tl;dr
vote: iguanaiguanaSo now, once I have convinced you all that I am town, we will need an alternate wagon to explore. Let me look around at those alternate wagon's before I convince you that I am town. To do that, let's look at my very own wagon since I hope there is at least one scum on it: silverspawn, Iguanaiguana, gkrieg13, Seprix, Haddock
silverspawn - Read through and here are the highlights of what I found interesting. Has this
early vote on me because I "endorse" the scumslip argument that Reggie is making. Jokes
about not reading the setup, agrees with ADK giving him a town read, and votes gkrieg based on ADK's argument. Then
switches back to me based on the "fakehammers are townie" argument.
score: 4.3/10 - somewhat scummy. The earlier, sheepy stuff doesn't read like town!silverspawn, and voting for me because "fakehammers are townie" is fairly lazy. While I can totally see how he knee-jerk reactioned into that vote (similar to how I knee-jerked into voting for gkrieg because of the fake hammer) I think that overall silver has not been that great this game and could totally see him being scum
iguanaiguana - creates the first case one me. I mean, before the whole fakehammer incident. He voted for me first in a
vote-only post, then a while later
actually built a
little case. (
opportunistic voting) Not sure if he RVSed me then decided I was actually scummy, or always had that case in mind. Either way, seems relatively townie of him. He seems
pretty firm with his case, but then when Joseph starts doing his thing switches
right over to Joseph. After my gkrieg vote he switches
firmly back over to me and hasn't moved. He even builds a
nice little case on me.
score: 3.2/10 - His case is built around "opportunistic voting." This sounds like a great little pseudo-case that scum might try to push in order to get a lynch through while looking legit. But worse still was how he switched to Joseph then back on me. That Joseph lynch was too easy. I mean, just too easy. Jumping on Joseph arouses no suspicion, no worries. Easily explained away the next day or later. Then when the winds blew back a different (and in iguana's mind a very nice) direction it was too easy to go right back on me. I think iguana might be a good place to start looking for scum
gkrieg - Opens up nicely with some good old-fashioned RVS, then moves right into a
small little reads list. You know, the one ADK and silver found him scummy for. Well, I got town vibes from it. Votes Joseph after Joseph jokes about being scum, and sticks there for a while. Pretty intent on the lynch, I mean, he even fakehammers Joseph! He immediately votes for me after I call him out for the fakehammer, and has stuck on me without adding too much else otherwise.
score: 6.4/10 - So, that fakehammer feels more and more like town to me. Having a couple days break, thinking through all of what silverspawn has mentioned, yeah. Fakehammers are not necessarily scummy. I still don't like them. But the way he did his fakehammer and then switched right to me feels genuine enough. If Joseph ever does flip scum then we will obviously have to re-evaluate, because that fake-hammer is what dissolved (well, I guess people are still voting joseph) Joseph's wagon.
Seprix - Early defender of Joseph. Transistioning over to passionate fight to bring me down. I love it. I love the case, and think you are town for it. Nothing is more exciting than that feeling that you have caught scum. And town are usually the ones to catch that feeling. So I like a town read here on Seprix
score: 9.2/10 - genuine, heartfelt, townie.
Haddock - Is against the Joseph wagon, notices silver as slightly scummy
followed by a vote. He is tricked by gkrieg's tricksy little fakehammer here, and has some
townie posts in "twilight." He then sheeps the case against me, and generally exists without too much of a presence this game.
score: 7.0/10 - I would love to see him revisit the case against silverspawn. I could probably be persuaded to look in that direction. Has seemed generally lazy, but not scummy. More town than scum for now.