Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Axxle]

http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=7438.new#new

[Jorbles]

A one hour forum game? That's crazy.

[Archetype]

A one hour forum game? That's crazy.

It was. Maybe it's possible to do it again, but everyone would have to be active.

Anyways, back to the game!

Robz is seeming pretty scummy to me. SK hunting and all.

[mcmcsalot]

Robz is seeming pretty scummy scary to me. SK arch hunting and all.

FTFY

[ashersky]

Robz is seeming pretty scummy scary to me. SK arch hunting and all.

FTFY

What is it with Arch hunting anyway?  Dude can't survive in any games.  Have you ever made it to LYLO, Arch?

[Dsell]

Robz is seeming pretty scummy scary to me. SK arch hunting and all.

FTFY

What is it with Arch hunting anyway?  Dude can't survive in any games.  Have you ever made it to LYLO, Arch?

That one blitz game you moderated...

[Dsell]

Robz is seeming pretty scummy scary to me. SK arch hunting and all.

FTFY

What is it with Arch hunting anyway?  Dude can't survive in any games.  Have you ever made it to LYLO, Arch?

That one blitz game you moderated...

Woops just double-checked and it was actually Insom. Sorry!

[Archetype]

Robz is seeming pretty scummy scary to me. SK arch hunting and all.

FTFY

What is it with Arch hunting anyway?  Dude can't survive in any games.  Have you ever made it to LYLO, Arch?

That one blitz game you moderated...

Woops just double-checked and it was actually Insom. Sorry!

Not my finest hour.

I'm not too upset about not living to the end all the time though. I try really hard to be town when I'm town (and of course, when scum too) but it just comes off scummy to everyone else, sadly.

/sob story

I'll actually Vote: Robz. It's funny how often scum really goes after those easy lynches.

[Dsell]

Tbh I don't remember what's going on in this game, day one was short and not terribly substantive, I am just gonna have to reread at some point. I'm not sure that scumrobz really "goes for the easy lynches" though. Maybe a long time ago but he is pretty sophisticated as scum.

So obviously I'm not gonna discount the chance of him being scum here, but I do not think that looking for easy scum play is the way to find scumrobz.

[eHalcyon]

Vote Count 2.2

jotheonah (1): Jorbles
mcmcsalot (2): jotheonah, mail-mi
Razzishi (1): ashersky
Robz888 (1): Archetype

Not voting (9): Axxle, Dsell, Eevee, Galzria, liopoil, mcmcsalot, Razzishi, Robz888, spiritbears

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

hard deadline is Monday April 29, 9:00pm MDT

[spiritbears]

It feels like we just have so little to go on!  I'm not sure about a lynchvote on anyone....and I'm pretty sure I'm not buying eHal tryin to convince us Morg is really dead!  I mean come SHOW US The BODY!  I kind of like the idea of re-lynching Morg.  Beyond that, MC's perhaps overemthusiam at A2's death is the only thing that really stands out as "perhaps" at all scummy.  So for now my FoS is slightly on Mc.  But I sure wish we had more A2 interaction to figure out why someone would want him dead....

[liopoil]

I voted morgrim and it didn't show up in the votecount. so we can't lynch morgrim because we can't vote for him! he's either dead or vote-proof or something. I suggest we forget about morgrim.

[jotheonah]

I went to read joth's posts. There are only 3 of them. He didn't even vote yesterday, and one of the others made me suspicious of him. I think he's a great candidate for lynching.

I've been really busy IRL. I shouldn't even be playing. But you know I'm not a lurker scum. Never have been. When I'm scum I darn well play.

[Axxle]

I voted morgrim and it didn't show up in the votecount. so we can't lynch morgrim because we can't vote for him! he's either dead or vote-proof or something. I suggest we forget about morgrim.

Vote: liopoil
I'm pretty sure you're just posting just to post.  It looks like you're doing things but not really (going after a dead person).  It might be a bastard game but it's not that bastard.

[mail-mi]

I agree with spiritbears, were pretty much back in D1. The only real slight interaction is mcmc "cheering" that he was dead (if you can even call it that). So yeah I suggest we go to lynching lurkers.

