I would not vote MiX if he were challenged, as he has said something today that basically proves he’s town.
Can't currently think of a reason you would say this and not tell us what post you're referring to, given that scum already knows Mix's alignment.
Ok, fine.
If promoter is scum, I was either targeted (A) because MiX is town and scum thought I couldn’t resist challenging him, (B) because MiX is scum and scum thought I wouldn’t dare challenge him, or (C) because everyone has such a scumread on me that it doesn’t matter who I challenge because I’ll lose.
(C)'s the one that makes the most amount of sense here, given that if (B) then (C)'s still important in case you randomly pick another scum. This is especially true because Traitor exists. (A) sounds foolish, but given that you're thinking about (B) then (A) might actually be something scum think.
Can you tell I like those letters?
Lyncher Doctor means no jester, which is nice. Kills several theories I had yesterday about why certain people were behaving the way they were. And while losing a doctor sucks, he was realistically probably not going to be the most helpful doctor anyway. And we avoided the incredibly awkward scenario of having both him and his victim still around in LyLo. Not sure why he lied about his role though.
Bodyguard is the best fakeclaim for Lyncher, and I have no idea who wouldn't kill him after a Lyncher claim.
I support targeting MiX.
Do you think scum's thinking about (B) here?
I bolded the part above that’s relevant. Scum doesn’t make that mistaken point as they know that there is NOT, in fact, a Traitor, as we’re in BC/BD, not AD/BD - something I myself can validate as the
Town Promoter.
With Joseph’s flip, the setup is:
5 VT
Vengeful Townie
Psychologist
Tracker
Town Promoter
Semi-Elite Body Guard
Mafia Godfather
2 Mafia Goons
Lyncher Doctor
I promoted Joth last night because I believed he was scum from D1. My choices were between anybody on the horrible Joseph wagon, or one of my own scum reads. I decided it was too random to just pick one of the people on Joseph, so stuck with my gut on Joth.
If I were to pick for Joth, I would make him choose between {ADK, Faust, Glooble}.