MCMCSALOT
#129 after Insomniac votes for him, mcmc panics and unvotes.
In post #135 Robz catches this, and I agree with what Robz says there.
Vote: Mcmcsalot, for unvoting because he was freaked out. Panic is a scumtell, too.
I jumped on this wagon in #139 for the sole reason to see what happened with added pressure. But on reread, I wonder why that wagon just up and disappeared.
Don't even care about the votes on me getting to see more story is worth it.
Jimmmm’s defense (#146) seems reasonable; but it sort of obfuscates the reasons that Robz/ashersky voted for mcmcsalot. They didn’t vote mcmcs because he “unvoted too quickly”. A lot about that post felt very panicked.
I just went to look because I remembered mcmcsalot being very calm as scum with me in Blitz9. But in that game nobody EVER voted for him. This could be the first time we’ve seen scummcmcsalot facing serious pressure.
#170 mcmc acknowledges the wagon on him, but just asks how to get the game going. Then says about his wagon, when asked directly by Insomniac, that the panic was just confusion coming out of RVS. Says, “I would have been smart enough not to do that as mafia.”
In #174 I had analyzed this saying that Jimmm was uncomfortable with L-2 wagon, that nobody analyzed this wagon, and that mcmcsalot was super calm under pressure. I think I’ve figured out why he was so calm under pressure there. He realized that the main reason for the wagon on him was the panic he showed earlier, so he very deliberately showed no panic for the next set of posts waiting for suspicion to move on to somebody else. It turns out I was the first to unvote and backdown, which I now think was the wrong move.
#185 mcmcsalot says he thinks people aren’t engaged in the game, because other ideas haven’t been fully commented on. Asks if I thought he was town, then why would I expect him to panic at L-3?
I don't currently have any beliefs about your alignment, I'm still not sure what to make of it. I wasn't expecting you to panic, but I was expecting you to react in some way. There's overreacting to suspicion, which often feels scummy. there's indignance, there's self-pity, there's a lot of emotions somebody might show over being voted to L-3 with no apparent reason. You, however, reacted barely at all, and really were as calm as possible. It struck me as one of the things I should take away from this wagon.
I’ve said this before, but I’m realizing now that NO reaction is super weird, and quite a deliberate action. I think this was a scumploy.
Ooh, and mcmcs responses to that were also super weird.
Weeks from now when someone asks, what was mcmcsalots town meta again, this will be the post they refer too.
So you're saying you're/you expect to be more reactive/defensive when you're scum?
Not really, I don't think you can really announce your own town meta, let alone before completing more than one game. I think I'm a calm player overall regardless of alignment.
I said this before but his response is to declare his town-meta as calm, then to say that one can’t announce their own town-meta. Basically saying that he’s overall calm, but then awkwardly sticking in a “oh yeah, I’m town” reminder. I didn’t like it then, and I don’t like it now.
Later on mcmc said this about the whole secenario
Weeks from now when someone asks, what was mcmcsalots town meta again, this will be the post they refer too.
So this post was made quite jokingly, and when Jimm jumped on it I tried to explain that I wasn't serious about it but on a side note I do think I'm a calm player. Though I agree the posts were weird, I was trying to make jokes as the game was moving slowly, I'm not very good at it though.
I think an insistence to debate legitimate points with jokes “because the game is moving slowly” makes no sense. Deflecting suspicion via jokes is a scumtrait in my book.
During the Qvist/joth event, mcmcsalot voted for jotheonah for pushing his read so hard (reminding mcmc of himself as scum pushing raerae’s case in Blitz9), but then unvotes when people tell him townjoth tunnels.
While reading Eevee’s long analysis #294, I recalled that I voted mcmcsalot/Qvist for largely the same idea, basically going off of a small suspicion and seeing what happened. But I don’t recall having made any notes on mcmcsalot for a long time. Now I’m suspicious for the way he disappeared post-Eevee-claim.
#314 yuma points out that mcmcs vote/unvote on jotheonah was scummy. Yuma does point out that mcmc voted jotheonah for pushing a case hard, before we had even heard a response to the case from Qvist. That is suspicious, it makes sense to wait until we have a response, and have had a chance to analyze it.
#332 from mcmcsalot
We've love your post, I do have a question about your robz ash theory. Right now you feel strongly that ash is town correct. And you have said if robz flips scum, ash is your number one suspect, then you vote robz isn't this like voting for your top town read?
First off, what do you mean by “we’ve love your post”? Secondly, I don’t think this is what Eevee was saying that ash it town (wait, are you talking about Eevee’s post?). Eevee said that ashersky was looking scummy to him, but that Robz’s flip would help him develop this read even more, I think.
mcmc says he won’t lynch RobzI dislike the robz lynch only because I feel I can read him very well, I recently picked him out as scum and don't have any strong reads from him as well. Sorry I wasn't around today, I will definetly reread tomorow and get some more information out/ comment on robz and ash
This is odd, in that he’s saying he needs to reread, but at the same time is saying that he won’t lynch Robz because mcmc can read Robz well and mcmc isn’t getting any scumvibes from Robz. Why is he so sure Robz is town if he isn’t actually caught up on things? This sounds like scum tyring to buy some easy credit for being “against” a town-lynch that mcmc feels is about to go through.
Eevee also points out this is weird.
I dislike the robz lynch only because I feel I can read him very well, I recently picked him out as scum and don't have any strong reads from him as well. Sorry I wasn't around today, I will definetly reread tomorow and get some more information out/ comment on robz and ash
how can you have ANY reads on him!? he is refusing to post! unless you think that's a town tell?