Alright I am going to look at the people with votes on them: from highest to lowest (at least as I am typing this up)
Morgrim7 (4) - Morgrim is an enigma. Because his behavior is very, very consistent. The only time he deviated away from his stereotypical behavior (at least in the games I have been in) was when he was Vigilante in MIX. The interesting thing about his behavior is that it is actually fairly easy to replicate as mafia. (Low post count, sheeping reads, voting w/o explanation) but it is a little risky because it makes people want to lynch him. But Morgrim does have a decent survival rate lately (he survived all game in MVI and was the last player killed in MIX), so perhaps that risk is lessened of late.
Axxle (2) - I still think that at some point we need to discuss the implications of a scum aligned double voting Axxle could have on town. But I don't think that Axxle should be lynched today, especially as he will be able to help us reach a lynch with that double vote, that and he is one of the few people that I have a town read on.
shraeye (2) - Town read on shraeye. Partly because the two people voting him I have moderately scum reads on. The thing about shraeye is that he is willing and ready to pick and stick with fights and arguments. He has argued with Morgrim, ashersky, TheMunch, Insomniac, yuma, O, Glooble, Watno, Cuzz, cayvie, ftl, eevee and I am sure more that I missed He is constantly sticking his neck out. If he is scum, he will slip (some suggested that he already has) eventually if he continues to post this much, and if he is town I expect him to continue this behavior into subsequent days. A failure for him to do so, will read scum.
eHalcyon (2) - I've had a town read on eHal, but the longer he goes w/o voting for someone, the more that town read goes away. Note: someone said that he hadn't voted all game? He did vote for jot at one point at about midgame.
Grujah (2) - is he V/LA? He hasn't posted since September 22, 11 pm forum time. Can we get a prod for Grujah? But in the time that he has been on, he has posted nothing. I believe he has posted the least amount of substance out of any other player
Voltaire (1) - more of a scum read here: his posts remind me of ashersky, but less aggressive and argumentative. He seems to be trying to question everyone, but do so nicely w/o bringing any suspicion on himself.
Captain_Frisk (1) - either he is scum w/ little content, which is suspicious; or he is town w/ little content, which is too bad because he generally has really good analysis and understanding of the game, but I understand he has RL commitments. So he is a scum read, but it could be a RL scum read.
Young Nick (1) - scummy read; he has had time to read and catch up and provide analysis.
jotheonah (1) - jot's playstyle includes a lot of short, slightly sarcastic posts... that is just how he is. That said, he does seem guilty of opportunistic voting and sheeping; he consistently votes for ehunt--then votes somewhere else for a bit--and then comes back to ehunt (interesting that ehunt currently has no votes on him, for I think the first time since vote count 1.4.) so I have a scummy read on jot.
Insomniac (1) - Insomniac tends to get night killed if town, so if he survives night 1 he is scum right? /joke... No, I have a town read on Insomniac.
Galzria (1) - Town read for Galz. I am in agreement with him in regard to his lurker stance.
ftl (1) - ftl looks to me like a perfect example of scum trying at the beginning of the game to be active and fully participate, but as the game wore on, it became more and more difficult to keep up and not make a mistake, so instead of posting more and potentially making a mistake, he slowly sinks into the background.
Eevee (1) - Eevee.... hmm.... I always get a pretty good town read on Eevee--except that one time that I shot him--and he always ends up being town. I still have a town read on him.
Glooble (1) - the guy I am currently voting for. I still find him scummy and surprised that other people aren't. Although I guess he is on a couple of people's secondary votes. But I don't put any stock in secondary votes. The first one is the one that counts.
I will change my vote to someone with 2 votes on them to see if we can start getting a consensus, but everyone that has 2 votes I have a town read on except Grujah vote: grujah