Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Dsell]

I am glad I didn't have to choose between cayvie and Theorel. I was really, really convinced Theorel was town. Because he was for a while. I also believed cayvie was, but there was always something in the back of my mind. Guess that happens between two people who are lying to each other a whole bunch.

[cayvie]

Also Cayvie, we would have lost and I would have lynched you if you hadn't posted your last ~5 or so posts in the neighbor thread, where you mentioned both recieving counting house and using draught of the living dead on me 

well actually if you claimed during day you used draught I still probably would have lynched Theorel, but still..

see, i thought that using potions on people told you who used them! i thought you knew it was me.

[jotheonah]

No, they just got potions slipped into their drinks.

[eHalcyon]

Oh, and I hated being from My Little Pony. Seriously. WTF.

lol

i hated having to delete all my sarcastic posts and/or ones with swears in them!

Replace them with "Diddly"!

Man I almost did a spit take all over my laptop when I saw Galz come in on D3 with the quote from the Mafia QT. It was like a perfect storm of screwing our team with theorel giving dead Axxle's luck potion to the one guy who can spy in on QT's (how did we not think to NK him??)

Though I was highly amused at how long Insomniac managed to stay alive after that.

That quote had me thinking that Galz might be scum, because you linked Robz and me.  Knowing it was the truth, it also sounded to me like you guys were talking about the daykill rather than the mod "confirmation".

[Archetype]

Really fun game! There was so much behind the scenes stuff happening I got so confused. And the night where ftl, Jigglypuff, asher and I died was crazy!

But now I realise how weak asher and I really were

Execellent modding jot! And also co-modding Volt and Glooble.

Overall, really fun! Cant wait for the next one!

[Dsell]

Really fun game! There was so much behind the scenes stuff happening I got so confused. And the night where ftl, Jigglypuff, asher and I died was crazy!

But now I realise how weak asher and I really were

Execellent modding jot! And also co-modding Volt and Glooble.

Overall, really fun! Cant wait for the next one!

Yeah, really sorry! I thought I was so clever for figuring out that Jigglypuff and Mad hatter must both be scum roles! I used my one-shot extra night kill on you, so sorry about that. XD

[jotheonah]

Mad Hatter as bus driver, very logical. Especially because the flavor tying Eevee's character to his role was pretty weak.

[jotheonah]

Really fun game! There was so much behind the scenes stuff happening I got so confused. And the night where ftl, Jigglypuff, asher and I died was crazy!

But now I realise how weak asher and I really were

Execellent modding jot! And also co-modding Volt and Glooble.

Overall, really fun! Cant wait for the next one!

Yeah, I wanted everyone to have a fun role, but the town was pretty OP. So you guys were definitely pretty weak for balance reasons.

[Galzria]

Really fun game! There was so much behind the scenes stuff happening I got so confused. And the night where ftl, Jigglypuff, asher and I died was crazy!

But now I realise how weak asher and I really were

Execellent modding jot! And also co-modding Volt and Glooble.

Overall, really fun! Cant wait for the next one!

Yeah, I wanted everyone to have a fun role, but the town was pretty OP. So you guys were definitely pretty weak for balance reasons.

Lies. I was so under powered. It took inspired play by Theorel to make use of my role. Certainly nothing I could really control.

[jotheonah]

Your role was one of the other ones thrown in to keep town power down. As was Watno's. And Morgrim's mandatory bodyguard.

[Eevee]

Really fun game! There was so much behind the scenes stuff happening I got so confused. And the night where ftl, Jigglypuff, asher and I died was crazy!

But now I realise how weak asher and I really were

Execellent modding jot! And also co-modding Volt and Glooble.

Overall, really fun! Cant wait for the next one!

Yeah, I wanted everyone to have a fun role, but the town was pretty OP. So you guys were definitely pretty weak for balance reasons.

You still gave town me (not that I'm particularly useful as a person, but my role sure was) after all this balancing?

[Cuzz]

Man I almost did a spit take all over my laptop when I saw Galz come in on D3 with the quote from the Mafia QT. It was like a perfect storm of screwing our team with theorel giving dead Axxle's luck potion to the one guy who can spy in on QT's (how did we not think to NK him??)

Though I was highly amused at how long Insomniac managed to stay alive after that.

That quote had me thinking that Galz might be scum, because you linked Robz and me.  Knowing it was the truth, it also sounded to me like you guys were talking about the daykill rather than the mod "confirmation".

Just goes to show how hard it is to deduce what's obvious to others. When Galz posted the quote from our QT, from my perspective it was equivalent to joth saying "Cuzz and Insom are scum, promise I'm not lying."

The you and Robz thing was that both of you had made mention of a power involving music. I really wonder what would have happened if I had faked my nameclaim. I thought hard about it, but you had claimed what seemed like an ability to catch anyone in a lie, and all the while Insom of all people was pushing me to take my turn in the nameclaim so I panicked and told the truth.

I'm also completely ashamed in retrospect of not picking up on the earthbending flavor.

[jotheonah]

Really fun game! There was so much behind the scenes stuff happening I got so confused. And the night where ftl, Jigglypuff, asher and I died was crazy!

But now I realise how weak asher and I really were

Execellent modding jot! And also co-modding Volt and Glooble.

Overall, really fun! Cant wait for the next one!

Yeah, I wanted everyone to have a fun role, but the town was pretty OP. So you guys were definitely pretty weak for balance reasons.

You still gave town me (not that I'm particularly useful as a person, but my role sure was) after all this balancing?

Well, I felt super bad that I accidentally missed your sign-up! And I couldn't put you on a scum team. So I tried to make a really weak town role. It went like this:

What doesn't the setup have? A night-action bus driver! How can I make a bus-driver weaker? Only make it one-way.

