Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[liopoil]

My blitz game is ready to open for sign-ups whenever. Shraeye suggested I wait a little, so I'll do that. So just tell me when to open it. In the meantime, anyone who wants to see it can.


Also DMII did happen. scum won.

[sudgy]

Ashersky, I mentioned the games I wanted to do so they could get put on the games queue.  Two normal games, and two BM games.

[mail-mi]

After re looking and revising my game, its definitely BM. Sudgy, if ur alright with this, could our BM games go me you me you? (My first one is on the queue)

[liopoil]

that's a lot of bastard games...

[mail-mi]

that's a lot of bastard games...

Those are my favorite!

[EFHW]

Harry Potter is revised and ready when needed.  http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=7915.0;topicseen

[sudgy]

After re looking and revising my game, its definitely BM. Sudgy, if ur alright with this, could our BM games go me you me you? (My first one is on the queue)

That'll be fine.

[Archetype]

It'll be semi-open, but the big mechanic is this (stolen from mafiascum):

If a Scum player does not post for 48 hours, they earn 1 point. At night, 2 of these points can be redeemed for an additional nightkill.

It'll make people really want to LaL.

I'll run this if people want to see it done instead of Donner Party.

[yuma]

It'll be semi-open, but the big mechanic is this (stolen from mafiascum):

If a Scum player does not post for 48 hours, they earn 1 point. At night, 2 of these points can be redeemed for an additional nightkill.

It'll make people really want to LaL.

I'll run this if people want to see it done instead of Donner Party.

I don't think I like anything that 1. encourages players to lurk and 2. causes players to question why another player may or may not be posting (I mean if I go on VLA for 4 days to I get enough coins?) If I go on VLA will people just lynch me instead?

[liopoil]

we're already questioning V/LA claims enough.....

[sudgy]

we're already questioning V/LA claims enough.....

Ooh, it could be that if they announce the V/LA nothing happens.

Also, town could let people lurk for a bit, see how many NKs there are, then narrow down the players to lynch.

[liopoil]

You just say: "if you don't post for 48hrs, we will policy lynch you".

[Archetype]

we're already questioning V/LA claims enough.....

Ooh, it could be that if they announce the V/LA nothing happens.

That would be cool.

I don't know. Maybe I won't run it. I was just wondering what you guys thought of it.

[sudgy]

we're already questioning V/LA claims enough.....

Ooh, it could be that if they announce the V/LA nothing happens.

That would be cool.

I don't know. Maybe I won't run it. I was just wondering what you guys thought of it.

It could work, you might want to polish it a little bit first.

[yuma]

we're already questioning V/LA claims enough.....

Ooh, it could be that if they announce the V/LA nothing happens.

That would be cool.

I don't know. Maybe I won't run it. I was just wondering what you guys thought of it.

I think it could be a good effect for a RMM or BM game, but would be hesitant to put it into a "normal" game.

[mcmcsalot]

we're already questioning V/LA claims enough.....

Ooh, it could be that if they announce the V/LA nothing happens.

That would be cool.

I don't know. Maybe I won't run it. I was just wondering what you guys thought of it.

I think it could be a good effect for a RMM or BM game, but would be hesitant to put it into a "normal" game.

Honest opinion is that is a terrible idea. You can say "you lurk for 48 hours and noone else" A) people will lurk "accidentally" and B) scum is not required to nk so it tells nothing. Just helps scum in some scenarios. My guess scum won't lurk and won't use it except to rush/end mylo. It will also make us lynch town for lurking even more than we already do.

[EFHW]

I don't think it's great either.  It would be better to have an incentive for regular posting than an incentive not to post.

[liopoil]

three games going right now, soon to be four. There will also be no open for sign-up normal games at that point. Maybe time to open up another game, maybe raerae's?

[Archetype]

Well darn.

How about a more original setup?

Something I've been thinking about:

8 VTs
1 Town Informant
1 Town Cop
1 Mafia Goon
1 Mafia 1-shot Strongman
1 Traitor Informant

50% chance of one of the VTs being a Doctor
50% chance of the Mafia Goon or Mafia Strongman being a Role Cop

Only the Town Informant is told if there is a Mafia Role Cop or not
Traitor is separate of the main Mafia 2 man faction. He is told whether the Town has a Doctor or not.

Definitely needs to be tweaked if the idea is even workable.

If a Mafia kill targets the Traitor, he will be invited to join the main faction instead of dying

[liopoil]

how does the traitor win if he doesn't get recruited?

[sudgy]

If a Mafia kill targets the Traitor, he will be invited to join the main faction instead of dying

Can he refuse the invitation?  If so, if town wins after that, will he still win?  Just a couple of interesting questions I thought of.

Another thing with your setup is, of course, the possibility of follow-the-cop.  With a half chance of a Doc, though, that might be fixed.  I'm not sure.

[Archetype]

The Traitor is Mafia Aligned. But he'll gain access to the QT after being targeted.

The reason is so that if a kill fails one night, it's not obvious that there is a Doctor.

The idea was based off a way to change Follow the Cop so you don't know if you should or not. And then there's the 1-shot Strongman just in case.

[Archetype]

The Traitor is Mafia Aligned. But he'll gain access to the QT after being 'killed'. The reason is so that if a kill fails one night, it's not obvious that there is a Doctor (Though the Mafia could have no killed, but I like this better). The idea was based off a way to change Follow the Cop so you don't know if you should or not, that's why it's vaguely similar. And then there's the 1-shot Strongman just in case, and then there is a possible Role Cop to make up for the loss of one of their members (though maybe he should be something else...?)

[Archetype]

The Traitor is Mafia Aligned. But he'll gain access to the QT after being 'killed'. The reason is so that if a kill fails one night, it's not obvious that there is a Doctor (Though the Mafia could have no killed, but I like this better). The idea was based off a way to change Follow the Cop so you don't know if you should or not, that's why it's vaguely similar. And then there's the 1-shot Strongman just in case, and then there is a possible Role Cop to make up for the loss of one of their members (though maybe he should be something else...?)

[Archetype]

Oh woah. Triple post.

Just read the newest one.