Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Eevee]

It did not, my keyboard is just very dumb.

So, claimed races:

Humans:
Robz (not town, but not lying about his race either)
WinterSpartan
Eevee
raerae

Elves:
Archetype
Jorbles
Kooshie

Hobbits:
Morgrim
Jimmmmm

Ents:
mail-mi
Destierro

Eagle:
sudgy

Dwarf:
Axxle

See where scum is?

[Eevee]

Jimmm would be the only hobbit if he played. I don't think a bulletproof hobbit is the most obvious thing either. You see how from my perspective your claim is more believable in this perspective?

[Jimmmmm]

You're saying that all Town players being comprised of only 3 races is more likely than having Humans, Elves, 1 Hobbit and 1-2 Ents? So much more likely that it overrules me being a confirmed non-Dragon by a confirmed Town, and you're willing to bet the game on you having the correct idea about how the races would be divided up?

[Jimmmmm]

Bulletproof is just the role name in Mafia terms. Obviously a Hobbit isn't actually bulletproof, but he's much more likely to be able to slip away and hide when something's trying to get him.

[Eevee]

You're saying that all Town players being comprised of only 3 races is more likely than having Humans, Elves, 1 Hobbit and 1-2 Ents? So much more likely that it overrules me being a confirmed non-Dragon by a confirmed Town, and you're willing to bet the game on you having the correct idea about how the races would be divided up?

Well, if you are a hobbit, then mail-mi is town and there are two entish faith healers (=half doctors). I think that makes more sense than there being one half doctor (why only a half doctor in a setup this scum heavy!) and one random hobbit. Also, the fact you claimed after morgrim who turned out to be scum makes it more likely too.

Could Jimmm be an orc (so sudgy was just a sk)? Possible I guess? Although in this scenario I dont see why Jimm would claim hobbit after morgrim.

Again, I'm just trying to make up my mind. Maybe it's just that you are busy Jimmm, but somehow I feel town Jimmm would be more invested in trying to find who he is town with.

Whichever you is scum, has played very well in my opinion.

[Jimmmmm]

Maybe it's just that you are busy Jimmm, but somehow I feel town Jimmm would be more invested in trying to find who he is town with.

The mod had to do this:

No one has posted for 24 hours, officially.  Prods coming after 48.

Your argument is equally valid for all of us. I have been busy, this isn't the only place I've been less active than normal. And yes, I do really want to get this right, but that also seems to make it more likely that I'll put off putting the necessary work in. In DS9 at mylo I put it off so much that we no-lynched. I will have time to fully re-read both of you in the next 1-2 days, and hopefully I can nut out the best thing to do.

[Eevee]

I'll be flying home wednesday-thursday, questionable/nonexistent access around then.

is the reason I wasn't here. I did read first half of the thread in the plane though and wrote the noncoherent rambling of my thoughts about it there, posted it when I finally got back online.

I don't mind you taking a couple of days, I havent finished the reread either. It just feels like I'm the only one conflicted here, and you two are both just waiting for the other to drop down the vote so you can hammer me for the win. Mail-mi I dont know about, but the town Jimm I know would really want to get this right and would be borderline obsessed with paranoia and analyzing. You just seem to go "I think it's Eevee" with evidence I find quite flimsy. I would expect town Jimmm to be more scared of being wrong/care more about being right. But, maybe I'll see that in the reread. You can't possibly both be scum. 

[mail-mi]

AAARGH this is so frustrating!!!!!

[Eevee]

AAARGH this is so frustrating!!!!!

why?

[mail-mi]

Because I have absolutely no idea which of you two is scum!

[Eevee]

Because I have absolutely no idea which of you two is scum!

Is that because I said I'd find that thought process townie?

[mail-mi]

Because I have absolutely no idea which of you two is scum!

Is that because I said I'd find that thought process townie?

Umm... Either I'm stupid, or you put this in a really confusing way. Please explain.

[ashersky]

Vote Count 6.5:

Not Voting (3): Eevee, mail-mi, Jimmmmm

With 3 alive, it takes 2 to lynch.

The day will end on April 8, 2013, at 9:00 p.m. forum time.

[Eevee]

Because I have absolutely no idea which of you two is scum!

Is that because I said I'd find that thought process townie?

Umm... Either I'm stupid, or you put this in a really confusing way. Please explain.

I've been saying you both, especially Jimmm, feel scummy for not seeming like you genuinely want to solve who the other remaining townie is (but rather just resign into "I guess its Eevee").

[mail-mi]

Well, my mom says its Eevee so... (Just after hearing ur names and not reading anything.)

[Eevee]

Idk, this is sort of frustrating. On the other hand I feel like the other townie is giving us very little chance by reading me this badly, but I also just dont even know who to vote for myself, so..
I guess I'd vote for mail-mi if I had to choosen now, because of WS's results, but I certainly wouldnt feel great about it.

[ashersky]

Well, my mom says its Eevee so... (Just after hearing ur names and not reading anything.)

Mail-mi has been modkilled for talking about the game outside the thread (to his mom).

[ashersky]

Well, my mom says its Eevee so... (Just after hearing ur names and not reading anything.)

Mail-mi has been modkilled for talking about the game outside the thread (to his mom).

Not really.

[Eevee]

Well, my mom says its Eevee so... (Just after hearing ur names and not reading anything.)

Mail-mi has been modkilled for talking about the game outside the thread (to his mom).

Not really.

Just dont make him hated this time.

[mail-mi]

Well, my mom says its Eevee so... (Just after hearing ur names and not reading anything.)

Mail-mi has been modkilled for talking about the game outside the thread (to his mom).

Not really.

Holy crap that scared me. Thought town had lost.

Okay now Im leaning more sudgy was a SK and jimmmms scum and Eevees town

This might change after a few posts ( cuz that's just the nature of this game)

[Eevee]

Well, my mom says its Eevee so... (Just after hearing ur names and not reading anything.)

Mail-mi has been modkilled for talking about the game outside the thread (to his mom).

Not really.

Holy crap that scared me. Thought town had lost.

Okay now Im leaning more sudgy was a SK and jimmmms scum and Eevees town

This might change after a few posts ( cuz that's just the nature of this game)

What made this happen? (yay!)

[mail-mi]

B/c you are getting townier as he gets scummier.

[Eevee]

B/c you are getting townier as he gets scummier.

It's SO weird. How can Jimmmm feel SO scummy despite being an excellent scum player AND getting cleared by the dragon cop!? If he was scum, he should be able to mask it better given the circumstances (he likely could have baited one of us to vote for each other by now!). Idk, maybe it's just him being busy. I really need to finish that reread, but no way that can happen before sunday. I know dead people in the speccy, you must hate me. Soft deadline on next tuesday? Nothing binding, just a reminder for us to get to this game and just stick our necks out with a decision. Postponing it doesnt make getting it right any more likely.

[mail-mi]

Well I can't do that. I'm gonna be in Moab from Sunday afternoon to Wednesday. Good time for a vacation, right?

[Eevee]

Well I can't do that. I'm gonna be in Moab from Sunday afternoon to Wednesday. Good time for a vacation, right?

Well, it's not that bad. Literally our only hurries are forgetting our reads (and that's what rereads are for!) and the curiosity problems of the good folk in the spectator thread.