Then I realized that was actually stronger. OH WELL.

[Eevee]

Really fun game! There was so much behind the scenes stuff happening I got so confused. And the night where ftl, Jigglypuff, asher and I died was crazy!

But now I realise how weak asher and I really were

Execellent modding jot! And also co-modding Volt and Glooble.

Overall, really fun! Cant wait for the next one!

Yeah, I wanted everyone to have a fun role, but the town was pretty OP. So you guys were definitely pretty weak for balance reasons.

You still gave town me (not that I'm particularly useful as a person, but my role sure was) after all this balancing?

Well, I felt super bad that I accidentally missed your sign-up! And I couldn't put you on a scum team. So I tried to make a really weak town role. It went like this:

What doesn't the setup have? A night-action bus driver! How can I make a bus-driver weaker? Only make it one-way.

Then I realized that was actually stronger. OH WELL.

I didn't really mind..

[Archetype]

Really fun game! There was so much behind the scenes stuff happening I got so confused. And the night where ftl, Jigglypuff, asher and I died was crazy!

But now I realise how weak asher and I really were

Execellent modding jot! And also co-modding Volt and Glooble.

Overall, really fun! Cant wait for the next one!

Yeah, really sorry! I thought I was so clever for figuring out that Jigglypuff and Mad hatter must both be scum roles! I used my one-shot extra night kill on you, so sorry about that. XD

Don't sweat it! Mad Hatter does seem pretty scummy I would have suspected them too.

I was going to claim the blue caterpilar, but I couldnt remember his name! So in a quick decision I said MH and hoped asher could think of something to claim.

Are QT isnt as interesting as the others It was mainly accusing others as Scum and figuring out who we wanted to vote for… But we were wrong about nearly everything XD

Ashersky is a good player though. A lot more vocal than me

Those post restrictions we had were messed up! I couldn't understand half of what asher meant in his posts and it was very difficult to express my opinion on anything.

[theorel]

I will say, that I was really confused there at the end.  jo told me that both Voltaire and DSell had died...but I knew I hadn't killed them.  I had looked at the neighborhood QT, and I had already figured that DSell was doctor (as I said the day we lynched Insom).  Cayvie bringing O back to life made it extremely unlikely she was the SK.  I just couldn't figure out what could be going on.  If only Cayvie hadn't brought O back to life, I could have had my first "win" at mafia (being tied with town).  But alas, I ended up joining the sinking ship that was the scum-team that couldn't NK anybody.

Anyways, I still had fun, and I was trying to concoct a way to convince O to lynch cayvie.  I think had he not been neighborized, I might have tried to convince him that I had a 3rd-shot of my dead-powers and had used it to res him with Snape's potion.  I don't know if he would have believed me though.  Obviously not with cayvie talking about Counting House in the neighbor thread.

[Dsell]

Your role was one of the other ones thrown in to keep town power down. As was Watno's. And Morgrim's mandatory bodyguard.

Did Watno have any power besides turning a random person into a whale? What kind of other random effects would have happened if he had more chances to use it?

[jotheonah]

Watno had a (non-secret) second vote and he took an extra vote to lynch.

The IID turned a random player into a whale the first night. It doctored a random player (Robz) night.

The plan was to have it do a random effect that would potentially help whatever team was losing. (so the random doctor could have been a random roleblock or even a random kill, depending on the game state). If everyone was doing about the same, it would do something neutral, probably flavor-related.

When Glooble and I were younger we did a good amount of D&D Homebrewing and he used to like drawing up really complicated d-percentile tables for D&D artifacts (think the deck of many things). I was hoping to talk him into drawing up one of those for the IID, but there wasn't time.

[Watno]

YAY, we won
And Dsell actually was scum when he refused to nameclaim.

[jotheonah]

well, half-scum.

[Insomniac]

We woulda won too if it wasn't for you kids and the meddling dog too...

Oops no scooby based roles.

[jotheonah]

There WILL be a sequel, in terms of roles from all around pop culture and flavor being key.

However, (1) not for a while and (2) I'm aiming for it to be a non-bastard role madness game with better balance and an honest mod.

[Dsell]

YAY, we won
And Dsell actually was scum when he refused to nameclaim.

Most helpful scum ever, NK'ing 2 mafia and stopping a NK in the endgame... That had nothing to do with not claiming though. I could safely fakeclaim any medical doctor on tv. There were a lot of reasons for not claiming: Doctor is often a prime target for mafia NK's, if I became full SK later I wouldn't be bound to doctoring or a fake claim, if I became town I could maybe fully explain the whole situation and wouldn't have to explain a fake claim (or fake breadcrumb. Breadcrumbing House from House might have been a mistake in the first place, I did regret it some later). I did what I thought was best both for me and for the town. Fortunately no one really went after me for it.

[O]

I will say, that I was really confused there at the end.  jo told me that both Voltaire and DSell had died...but I knew I hadn't killed them.  I had looked at the neighborhood QT, and I had already figured that DSell was doctor (as I said the day we lynched Insom).  Cayvie bringing O back to life made it extremely unlikely she was the SK.  I just couldn't figure out what could be going on.  If only Cayvie hadn't brought O back to life, I could have had my first "win" at mafia (being tied with town).  But alas, I ended up joining the sinking ship that was the scum-team that couldn't NK anybody.

Anyways, I still had fun, and I was trying to concoct a way to convince O to lynch cayvie.  I think had he not been neighborized, I might have tried to convince him that I had a 3rd-shot of my dead-powers and had used it to res him with Snape's potion.  I don't know if he would have believed me though.  Obviously not with cayvie talking about Counting House in the neighbor thread.

I was going to test to see who knew the name.

[Axxle]

Looks like dying was actually a pretty good move for me, since you guys raided all my potions and used them extremely well!