Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[scolapasta]

That's what I'm doing.

I like how I'm most town. I feel like I've worked for that, and I like that I'm being rewarded for my effort.

Scola, did you give anything N2? Did you recieve anything N1?

Oh, whoops that was supposed to say "MiX?". as in maybe you're the most town? But not as definitive as without the ?.

[MiX]

I have been item less since after N1.

Also, this is why I don't trust the anyone can win with the three pieces of the owl. I mean I started with a piece, how am I supposed to collect the other 2, if I have to give it away?

That said, not sure why joth would mislead on that.

This is incredibly boring and I highly doubt you're town in this situation.

Do we lynch scola or LL first? I can't decide.

[scolapasta]

That I'm town in what situation?

[MiX]

That I'm town in what situation?

In the "I started with 1 piece of an item that is essentially only good for third-party and I need nothing else" situation.

[scolapasta]

OK. I agree that is boring. Read all the above I've posted.

And you're asserting I'm scum, because that's too boring.

Well, not much I can do about that. Except point out that the very setup describes this role, the generous towny. So we know boring roles like mine exist. Would it be less boring if it started out with a different item? I still would've had to give it away.

[MiX]

OK. I agree that is boring. Read all the above I've posted.

And you're asserting I'm scum, because that's too boring.

Well, not much I can do about that. Except point out that the very setup describes this role, the generous towny. So we know boring roles like mine exist. Would it be less boring if it started out with a different item? I still would've had to give it away.

Yes.

I'm fairly sure you're scum because I'm infinitely more powerful than you, and that's super boring for you if you're actually town.

Rest-of-town: what do you think?

[sudgy]

@faust, are you also talking about an owl piece too?

Dunno if it's an owl, I just know it's for some kind of bird. It got stolen from me last night. MiX was the only person who knew I had it.

How did you not know it was for an owl? What DID you know?

Whoever doesn't want me to make 1 post per quote+question, just say so.

As stated, I know that it was made of Copper, and that it belonged to a bird. I suppose I am not ornithologist enough to deduce what bird based on the piece of the bird I had.

That's strange, because mine said that it was part of an owl.

Anyway, I'll take a close look at this tonight and figure everything out about the claims.

I have been item less since after N1.

Also, this is why I don't trust the anyone can win with the three pieces of the owl. I mean I started with a piece, how am I supposed to collect the other 2, if I have to give it away?

That said, not sure why joth would mislead on that.

I think everybody else (that is not a generous townie) are not required to give away items.

[sudgy]

OK. I agree that is boring. Read all the above I've posted.

And you're asserting I'm scum, because that's too boring.

Well, not much I can do about that. Except point out that the very setup describes this role, the generous towny. So we know boring roles like mine exist. Would it be less boring if it started out with a different item? I still would've had to give it away.

Yes.

I'm fairly sure you're scum because I'm infinitely more powerful than you, and that's super boring for you if you're actually town.

Rest-of-town: what do you think?

I know you won't listen to me because you think I'm scum, but scola's situation is exactly mine.  I guess I will claim now, I'm a generous townie, and started with an owl piece.  His situation is identical to mine.

[scolapasta]

That's strange, because mine said that it was part of an owl.

Sure, but if you had the head, it would make sense you would know it was an Owl. Without the head, it was just a bird to me (and I assume faust).

I think everybody else (that is not a generous townie) are not required to give away items.

I did ask that question a few times, no one confirmed either way, but it does seem like it.

[MiX]

Okay ?? ?? ?? ?? ?? ?? ??

Am I the only person with my mechanic in the game?

[scolapasta]

OK. I agree that is boring. Read all the above I've posted.

And you're asserting I'm scum, because that's too boring.

Well, not much I can do about that. Except point out that the very setup describes this role, the generous towny. So we know boring roles like mine exist. Would it be less boring if it started out with a different item? I still would've had to give it away.

Yes.

I'm fairly sure you're scum because I'm infinitely more powerful than you, and that's super boring for you if you're actually town.

Rest-of-town: what do you think?

I know you won't listen to me because you think I'm scum, but scola's situation is exactly mine.  I guess I will claim now, I'm a generous townie, and started with an owl piece.  His situation is identical to mine.

I mean I get MiX's opinion that this is boring (and agree), but again, it says it right in the set up. Some of us will be generous townies with no other power:

You are a Generous Townie. You have no special powers. Your weapon is your vote. At night, if you have at least one item, you must give at least one item to another player (unless this is overwritten by the item description.)

