his easiest mislynches.
The scenarios where they are opposite alignments seem pretty unlikely at first glance, regardless of which direction it is in. Can someone logic check me there?