Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[mcmcsalot]

I join the chorus of people saying EFHW's claim is hella suspicious, but let's give them one night to either get nightkilled or get a result.

This is a good point efhw can at least provide results

[Cuzz]

If mafia didn’t pick a bunch of mods fake claiming is relatively safe and tracker is by far the most dangerous role which they at least get to take out in the event of a counterclaim.

I would also pivot to scola but I’m not sold efhw is really tracker

Me neither but I don’t think it’s safe to go through with an exile at this point

[WestCoastDidds]

If mafia didn’t pick a bunch of mods fake claiming is relatively safe and tracker is by far the most dangerous role which they at least get to take out in the event of a counterclaim.

I would also pivot to scola but I’m not sold efhw is really tracker

Me neither but I don’t think it’s safe to go through with an exile at this point

Exile or no exile?

[WestCoastDidds]

It seems like we lose the most when we no exile. And if there is ever a day we choose to no exile, I would prefer we do it as a time that moves the nights to the weekend so we actually get 5 days out of our days.

[Cuzz]

If mafia didn’t pick a bunch of mods fake claiming is relatively safe and tracker is by far the most dangerous role which they at least get to take out in the event of a counterclaim.

I would also pivot to scola but I’m not sold efhw is really tracker

Me neither but I don’t think it’s safe to go through with an exile at this point

Exile or no exile?

Not safe to exile efhw

[LaLight]

even if we wanted to get rid of EFHW, I think too many people have moved off her wagon by now. With less than 2 hours to go, it's scola or bust.

We do have an even number of players, so failing to exile here isn't the worst thing in the world. In fact I'm a little surprised no one suggested it.

yes, but there also might not be a nightkill

[Awaclus]

Deadline is in about 50 minutes.

[Awaclus]

No-exiling and then successfully preventing a NK would be the lamest thing ever, we should consider no-exiling later when we have a better idea if a kill is ever going to be prevented.

[jotheonah]

unofficial vote count:

Cuzz (1): Awaclus
EFHW (2): mcmcsalot, Galzria
jotheonah (1): Swowl
Galzria (2): shraeye, scolapasta
scolapasta (6): Robz888, Cuzz, LaLight, EFHW, WestCoastDidds, jotheonah

Not Voting (0)

People who can get an exile for us right now: Awaclus, mcmcsalot, Galzria, Swowl, shraeye -- at least three of whom have been around posting in the last couple of hours.

[WestCoastDidds]

If mafia didn’t pick a bunch of mods fake claiming is relatively safe and tracker is by far the most dangerous role which they at least get to take out in the event of a counterclaim.

I would also pivot to scola but I’m not sold efhw is really tracker

Me neither but I don’t think it’s safe to go through with an exile at this point

Exile or no exile?

Not safe to exile efhw

Ah!

[mcmcsalot]

Yea I am here and will hammer scola just waiting to see if they show up as they said they would

[EFHW]

My role came as a mod. I started out as VT.

[scolapasta]

I'm town, so should not be exiled. That said, I don't like the end of no exile either, so...

At least if I get x out. Hopefully you can learn some information from who's suddenly decided to vote for me. It seems pretty suspicious how quickly the wagon on me got created.

For what reason? Because I didn't post much on day one which I've admitted every game I played that I'm not good at. Weird.

Problem. I also don't see anyone likely to be exiled today. Which kind of sucks for me.

[scolapasta]

I do hope efhw is at least really a tracker, and survives the night with some information.

[scolapasta]

At least efhw exiling me. This game won't lose it for us like it did last time. 🙂

Clearly, i am still bitter about that.

[WestCoastDidds]

At least efhw exiling me. This game won't lose it for us like it did last time. 🙂

Clearly, i am still bitter about that.

I think it’s totally fair to stay salty awhile. I feel ya

[mcmcsalot]

well i don't love it but vote: scola

[scolapasta]

well i don't love it but vote: scola

Spoken like a scum player. One of the brothers I'd say for sure.

Good luck town!

[mcmcsalot]

At least efhw exiling me. This game won't lose it for us like it did last time. 🙂

Clearly, i am still bitter about that.

I think it’s totally fair to stay salty awhile. I feel ya

salty about that game where he lurked for the first 2 days, claimed a pr at l-3 and then later lied to town about the use of his pr. Are we supposed to be shocked that that player gets exhiled in an endgame?

[WestCoastDidds]

At least efhw exiling me. This game won't lose it for us like it did last time. 🙂

Clearly, i am still bitter about that.

I think it’s totally fair to stay salty awhile. I feel ya

Mwhahahahaha. Yep, lessons learned for sure. But that last day did go down really fast before he got to say much
salty about that game where he lurked for the first 2 days, claimed a pr at l-3 and then later lied to town about the use of his pr. Are we supposed to be shocked that that player gets exhiled in an endgame?

[scolapasta]

I have yet to post much about last game, but I think lying as town is perfectly acceptable. As it's a tool town has since Mafia has more information.

It backfired me last ti, me since I had the role detective, otherwise it probably would have worked

Also, I don't recall lurking day two of last game. I do seem to lurk d1s, because I don't like day one, hopefully people will stop exiling me for that

[mcmcsalot]

well i don't love it but vote: scola

Spoken like a scum player. One of the brothers I'd say for sure.

Good luck town!

If I was scum I would just exhile you before you even came back. perhaps this is town!mcmc frustrated because I think there is a decent chance you are town and your exhile doesnt tell us anything about the rest of the players in the game since you have zero interactions with them.

[scolapasta]

For future game, I'll also add not posting, doesn't necessarily mean lurking. I have times where I'm busy and just don't have time, and then times where I can post lots of things. It does seem as my posting time's off and come when others can't, late night East Coast.

[mcmcsalot]

I have yet to post much about last game, but I think lying as town is perfectly acceptable. As it's a tool town has since Mafia has more information.

It backfired me last ti, me since I had the role detective, otherwise it probably would have worked

Also, I don't recall lurking day two of last game. I do seem to lurk d1s, because I don't like day one, hopefully people will stop exiling me for that

I explained it in the speccy qt of that game, while lying as town can be beneficial for town lying as scum is extremely beneficial for scum. Hence allowing lying as town opens the door to lie as scum and say well I was lying as town for X or Y reason. The upside is so much bigger for scum collectively its better for town to refuse to allow town to lie thus preventing scum from lying.

[scolapasta]

well i don't love it but vote: scola

Spoken like a scum player. One of the brothers I'd say for sure.

Good luck town!

If I was scum I would just exhile you before you even came back. perhaps this is town!mcmc frustrated because I think there is a decent chance you are town and your exhile doesnt tell us anything about the rest of the players in the game since you have zero interactions with them.

I don't believe the I would Exile without letting you post.