This finger pointing is all well and good, ash, but you've been prompted to come up with a case and refuse to do anything but piggy back on things people have said and try to force them to apply to me. If you're truly town try doing something helpful instead of half-butted scumhunting.
Prompted by whom to come up with a case on whom?
I'm by no means the best scumhunter around. Here are a few thoughts:
1) I just modded Eevee in MXXIV, where he was a fantastic asset to town (see the ending of D3, especially). He hasn't done anything near as useful in this game. So Eevee from this game is not playing like great town!Eevee. I think this bears consideration.
2) My strong town read is based on knowing Jimmmmm is masterful as scum in recognizable ways (to me, I think), and he just hasn't done anything like that this game. He just won again as scum in blitz. Scum!Jimmmmm is actually a better scumhunter than town!Jimmmmm. Now, scum!Jimmmmm actually builds the cases on town, but he actively participates in a way that seems very pro town. He hasn't done that this game, so I continue to feel like he's town. He also has another big town tell that I'm not going to mention, so that I can continue to look for it in future games, that he's using in this one.
3) Jorbles has played like I expect scum!Jorbles to play this entire game. I've had the scum read since D1, and it hasn't waned. It hasn't risen to "OMGHESSCUMMMMMM" level, and he hasn't slipped at all. But I won't be surprised when he flips Mountebank.
4) raerae had the disadvantage of subbing in. Subbing in is hard, and is a huge help/favor to the game. She deserved a pass for the first day or two anyway. Plus, there was RL VLA to deal with. So, trying to take those things into account, my feeling on you the whole game has still been one of "that's not the normal raerae we see in games." Less brash and mean, less case pushing, less of everything. Remember how we went at it on D1 of DS9? That's TOWN!raerae. I've learned from that game, where I highly suspected you. Now, you are nothing like that, so I suspect you.
5) sudgy felt kind of scummy all game, but we've all accepted that his gold key claim has to be true, given no one has countered it. I think one thing we're all forgetting is that one of the town members that is dead bought the key, sudgy is scum, and he's just making up everything he's saying about what the dead players are saying.