Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[chairs]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

[sudgy]

sudgy, what even gave you the idea to do it before discussing it? vote: sudgy

I thought it would solve the "should we song claim or not" by seeing some pros and cons before we do it.  I still don't think it will out any PRs.

[A Drowned Kernel]

I plan to play reasonable this game btw

back to vote: WW for voting for Eevee

"I plan to play reasonably"

votes three times in three posts

[A Drowned Kernel]

I have trouble coming up with a song that I would consider related to VT.

[A Drowned Kernel]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

vote: chairs while I don't think I like any claiming plan, I don't think sudgy's scummy for suggesting it.

[Teproc]

I plan to play reasonable this game btw

back to vote: WW for voting for Eevee

"I plan to play reasonably"

votes three times in three posts

Voting a lot early is good for town, as long as the are serious votes.

[sudgy]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

Vote: chairs for trying to start a wagon on me.

[Teproc]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

Vote: chairs for trying to start a wagon on me.

Why is that scummy ?

[silverspawn]

I plan to play reasonable this game btw

back to vote: WW for voting for Eevee

"I plan to play reasonably"

votes three times in three posts

throwing votes around in the beginning of a game is totally nothing special/impactful/unreasonable. I'm talking about stuff like early claims, refusing to contribute, self votes, etc

[silverspawn]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

vote: chairs while I don't think I like any claiming plan, I don't think sudgy's scummy for suggesting it.

I also voted for sudgy for that. did you just look for a reason to vote for someone?

vote: ADK

[Witherweaver]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

I don't think scum would actually propose an anti-town plan like that. 

[A Drowned Kernel]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

vote: chairs while I don't think I like any claiming plan, I don't think sudgy's scummy for suggesting it.

I also voted for sudgy for that. did you just look for a reason to vote for someone?

vote: ADK

Yes I am looking for reasons to vote for people, it's how this game works? The votes on sudgy seem a little reactionary to me, and chairs looked like he wanted an easy wagon to jump on, so I voted for him.

[Teproc]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

I don't think scum would actually propose an anti-town plan like that. 

Meh. I think it's slightly townie to propose horrible claims, but it's not a very strong indicator to me.

[sudgy]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

vote: chairs while I don't think I like any claiming plan, I don't think sudgy's scummy for suggesting it.

I also voted for sudgy for that. did you just look for a reason to vote for someone?

vote: ADK

For me, chairs' vote was the most scummy because it started getting into wagon territory, while the others were just votes.

[Teproc]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

vote: chairs while I don't think I like any claiming plan, I don't think sudgy's scummy for suggesting it.

I also voted for sudgy for that. did you just look for a reason to vote for someone?

vote: ADK

For me, chairs' vote was the most scummy because it started getting into wagon territory, while the others were just votes.

That still doesn't answer my question : why is that (starting/participating in a wagon) scummy ?

[sudgy]

vote: sudgy for the aforementioned soft attempt to root out PRs.

vote: chairs while I don't think I like any claiming plan, I don't think sudgy's scummy for suggesting it.

I also voted for sudgy for that. did you just look for a reason to vote for someone?

vote: ADK

For me, chairs' vote was the most scummy because it started getting into wagon territory, while the others were just votes.

That still doesn't answer my question : why is that (starting/participating in a wagon) scummy ?

Because my wagons are always ridiculous and don't usually go anywhere.  If it was somebody else it wouldn't be nearly as scummy.

[Teproc]

Wait, what ?

Voting on a sudgy wagon is inherently scummy is what you're saying ?

What ?

[sudgy]

Wait, what ?

Voting on a sudgy wagon is inherently scummy is what you're saying ?

What ?

At the beginning, yes.  As long as you've played with me before, you know that I always get a wagon at the beginning of every game.

[Teproc]

Wait, what ?

Voting on a sudgy wagon is inherently scummy is what you're saying ?

What ?

At the beginning, yes.  As long as you've played with me before, you know that I always get a wagon at the beginning of every game.

Even if that is true (I haven't noticed but sure), the conclusion you get from that is that scum always ends up favoring sudgy wagons in every game you're in ?

[sudgy]

Wait, what ?

Voting on a sudgy wagon is inherently scummy is what you're saying ?

What ?

At the beginning, yes.  As long as you've played with me before, you know that I always get a wagon at the beginning of every game.

Even if that is true (I haven't noticed but sure), the conclusion you get from that is that scum always ends up favoring sudgy wagons in every game you're in ?

Yes, they don't usually do anything good and scum want things that don't do anything good.

Now, chairs doesn't have to be the mafia, I'm just saying he's more likely than the other players at the moment because of this.

[sudgy]

I still don't think it will out PRs, but we don't have to do it if we don't want to.

[xxpittip]

Vote: Xerxes. He still hasn't written anything since the game started.

[Hydrad]

I still don't think it will out PRs, but we don't have to do it if we don't want to.

this is kinda what I think also. But I guess I'm against it in the slight chance that it does out PR's

[silverspawn]

Wait, what ?

Voting on a sudgy wagon is inherently scummy is what you're saying ?

What ?

At the beginning, yes.  As long as you've played with me before, you know that I always get a wagon at the beginning of every game.

vote: sudgy for trying to pull himself out of the lynch pool day1.

[chairs]

I think there's a chance that it will out PRs, albeit in potentially subtle ways.

Torn between sudgy and XP now since the later is lurking.