Okay, here's my actual contradiction case, as opposed to just pointing it out:
Imagine these three scenarios:
-Town Eevee A sees Dsell's #25 and thinks "Oh yeah, that's right, we're Station or something. Well at least I can clear myself by checking my PM and saying that." He then almost immediately sees joth's #29, and is disappointed, leading him to say this:
I could have had time to answer and clear myself before Joth stepped in
(I'll acknowledge that that was taken slightly out of context, I'll get back to that)
-Town Eevee B sees Dsell's #25 and thinks "Well that would not be a great way to get Town cred, hopefully joth steps in." He then almost immediately sees joth's #29, and is relieved that he doesn't have to choose between giving some scummy-looking non-answer, or gaining some undeserved Town cred, leading him to say:
Fwiw, even if I got here before Joth, I wouldnt have answered because it would have felt like a very unfair way to gain a lot of town cred.
The point here is that Town Eevee knows if he's A or B when he reads #25, and he knows if he's disappointed or relieved when he reads #29.
-Scum Eevee sees Dsell's #25 and thinks "Uh oh how am I going to get out of this?" but then sees joth's #29 and thinks "whew well that was close, now all I have to say is that I would have said it and they won't know one way or another." He then has some time to think about the situation, and his meta, and how he would react as Town (because let's face it, we all think more about ourselves when we're scum). Nearly 3 hours later, he has come to the conclusion that Town Eevee is a standup guy who wouldn't try to take unwarranted Town cred and so he lets us know how sportsmanly Town Eevee really is. Unfortunately he's been so caught up in his thoughts of what he would do that he forgets what he has done, that is said that he would have cleared his name and taken the Town cred. So he ends up contradicting himself.
Now, I'm not saying I know 100% that Eevee is scum. I'll gladly listen to an argument for Town Eevee C who isn't quite sure how he would have reacted. But I certainly think it's the best day 1 case I've ever made.