Vote: ashersky then?
I like your like of thinking Frisk, and basically only disagree on Qvist.
No. if you disagree with qvist, then my argument is shot. Also, we can't just start lynching until we figure out who we think is town in that set.
Just reread this. Looks real scummy for Eevee:
-CF proposes 5 people of which he thinks 3 are scum and that if he is correct and we can absolve one of that list, lynching the other 4 would win the game.
-Eevee reiterates that he thinks that Qvist (not on CFs list) is scum (had voted for Qvist for a similar reason to Yumas argument; "town reads for no reason are scummy" [I think here it is worth noting that earlier Eevee was expressing a lot of opinions on gut and is now saying this is a scum trait])
-Having said this, Eevee agrees to go along with CF's plan. If he thinks that Qvist is scum then, while he might agree that a plan based on a certain premise is sound, it would be a bad idea to just start killing off CF's short list. Also he was comfortable going ahead with killing off CF's short list before one player was removed from it (which was a necessary condition for the plan ending in a town win).
PPE: this is relevent to CF and Eevee's back and forth