I am going to do something I did in Adventure Time--albeit as scum--that I think helped narrow down who was scum pretty substantially... for reference
here is the post there:
Basically the premise is that scum would want to vote for each other to create "interactions" and what not in the game itself... This made me think that players with low amount of non-RVS votes would be likely to be town. In that game I was able to pinpoint 6 townies out of the 10 in that game... I haven't tried it in other games, but will do so here...
Keep in mind I am trying to establish RVS votes from the context in the post and when it happened in the game state, hopefully I don't get any of them wrong
1. Archetype - 0 votes
2. yuma - 0 votes
3. XerxesPraelor - 2 votes (both policy votes)
4. xeiron - 4 votes
5. faust - 1 vote
6. Twistedarcher - 1 vote
7. Witherweaver - 1 vote (well 2 from me)
8. shraeye - 0 votes
9. sudgy - lots of votes
10. A Drowned Kernel - 1 vote
11. AndrewisFTTW - lots of votes
12. Jimmmmm - 3 votes
13. ashersky - 4 votes
So not quite as useful? But maybe still useful...? At least it will be good to have as a reference to see if this theory of mine holds out over time or not.