I'm looking at the details of what actually went down, rather than simply "AHoppy got intent to hammer twice and wasn't lynched".
The first time around, the vote count (according to yuma's quoting of sudgy) was:
Twistedarcher (1): Eevee
Eevee (4): Twistedarcher, Archetype, Jimmmmm, yuma [L-3]
AHoppy (5): chairs, pingpongsam, Teproc, Voltaire, scott_pilgrim, yuma [L-1]
Robz stated intent to hammer, and within 3 minutes both Voltaire and yuma had unvoted. Voltaire was Town, so no problem there. It seems fairly unlikely that yuma would put his partner on L-1 and then panic when someone announced intent to hammer. So from what I can tell, no shenanigans there.
Robz then received votes in quick succession from yuma, Voltaire, pps, Archetype.
I assume, pps, that you're excluding yourself from the shenanigans which saved AHoppy, so maybe Archetype was willing to put his vote on any other Townie to save AHoppy. Maybe.
Then more stuff happened, people voted for Eevee and Teproc, leaving the following vote count (according to Teproc, edited to include yuma's vote on Teproc):
Ahoppy (4) : chairs, Teproc, scott_pilgrim, Robz
Eevee (3) : Twistedarcher, Jimmmmm, Archetype
Robz (2) : Voltaire, pingpongsam
Teproc (2) : faust, yuma
Twistedarcher (1) : Eevee
chairs (1) : Ahoppy
Later AHoppy supposedly got back up to L-1, but it now seems he only got to L-2. I don't think it's that important though, since everyone thought he was on L-1:
Ahoppy (5) : Teproc, scott_pilgrim, Robz, chairs, pingpongsam
Eevee (3) : Twistedarcher, Jimmmmm, Archetype
Robz (1) : Voltaire
Teproc (3) : faust, yuma, Eevee
chairs (1) : Ahoppy
Voltaire (Town) stated reluctant intent, and he and Eevee agreed they didn't like the lynch. yuma suggested Teproc, whom scott changed to before any current suspects off the wagon other than Eevee and yuma posted again.
That's all I've really got time for now. How's that for actual wagon analysis pps? Do you conclude based on this that the scumteam must be AHoppy/Eevee/Arch?