All these detailed posts are wearing me out! Rapid fire review time!
Great Cards: These cards seem balanced and will work fine in most games.
Hidden Trap, Archipelago, Hunter, Synod, Abbey, Fountain, Floodgate, College, Spellbook, Incantation, Research, Retort, Ascetic, Fund, Auction, Decree, Convoy, General, Sunken City,Barge, Dignitary, Alley, Carpenter, Stockpile, Redistrict, Search Party, Vendor, Crop Rotation, Assemble, Ghost Town.
Good Cards: Balanced, but need some cosmetic changes or better wording.
Vizer (off-color border), Castle, (off-color border), Emissary (if the game ends on another player's turn), Arcanium (thicken line), Battlefield (renamed skirmish, clarification for ties),Fief (gain the attack subtype), Catacombs (rename caverns), Scriptorium, (drop the "from the supply" clause)
Okay Cards: Need slight changes or adjustments.
Jeweler (Cost 6), Suq (Change the treasure top decking to -1 coin token), Shaman (change top of deck to shuffle in, Elixir (Cost 2P, potion gaining mandatory), Warlord (Discard down to 3 cards), Surprise Attack (Drop the "Discard It" phrase), Keep (Drop the discarding, set aside cards other than durations), Recruiter (Bold +1 action, drop +action from first choice, remove line, change bottom phrase to "If you have two other attacks in play"), Sentinel (+3 cards, put any number on top of deck), Patron (Increase value of any or all coin symbols, add a "while it is in play" clause.), Mining Camp (Gain silver if you didn't gain a ruins), Excommunication (Drop the +buy, cost 2), Harlot (Cost 3), Escalation (Cost 3, trash for reaction), Suburb (Drop the +coin), Hospital (Add "When you gain this, put three victory or curse cards from your discard pile on top of your deck), Gold rush (Add cost reduction cap of -1), Monastery (draw to 5 or until you have drawn 2 cards), Sheriff (Only give +1 coin if you spent a token)
Bad Cards: Wouldn't play with these, need serious fixes.
Battle Strategy, Cloister, Royal Demesne, Harbinger, Draw-to-X Villages.
Phew! If you need a detailed explanation of my reasoning or a link to the source thread feel free to ask!