Ok.
10 people left, 5 VT (2.7, ____, ____, _____, _____), 1 Doc (Voltaire), and 4 scum on two different teams.
The two people who were mentioned the most as suspects D1 (not faust) were Sudgy and Yuma. For the sake of my argument, lets say one of these is scum and because of the quickhammer call him yuma.
Now 5 VT (2.7, Sudgy, ____, _____, _____), 1 Doc (Voltaire), and 4 scum on two different teams (Yuma, ____, ____, ____)(four blanks rather than groups of two since we don't have info to really go for scumteams yet).
I have a town read on Robz based on his D1 play, and everyone can see that I think Archetype is scummy. Now, I am not sure just how random the assignments are, but I can really see a newbie being on mafia (see Robz point 2 about the Ash NK-the first and third points are stretching it a bit--ash was on Faust since the sudgy episode before the "do not kill" thing--maybe on the third point but i doubt it), so we now have:
5 VT (2.7, Sudgy, Robz, _____, _____), 1 Doc (Voltaire), and 4 scum on two different teams (Yuma, Archetype, Gveoniz, ____)
But wait! Jimmmmm was also a "newbie" when roles were assigned (NHS), and I don't see more than one newbie being put as mafia. And Gveoniz has seemed towny to me. For example:
Voltaire - doc. Do not lynch, do not kill.
Why are you talking about "do not kill"? Informing the other scum team not to kill him?
Err... I'm informing all scum teams not to kill him? They are all scumhunting in a way, so maybe they find reads lists helpful to find opposing scum. If I were scum, why would I want to inform the other scum team of anything? They would be a bigger threat to me than town.
I guess your explanation is reasonable, still feel really strange though.
That looks like a simple acceptance of a explanation. More town than scum (especially newish player who doesn't want to cause too much controversy). So, even without any real input from Jimmmm, for my little thinking through we have
5 VT (2.7, Sudgy, Robz, Gveoniz, _____), 1 Doc (Voltaire), and 4 scum on two different teams (Yuma, Archetype, Jimmmmm, ____)
Now only Eevee and liopoil left. Both are right at the edge of being lurkers, but posted enough (and with enough content) to avoid that accusation D1 (although they better get more active here in D2). Here I am just going off my gut:
(confident with those in italics-the ones I am comfortable with their placement I underlined)
5 VT (
2.7, Sudgy,
Robz,
Gveoniz, Eevee), 1 Doc (
Voltaire), and 4 scum on two different teams (
Yuma,
Archetype, Jimmmmm, liopoil)
Put into quiz format:
Want to Lynch: Archetype
Wouldn't mind lynching: Yuma
Wouldn't shed a tear over lynching: Sudgy, Eevee, Jimmmm, liopoil
Want to wait for D3 to decide: Robz, Gveoniz
Won't lynch: 2.7, Voltaire
I recognize this list is a little ambitious as well as being a little unscientific (read gut-feeling) but we need to start with something.