Here's the promised reread:
Voltaire
Well, there's lots of VLA going on. But still, when he was available, he was very active. Had a small fight with Robz, which is null to me. Disagreed with me on theory stuff. Posted his lynch pool before he left, which - as ashersky pointed out - felt a little different than his usual lynch pools. Wasn't around when all the e stuff went down. I think town!Voltaire would be a strong asset for us, so we don't want to lynch him just because of VLA. He's out of my lynch pool for today, barring further developments.
Robz
First thing is disagreeing with me, the IC status thing, and the Jimmmmm vote. All of which fits in a town narrative for me, but could also be scum. Strange to claim that he didn't really read the setup, which is what I expect from a player like Robz and therefore gives some scum points. Then the fight with Voltaire, including a rage vote... this could certainly be faked, still I know that Voltaire and Robz don't get along well. Then, during the e discussion, Robz finds him scummy, but doesn't vote because he finds others scummier. This seems strange to me, because if you find someone scummy and there's a wagon on them, wouldn't you join regardless? He also helps distracting by joking with e. Joined the Jorbles wagon with little explanation later. Lastly, saying my post about hunting off-wagon scum was "good thinking" while suspecting two on-wagon players. Overall I get a scummy feel here.
Jimmmmm
First of all, I don't think his initial exchange with Robz regarding IC status is scummy. Much VLA following. Votes mcmc. Makes a point that speaks against e being scum. Later states he does not support an e lynch. Starts the Jorbles wagon. Later finds it suspicious how fast the Jorbles wagon grew. I don't see specifically scummy behaviour in Jimmmmm's posts overall. He's null to slight town to me.
manda
Agrees with Robz on that my plan is dangerous. Then also VLA. Doesn't think e is super scummy, even though she criticizes the D1 passes. Joins the Jorbles wagon without finding him scummy. I lean scummy on manda right now.
Teproc
Also agrees with Robz' initial criticism, although he later points out that Robz read the setup wrong. Gets into a little theory discussion with me. Finds Robz, ash, Jimmmmm and Morgrim scummy. Is frustrated with Morgrim which I agree seems rather townie. Finds e a little scummy for the D1 passes. Later has a null read on e. Overall slight town read.
morgrim
Well, Morgrim... not very helpful in his first contributions. Later a self-vote. But then gives reads, finds mcmc scummy and has a town read on e. Jumps the Jorbles wagon late. Could be scum, I'm pretty null here.