[liopoil]

That post was in response to spiritbears suggesting we lynch morgrim again. Do you have a better topic for us to discuss? we reallly have nothing to go off of.

[Axxle]

Unvote
Missed that part.  I'll do a reread but I think mcmc might be the best choice for an Axxle2 killer.  He's afraid I'd share information with him and vice versa.

Vote: mcmc

[Robz888]

Unvote
Missed that part.  I'll do a reread but I think mcmc might be the best choice for an Axxle2 killer.  He's afraid I'd share information with him and vice versa.

Vote: mcmc

Wouldn't that just be, like, something anybody would do? "Who should we kill?" "I don't know, there's two Axxles, let's kill him." "Sure." You know?

[liopoil]

yeah pretty much... scum didn't have too much to go off of either...

[Jorbles]

Unvote
Missed that part.  I'll do a reread but I think mcmc might be the best choice for an Axxle2 killer.  He's afraid I'd share information with him and vice versa.

Vote: mcmc

I'm not down with this mcmc lynch. I think this is a preplanned frame job.

[Axxle]

Unvote
Missed that part.  I'll do a reread but I think mcmc might be the best choice for an Axxle2 killer.  He's afraid I'd share information with him and vice versa.

Vote: mcmc

Wouldn't that just be, like, something anybody would do? "Who should we kill?" "I don't know, there's two Axxles, let's kill him." "Sure." You know?

I think some other people think I make one half purposefully useless. Other people would also try to kill some of the stronger players (I'm not very good at getting people to see my line of thinking)

[spiritbears]

Unvote
Missed that part.  I'll do a reread but I think mcmc might be the best choice for an Axxle2 killer.  He's afraid I'd share information with him and vice versa.

Vote: mcmc

I'm not down with this mcmc lynch. I think this is a preplanned frame job.

Pre-planned?  By whom?  The only thing I noticed was MC suggesting he was didn't like A2 and some others saying well, that might be kind of scummy--or at least suggest maybe he would kill for that reason...  Are you suggesting there are people here that would lynch MC for some meta reason?  If so, what reason?  I just am too new to know MC, though he played scum in the only other game I played.  I'm not sure hating A2 is a great reason to lynch MC, but not sure it's a terrible reason either. 

[spiritbears]

Unvote
Missed that part.  I'll do a reread but I think mcmc might be the best choice for an Axxle2 killer.  He's afraid I'd share information with him and vice versa.

Vote: mcmc

Wouldn't that just be, like, something anybody would do? "Who should we kill?" "I don't know, there's two Axxles, let's kill him." "Sure." You know?

That just doesn't sound like scum reasoning....unless scum is playing nice D1

[Jorbles]

Unvote
Missed that part.  I'll do a reread but I think mcmc might be the best choice for an Axxle2 killer.  He's afraid I'd share information with him and vice versa.

Vote: mcmc

I'm not down with this mcmc lynch. I think this is a preplanned frame job.

Pre-planned?  By whom?  The only thing I noticed was MC suggesting he was didn't like A2 and some others saying well, that might be kind of scummy--or at least suggest maybe he would kill for that reason...  Are you suggesting there are people here that would lynch MC for some meta reason?  If so, what reason?  I just am too new to know MC, though he played scum in the only other game I played.  I'm not sure hating A2 is a great reason to lynch MC, but not sure it's a terrible reason either. 

Specifically I think jotheonah did the framing. It's not a meta reason, but very much in this game. mcmc spoke ill of Axxle2 (and is the only one who did). Axxle2 dies. joth immediately comes out to say that he thinks mcmc killed Axxle2 because he didn't want him in the game and votes for him. A scummy player (joth) going after someone (mcmc) for a flimsy reason. I'm not 100% sure that joth is on the scum team that executed the kill, but I think it's likely.

[Galzria]

Vote: Jorbles

"I'm not 100% sure Joth is on the scum team that executed the kill..."

A) Demonstrates knowledge of multiple scum teams.
B) Demonstrates that his own scum team likely was not the one to kill A2.