Okay, I'm going to cut this post down to things I see as important and comment on them.
Well, POE, and I don't find manda and mcmc all that scummy, and you are more muted and less of a leader as scum, as you have been all this game.
So two reasons: PoE based on manda and mcmc not being scummy, and Voltaire's meta.
I'm not super confident on that. I'm more confident that Teproc and Voltaire ARE scum, and I really don't think manda is.
Uh... what? You're not confident that mcmc is Town, you're confident that Teproc and Voltaire are scum. Based on mcmc being Town. This is circular logic.
Voltaire, you are resorting to my scum tactic, you are trying to discredit me! See, he knows I will flip town and that will be bad for him. I have him so, so caught.
No you don't.
Walrus: Everything you just said about me correct, and if you had played more games with me, you would know this makes me town. I'm definitely all over the place, and I'm definitely exuberant.
Are we supposed to believe that scum Robz doesn't know what makes Town Robz Town, or that he's unable to replicate it?
I would point you to Day 3 (I think it's 3) of Wibbly Wobbly Mafia, which was Mafia XXIX. I certainly went a tad crazy and actually zeroed in on the town Vig to begin with, outing him. But after that I had all the puzzle pieces put together, we lynched based on my recommendations, and won (and I got my first town MVP!). This game is that game. And Voltaire was scum then and I caught him.
I'm not as sure this time, mostly because I have a lot of new meta info on Voltaire since that game, that was actually made it harder for me to read him. But intuitively, this game feels to me like that game. I mean, it shoudl and would persuade you that I'm town, if you had been in that game. Unfortunately, no one here was, except Voltaire.
We're supposed to believe you're Town based on a single Town MVP performance? You're a long way from MVP at the moment if you're Town - you vehemently supported the Morgrim lynch and vehemently opposed the ash lynch. And you're not actually sure about Voltaire, you just expect us to believe you're Town based on a game that conveniently no one else other than Volt was in?
I might support the mcmc lynch more after we hear from him, I just hate the idea of letting Teproc and Voltaire--who are very scummy--get away with this because mcmc is on vacation.
That said, there is a scum narrative for mcmc and I know I have a blind spot about him and it's better to lynch him than me. But it's best to lynch Voltaire!
You still haven't given any good reasons why Teproc and Voltaire are scummy or why it's best to lynch Voltaire. Circular, inconsistent PoE and a couple of vague meta reasons. What are we supposed to think, that scum Robz is better than this?