Eevee: He's been very busy, so there's not much. Comes back and defends EFHW, with this:
Kudos to nkirbit for pushing us to the right direction. I don't think I agree about EHFW though, what are you implying? "A little weird" doesn't automatically mean mafia-y.
Not sure what to make of this, honestly. All my initial comment about EHFW stated was that it was "a little weird", not anything about EHFW being scummy for this. Eevee defended EHFW from an accusation that I hadn't even made. I never said anything about "A little weird" being mafia-y, and I don't know why Eevee felt the need to defend EHFW here.
Votes Liopoil for simply being "a bit off" with no further explanation. Okay, I guess, but I'd like to hear the reason for why he feels a bit off! And nothing since then. He's been busy, I know, but it's weird to come back to a game you've been out of, make a vote for "someone being weird", then hop off again. Scumread for me.
Sudgy:
Immediately votes EFHW after I make my initial comment about her. Thinking about it, I wonder why Eevee's question is pointed at me, and not Sudgy.. sudgy was the one to vote for EFHW!
Anyway, this is a very sheepy vote, but I just hammered Sudgy incorrectly in part for being sheepy, so I'm not going to put any weight on this vote.
He then votes for me, but it was pretty much RVS. Then doesn't have a lot of content.
I'm going to go with a town-read here. I'd like to see more content, especially original content, but I just mis-lynched Sudgy for the same reason, and he was town the last time he acted like this.
Xeiron:
Wow, there's remarkably little content here. Like, less than both Eevee and Mail-mi, which is saying something. His only meaningful contribution was an RVS vote on me, and calling that meaningful was a stretch. Scumread for an extreme lack of meaningful activity.
Liopoil:
Bring's up a history of EFHW, but doesn't comment on it at all. Doesn't respond to Eevee's vote at all, but this is expected... Eevee hasn't really given him anything to respond to. He posts a bunch of reads, which I like, but doesn't give any reasons for any of them, which I don't like. Raerae asks him three questions, which he ignores. In particular, raerae asks this:
A history of EFHW and RVS:vote: nkirbit
What's this about?
So far, xeiron is the only one acting scummy, for voting nkirbit without explanation. So vote: X.
Unvote. A vote without explanation is fishy. Now it has been explained.
RVS is usually accompanied by some kind of joke or teasing.
really quiet here. I don't normally support RVS, but maybe it will get us somewhere. Vote: raerae for trying to push the discussion forward.
My vote was not serious, and indeed, the two sentences don't make sense one after the other at all.
What did you hope to accomplish with this "history"?
Which I think is a fantastic question and would like to hear from Lio about.
Why are we even talking about lovers anyway? We don't even know if we have any, it would just fit with the theme...
lack of anything else to talk about. Not wanting to talk about this is slightly scummy, because scum might not want to. I'll Vote: sudgy
Lack of anything to talk about? How about the multiple questions that raerae asked you?
You did answer these later, but I wasn't very satisfied with your responses. Your reads were hardly based off anything? That's dumb! They were obviously based off of something, and raerae and the others would like to know what.
Scumread, for sure.
In summary:
Scumread: Liopoil, Xeiron, Eevee, EHFW
Neutral: Mail-Mi, TA
Town: Raerae, Sudgy
That's a lot of scumreads, so I'll clarify that EHFW and Liopoil are my top two reads at the moment. Both higher than xeiron and eevee, who are mostly caused by lack of activity.