Vote: Faust. This needs to happen.
Axxel's right. It must be Axxel and faust, or faust/arch. Either way Faust is going to be scum. We need to kill him first.
We lynch faust, he turns up scum either way.
Now the question is Axxel or Arch tomorrow. That's the new LyLo scenario.
If arch is alive tomorrow, he's scum. Scum!Axxel would kill arch because he'd be able to use timid sensor to figure out if he's scum. Scum!Arch obviously couldn't.
So if arch dies, then it's EFHW, me, and Axxel. We'll lynch Axxel.
If Axxel dies, it's EFHW, me, Arch. We lynch him.
Looking at it again, this post really gives me the heebie jeebies. DeDe is implicitly assuming
A) There is a 2-player scum team.
B) Axxle and Archetype can't be in the same team.
Assumption A is just completely baseless. All we know is that we had only one kill. There are multiple explanations for this. Either mafia targeted Archetype (okay, I guess from DeDe's point of view, this would mean that I am scum), or mafia targeted the SK (or someone else, for that matter), who is bulletproof. Why must there be a three-person team?
Assumption B is equally problematic, as I already laid out. There is no reason to believe that Axxle and Arch can't be on the same team.
Dude, this is just wrong. You're OMGUS attitude also makes me
Vote: Faust. You are 100% scum.
So, two scenarios. Axxel is scum, or he's not.
So let's say he's town, then you and arch are scum. You're partners too, otherwise Arch. would have rolled with a kill on you.
Arch: You know you're town, I'm guessing, which leaves us with Faust and Axxel being scum.
I doubt that mafia or a SK had redirecting since WW had nexus. That's really a moot point either way. We can't prove anything. Logically, in most scenarios, you're scum.
So let's say he's scum and you're not lying. Then he has to be a SK or mafia with arch. He can't be part of a three person mafia because of flavour.
So he's either partners with Arch or he's a SK.
He can't be partners with Arch. Arch would have rolled with his read on you and got you lynched. Plus, why would Axxel be the largest proponent of a two-person mafia team? That simply doesn't make sense, especially when the more general consensus was a SK. And why would Arch lie and then tell of his lie? This just doesn't seem like a true scenario.
So Axxel is the SK. Sweetness. That leaves mafia to you or arch. Again, if arch was mafia he would have just rolled on his read for you. Doesn't make much sense.
That leaves you being mafia. You thought you'd get a lynch on the SK then be free to kill tonight, get it down to 2-1 tomorrow and then hope for the best.
Now you may have a mafia PR of 1-shot lynchproof or something like this, because then it would be perfect to lynch axxel, get your kill and win.
Vote: Faust. This needs to happen.
Axxel's right. It must be Axxel and faust, or faust/arch. Either way Faust is going to be scum. We need to kill him first.
We lynch faust, he turns up scum either way.
Now the question is Axxel or Arch tomorrow. That's the new LyLo scenario.
If arch is alive tomorrow, he's scum. Scum!Axxel would kill arch because he'd be able to use timid sensor to figure out if he's scum. Scum!Arch obviously couldn't.
So if arch dies, then it's EFHW, me, and Axxel. We'll lynch Axxel.
If Axxel dies, it's EFHW, me, Arch. We lynch him.
What exactly excludes an Axxle/Arch scumteam? That Arch didn't claim to have investigated me? But I had already claimed my result on Axxle, and maybe Arch thought I would be believed over him. Plus, Arch needed a convincing narrative to explain why he's still alive if he's going to claim I am scum.
Note that Arch in fact DID claim he sensored me, only to make a turnaround later.
This is pretty flimsy. He could have said you killed Andrew, and you're honest about axxel. Then you'd be dead and his narrative still works.
I'm secure in this vote. Let's how this plays out.