As for the game...
vote: reinoe
I have a longstanding "don't lynch new players on D1" rule, but I'm willing to waive that here. Why?
1) He's crying wolf at the top of his lungs. Some choice bits include "he's claimed scum" and "he's done zero scum hunting" as undeniable truths about TA. These are disingenuous at the least and overtly hostile at worst.
2) He's being purposefully obtuse. Acting as if he didnt understand what TA and others meant about the neighborhood, utility, scum knowledge, etc. He's obsfucating.
3) The early, unprovoked, unneeded, useless claim. All of those adjectives are why scum wants to pull off that claim and why town wouldn't do it recklessly. It was completely safe, give town zero useful knowledge, and could seemingly buy the claimant town cred.
4) Overt hostility for (seemingly) no reason.
Why those specific things? He actually reminds me of me in my earlier scum days. I've successfully railroaded town into turning against each other by doing all of those things. It got to the point where a longtime mod/player/pal here on f.ds accused me of trying to break people to the point of /outing from the game to have less town players to mislynch. (I wasn't.)
tldr: Everything I noted about reinoe's play is what I expect from an aggressive scum style.