joth's unannounced L-1 vote seems scummy prima facie, but I actually think it reads relatively towny to me--especially at this point in the game it's more likely that town is going to be cavalier with their vote like that, while I'm sure scum is watching the count like a hawk. Seems genuine enough so far.
First, laconic? That's a new one. Second, though I obviously disagree with you about myself, I agree about joth's towniness for the same reasons you state.
But we'll see once they've given me something a little meatier to work with.
(insert topical Arrested Development quote here--I need to rewatch it so I have some zingers readily at my disposal lol)
You can just taste those meaty leading posters parts right now.
By laconic I mean that I'm feeling now like you've been posting like "Yes", "No", "All in good time", while normally I think your posts are longer and more developed. Maybe you're just trying to be sagacious, or maybe there's something you're not telling us. Other more recent posts like "You are correct, I have not" give me the same vibe.
Nice alley oop on the AD reference though haha
I agree with jo though that ash's post on Volt does seem like a stretch. I know it's just D1 speculation, but it's exactly that--D1 speculation. There's not a whole lot of definitive information to extract or deduce right now, and ash's confidence here makes me a little uncomfortable. He could be totally purloined letter-ing with two D1 claim scum games in a row.
More towny feelings from jo and Eevee. I agree jo that I think ash was misrepresenting you.
faust's vote on jo strikes me as weird, possibly scummy?
And I would love to hear more from xeiron, and especially Archetype and EFHW. Scum could be feeling very comfortable lurking along right now. Either way, I'll need something more from you guys to make a judgment. I knooooow I'm pretty lurky too, but I try to make each of my posts count for something.
So I guess where I stand right now is
vote: Voltaire, and OK with an ash lynch too. Next preference would possibly be faust, or maybe one of the lurkoids--I don't want to fall into the pattern yuma cautioned against in that one game, of biasing people as scummy just because they've been more active.