I mean once we know this exists, how do you make it less boring?

[MiX]

Sigh, I guess this push was anti-town, I'm sorry.

It feels like there's no actual PRs, or maybe scum just killed them all and we're screwed.

[Joseph2302]

Everyone but Joseph has claimed to start with exactly 1 item. This seems to make sense. For me it clears the chance he's scum, although I'm fairly sure there's more items than what have been claimed.

For example, I can't find what Didds wanted. Maybe Swan had it?

Okay clarification needed: I started with 1 item, but it's not useful to me
Or anyone else based on what people have said

Do you still have it?

Yes

[scolapasta]

So, I still wonder if the the baseball cap makes someone an IC. (I'm just imaging a little kid with a cap). Maybe it would only do that for generous townies? (clearly it can't for everyone).

[jotheonah]

Sigh, I guess this push was anti-town, I'm sorry.

It feels like there's no actual PRs, or maybe scum just killed them all and we're screwed.

Maybe the people with PRs just don't want to claim them? At this point it almost feels like we should mass fullclaim. I mean, we nearly have.

[MiX]

Sigh, I guess this push was anti-town, I'm sorry.

It feels like there's no actual PRs, or maybe scum just killed them all and we're screwed.

Maybe the people with PRs just don't want to claim them? At this point it almost feels like we should mass fullclaim. I mean, we nearly have.

We'll do that tomorrow, it's fine.

[mail-mi]

So, I still wonder if the the baseball cap makes someone an IC. (I'm just imaging a little kid with a cap). Maybe it would only do that for generous townies? (clearly it can't for everyone).

It didn't say that in the description. And I don't know how that would work, if the generous townies could give each other the baseball cap and create a bunch of ICs... Seems imbalanced.

[A Drowned Kernel]

I have been item less since after N1.

Also, this is why I don't trust the anyone can win with the three pieces of the owl. I mean I started with a piece, how am I supposed to collect the other 2, if I have to give it away?

That said, not sure why joth would mislead on that.

This is a lie; I gave the magnifying glass to scola night one

vote: scola

[MiX]

Ho boy.

I think scum enters the 1v1 willingly if they think there's 4 scum (they either know or suspect there's a traitor)

Interesting.

[MiX]

mail-mi VS skip

faust VS LaLight

ADK VS scola

Does that make sudgy town? I don't wanna believe that...

[mail-mi]

I have been item less since after N1.

Also, this is why I don't trust the anyone can win with the three pieces of the owl. I mean I started with a piece, how am I supposed to collect the other 2, if I have to give it away?

That said, not sure why joth would mislead on that.

This is a lie; I gave the magnifying glass to scola night one

vote: scola

Oh interesting.

I think in this situation scola comes out as scummier.

[mail-mi]

mail-mi VS skip

faust VS LaLight

ADK VS scola

Does that make sudgy town? I don't wanna believe that...

The only nigh-garunteed 1v1 we have here is ADK and scola. There could easily be two town sailors or two town pawnbrokers, I think.

[scolapasta]

So, I still wonder if the the baseball cap makes someone an IC. (I'm just imaging a little kid with a cap). Maybe it would only do that for generous townies? (clearly it can't for everyone).

It didn't say that in the description. And I don't know how that would work, if the generous townies could give each other the baseball cap and create a bunch of ICs... Seems imbalanced.

I mean, it's got to do something, no? And if only 2 generous townies, at most two ICs.

Though, I now have another idea of what it could do -  could there be a some kind of Master of Disguise role?




PPE: huh, interesting. I'll still post this, but will clearly respond to other posts!

[scolapasta]

I have been item less since after N1.

Also, this is why I don't trust the anyone can win with the three pieces of the owl. I mean I started with a piece, how am I supposed to collect the other 2, if I have to give it away?

That said, not sure why joth would mislead on that.

This is a lie; I gave the magnifying glass to scola night one

vote: scola

OK, ADK is scum. I received nothing.

And everyone else who tried giving an item but was intercepted was told that it was intercepted. (right?)

I do agree with MiX that scum might be willing to enter a 1v1 based on #s here. But one way to help prove my innocence would be for other generous townies to claim. I mean, how many can there be?

Also, ADK, why give it to me? I didn't claim any needed item. DatSwan at least had a telescope in his list, and that may have been a roundabout way of hinting at a magnifying glass. Did you not trust them (like I didn't Joseph). But then why me?

[faust]

@ADK: Did you receive confirmation that you successfully gave away the item?