I'm going through the list of players and rereading those who have posted little. I am also quickly skimming through players who have posted a lot. And I'll count how many posts were made pre-game (that is, I will subtract posts made before the day 1 post on Sept 15, 10:57am MDT).
Note that I am not watching as new posts come in, so some of these counts might become outdated by the time they get posted.
ftl -- 6 posts pregame, 23 after that. Near the start, seemed overly interested in catching the doublevoter. His explanation was that he thought all doublevoters were scum. Although his post count is low, the content of his posts is above average in this game.
Voltgloss -- 13 posts pregame, 25 after that. There is some fluff, some content, but nothing that stands out in the slightest. Most interesting posts were the ones at the end, where he announced a case on me and did not deliver (but that is probably more to do with real life things, so that's not something to read into). I still don't like his yuma gambit, where he voted for yuma and then later unvoted and FOS'd the people who voted yuma (see post #550 and the posts that follow on that page).
Eevee -- 7/47 (this format should be clear, right? the second number is posts after gamestart, not total posts). This is enough posts that I don't want to actual re-read. I get a town vibe from him though.
Grujah -- 11/15. He starts the meta discussion, of which I am not a fan. Votes for cayvie based on misunderstanding of her claim. Few posts, mostly content-less IMO.
Insomniac -- 11/39. About a quarter of those 39 posts were made recently, in conversation about his vote picks.
Glooble -- 6/16. A couple of bigger posts just giving thoughts on the players, but still mostly contentless. 3/45. Null read.
jotheonah -- 11/90. Too much to reread.
Young_Nick -- 9/13. I know he was V/LA for a good portion of the early game, but if he started following when he got in he should have been able to contribute to conversations then. Plus, he just complains about nobody giving him summaries. Just go back and read, dude. The ONLY post I see that has even a bit of content in it seems to be one where he muses about lynching Axxle due to his doublevote, on the basis of yuma's suggestion. That's it. I really don't like this -- he's had time to catch up, or even without that he could have contributed to current conversations. Instead, he opted to continue lurking. Or, to use the new catch phrase, "actilurking".
Voltaire -- 12/65. I skimmed through and nothing stands out. Meh.
Axxle -- 6/26. Not much content, though I still have a slight town vibe from him. I don't know.
O -- 1/33. Posts are O-like in general. I get town vibe from him.
cayvie -- 9/67. Re-reading doesn't help much; I almost never get a scumvibe from cayvie. I don't here either. Her "can't be on townie wagon" is weird. It's a neutral thing, but I don't know what to make of it. Other than that... yeah, town vibe...
shraeye -- 3/56. Seemed weirdly focused on O for a majority of the day. I haven't looked at his document yet. Other than that, neutral.
Cuzz -- 3/20. Relatively content-less.
yuma -- 4/53. Still neutral to me.
ibgtennis -- 1/9. So, so content-less.
TheMunch -- 1/46. Not going to re-read at this time. Still feel he is a bit suspicious based on earlier exchange.
Morgrim7 -- 6/14. Morgrim is Morgrim. :\
eHalcyon -- 9/84. Not going to re-read myself.
Watno -- 1/32. Mostly neutral. I think his exchange with TheMunch after my own discussion with Munch looks overly aggressive.
Galzria -- 30/44. Has posted a lot less than I thought. I think his "I'm going to lurk" snarkiness (I kind of want to label it a tantrum) in the early game is a bit weird. Generally neutral on him anyway.
Captain_Frisk -- 6/41. Posts do seem relatively content-less.
ehunt -- 3/63. When ehunt made his "I'm going to post once a day" post, I thought it was clear that it was once per real life day, not once per game day. Rereading it now, it is obvious that it meant once per real life day. So FOS: people who thought it was once per game day.
In general, ehunt reads town to me. His "give me an item" thing was a little weird, but no weirder than cayvie's lynch thing. O wanted people to reread ehunt... nothing looks particularly scummy to me, actually.
Hm, one statement that is a bit weird is #694 where he says you shouldn't confirm people as townies because of a cult, even if you are about to be lynched. I mean, I can kind of seeing that making sense, but I think it would be better for people to divulge that info, and the rest of us just have to bear in mind that the info might not be good. He makes the concession for when they are about to be lynched, in #697, but I think it makes sense either way. Meh.
I'll also note that, from re-read, I think ehunt and Galzria seem to be buddying a little bit. That's not worth any suspicion, but it's something to remember if one of them flips scum.
I'm not sure what you're seeing, O.
ashersky -- 1/19. Not much content, but he is semi V/LA so I guess it's forgiveable. The "restart RVS" comment was weird.
Summary
Suspicious of the following, for not really contributing at all:
ftl, Grujah, Glooble, Young_Nick, Cuzz, ibgtennis, Morgrim (but Morgrim is Morgrim), Captain_Frisk
Suspicious of the following, but these suspicions may be tainted by OMGUS:
TheMunch, Voltgloss, Insomniac
Robz, can you prod TheMunch please? In the time I took to write this, TheMunch came back.
Author
Topic: Mafia XI: Find Yourself in the Courtyard Masquerade -- GAME OVER, TOWN WINS (Read 318826 times)