Jimmmmm never flavor claimed, I guess.
So Andrew claims to have blocked TA, who killed faust anyway.
Andrew claims to have jailed (doc + targeted) yuma, who killed ww anyway.
Andrew claims to have doctored his 2nd highest scum read.
Yeah, that all looks great. He of course has the cover of a scum player who flipped redirector, and has claimed a role that changes if he's targeted.
Here's a scum narrative for you: what if he does have a role like that, and a partner who is a redirector? How about you have your partner direct you where you want to have whatever action to take happen, to ensure it happens? It's like a trade off, where the partner can't redirect town but you get a stronger scum power for Andrew. Does that fit any flavor in the books? Working together to do magic or something? Regardless, he claims to have been targeting all kinds of stuff in the middle of all the action the first two nights, and then when the redirector is dead, all he did was doctor someone who was his 2nd highest scum read and probably unlikely to be killed.
Let's think this through again. He DOCTORED his 2ND HIGHEST SCUM READ. Also, in the list of "going to die tonight" people, where does Jimmmmm fall at the end of yesterday? I mean, we have basically IC yuma, we have claimed bodyguard guy Arch protecting him--so one or the other makes sense to protect. We had xerxes who claimed he would be confirmed town today if he lived. Why protect Jimmmmm ahead of any of those three?
I get it, I'm your biggest scumread. Block me, then. But you don't doc me, anyway. So your choices were: yuma, arch, xeiron, xerxes, Jimmmm. I have to think that Jimmmmm comes 4th on that list to protect for any town doctor. Xeiron is probably dead anyway, so he stays at the bottom.
So we have N1/N2 claims contrary to what actually happened, with the built in excuse of a scum redirector. But his own claim makes sense as a partner to the redirector, as a way to use his power.
And we have an N3 claim completely different from his thinking on N1/N2, which fits with not having his redirector buddy to help him anymore. And he targeted the second least sensible person to target.