This post is written with the intent of maximizing the information I can wring out of the fact that multiple players have voted for a townie (me). If you question that fact (reasonable!), this may not carry much weight.
As of when I started this post/re-read/research, the wagon on me was as follows:
(4): Robz, shraeye, chairs, mcmcsalot
The following player(s) have voted for me but are not currently on me:
(1): TwistedArcher
The following player(s) have expressed willingness to vote/lynch me:
(2): ashersky (many times), raerae (thinks I made a post that is the
definition of scummy and
will vote for either lio or me, but has since backed off)
(that's more than enough to put me at L-1, something I predict will probably happen)The following player(s) have indicated they find me scummy:
(1): liopoil (
maybe scumread)
The following player(s) have not expressed any opinion about me:
(2): Jimmmm, nkirbit
The following player(s) have stated that they do not like the case on me. I assume this means it is unlikely they vote me:
(2): UmbrageOfSnow, Eevee
So who do I find scummy here? I do not find shraeye scummy. I got a town v town vibe from our argument earlier, and I have found shraeye's other actions, and dedication to pushing my case as their top read, what I would expect from town.
Robz I do not find that additionally scummy for his vote on me. It's his other actions that give me a scum vibe. When Robz voted, TA was on me, so Robz's vote should be treated as second on my wagon (in my opinion). But Robz is no longer that strong a read for me. It's frustrating, because if Robz is scum, it means he's learned the lesson "never be townie" and he can play lite anti-town and survive as scum.
Chairs I find the most scummy. Others have covered this before, but he hopped on my wagon due to a "gut feel" that he has never explained, and it was the second time he'd done so. He's seen that TA has voted for me in the past, so he's the 3(4) vote on my wagon, tipping it over the edge to viability.
mcmc I also find scummy, but not as strongly. I don't know what to make of his ash vote, return to me, and now statement he doesn't want to lynch ash. His other contributions have been less than stellar, but mcmc did this in B2B too. If he hadn't claimed VT at the start, I would have been much more willing to vote him in that game, and he was town.
TA I have gotten town vibes from in other places, and his original vote on me is not bad. He called me out for something that scum occasionally do. Taken with his other behavior, I maintain a town read on TA.
Ash seems to be setting himself up
very nicely to put me at L-1 or hammer me without seeming suspicious. It reeks of laying groundwork to me.
raerae apparently doesn't see the case on me after an (aborted?) re-read and has voted for Eevee for lurking. No info to gain there.
lio is also possibly setting himself up nicely to cast a late vote on me, but lio has faded into the background quite a bit and I'm not sure what to make of him at this point.
That's what I get from my wagon. There are some very interesting interactions going on among my scum reads that indicate either they are bussing or several of my reads are wrong, so I'm going to do more re-reading and try to puzzle that bit out.
Based on the above, I'll happily
vote: chairs once again. Still open to Robz or ash.
Author
Topic: MXXVII: CLUE Mafia Mafia Wins (Read 188033 times)