oh, the latter, for sure. imagine a doc that can only save a certain player, you kind of
assume the other guy is town if you are, you know? I think that's a good analogy for this situation.
Yeah, I get what you're saying. I still think you're wrong, though.
Here's a fun exercise:
If Sudgy is scum, who would his partner be?
My guess is almost certainly not Eevee. I don't see any way Eevee is scum and doing this. Actually, I don't Eevee being scum in general. If he's scum, and Sudgy is scum, it's way, way, way too risky to pull this off. And there's no case where I can see him being scum and Sudgy is town, barring a counterclaim. So I think Eevee is conf town to me.
I'm not sure if Raerae or EFHW would bus their scum buddy. I don't think they would have jumped on him like that.
That leaves mail-mi or nkirbit. If it's nkirbit, we'll find out anyway. If it's mail-mi, then I think I know what his role is.
My best bet right now is Sudgy/mail-mi (and if it's not mail-mi, nkirbit).
Now, if Sudgy ISN'T scum, that means 2/3 of (EFHW, Raerae, Mail-mi) are scum. And I think possibly nkirbit as well, although that's probably less likely.
I will think about this and come back to it.