Addressing a few things but not quoting because I'm a lazy drunk.
1). Sudgy's role and whether it does or does not make sense as a scum role: I 100% believe it does make sense as a scum role. You are given the opportunity to sway somebody to your side of things. For instance, you could say, 'Hey so-and-so, I totally super think you're town, we should hang out...' and so-and-so, knowing they are town, could say, 'Look! Somebody finally gets me! That person is obviously town because they can read me correctly!' Or, you could say 'Hey so-and-so, I have information X, Y, and Z and you should vote with me because of that...oh, and I think you're town,' and BOOM! another vote with scum. Obviously, this goes both ways so I don't think we decide solely based on the role.
2) EFHW, if you are town, a little more conversation would be fabulous. I know I soured you a little bit with Pirates but would really appreciate some thoughts. But only if you're town, cool? If you're scum, maybe you can just ignore this game, k?
3) Let's just go over this one more time, IF both sets of lovers are town, scum could have won this game before D2. Seriously, I'm going to make this a little bigger so ya'll read it.
4) Eevee claimed. Can everybody else please NOT do that? Cool.
5) mail-mi keeps saying he won't vote for sudgy but doesn't acknowledge the oddity of sudgy (claimed lover, one more time for those of you who missed it) being alive, he just keeps telling us to trust his half-baked two night kill jibber-jab.
6) Eevee, I understand you don't want to die. I support that. But you seem to be basing the majority of your sudgy read on your alignment. Is there anything else you can tell us, without more claiming, that will help your situation? If not, do you understand the logic behind the suspicion surrounding sudgy?
7) mail-mi, once upon a time (earlier today) you advocated lynching Eevee. Do you still support that considering his claim?
8 ) Regarding a softdeadline, I can't commit to anything. I'm making a giant move in a few weeks and planning/packing takes priority. That said...I am out of town next Tuesday - Thursday nights...