Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[MiX]

Back to Vote: LaLight actually, this game's harder than I thought.

Mostly because we lynched people that don't let us solve the game.

[skip wooznum]

So the story with the owl is:

Joseph started the game with piece A, still has it.
Scola started the game with piece B, gave it to joth N1, stolen by Joseph N2.
Faust started the game with piece C, offered to trade with mix N1 (mix declined), stolen by unknown N2.

Is this an accurate and complete account?

Joseph started with a piece? I guess that makes sense balance-wise.

Who's scum?

I thought he said somewhere that he has two pieces, and nobody else claimed to give any to him.

I don't know. I'm working my way through your "why is everyone town" and I agree with most of it. Otoh, I was hard townreading adk and LL. It occurs to me that the owl might have some different effect in scum's hands, which means joth might be scum. Scola and sudgy are also good candidates. And then there's always mail-mi!

Ppe

[MiX]

And is in I believe 3 parts, of which someone (I assume sudgy) gave me 1 last night

Who is this someone?

[sudgy]

My scumread on LL is giving way to sudgy/skip scumteam. sudgy defends skip all day and pushes mislynches.

Vote: skip and I'd like a claim from sudgy in their next post.

Oh no, one person voted for me, I have to claim!  Not happening, unless we're doing a massclaim or something.  I will say (since I've already hinted at it) that I started the game with an owl piece and gave it to Joseph.

[MiX]

My scumread on LL is giving way to sudgy/skip scumteam. sudgy defends skip all day and pushes mislynches.

Vote: skip and I'd like a claim from sudgy in their next post.

Oh no, one person voted for me, I have to claim!  Not happening, unless we're doing a massclaim or something.  I will say (since I've already hinted at it) that I started the game with an owl piece and gave it to Joseph.

See you did claim in your next post.

Reread D1 and D2, lynch order:

Sudgy: Pushes mislynches, read D2 for Galzria push all day, zero regrets today, look at how he defended the 1v1 D1, and then skip once he had to make a decision (he voted mail-mi), seems to be helping scum much more than town.

LaLight: Forcing a 1v1 on faust which is essencially a smokescreen and anti-ton, self votes for AtE, terrible reads, on mail-mi's wagon a bunch.

Skip: Scummier of the D1 1v1, mostly because I think he's sudgy's partner.

mail-mi: Cap is useless, hasn't given it away I presume, no one needs it, we need to close the conflict with skip, likely to be scum if skip's town.

Scola: D2 push on Galzria, not doing much, not as town as most.

ADK: Out of the non-town, he's the one pushing the best things and overall looks townier.

Joseph: Well he's not town, so if we must, we can do this.

[scolapasta]

I've been wanting a skip lynch since d1.

Vote: skip

[skip wooznum]

Oh sorry, missed sudgy's owl piece.

[MiX]

Oh sorry, missed sudgy's owl piece.

He hadn't claimed it.

[MiX]

Joth, why did you give the notebook and not the codebook?

I finally wrote every claim, and this would complete my townread on you.

[Joseph2302]

So the story with the owl is:

Joseph started the game with piece A, still has it.
Scola started the game with piece B, gave it to joth N1, stolen by Joseph N2.
Faust started the game with piece C, offered to trade with mix N1 (mix declined), stolen by unknown N2.

Is this an accurate and complete account?

Joseph started with a piece? I guess that makes sense balance-wise.

Who's scum?

I thought he said somewhere that he has two pieces, and nobody else claimed to give any to him.

I don't know. I'm working my way through your "why is everyone town" and I agree with most of it. Otoh, I was hard townreading adk and LL. It occurs to me that the owl might have some different effect in scum's hands, which means joth might be scum. Scola and sudgy are also good candidates. And then there's always mail-mi!

Ppe

I started with 0 pieces
Was given one N1 and stole one N2

[Joseph2302]

My scumread on LL is giving way to sudgy/skip scumteam. sudgy defends skip all day and pushes mislynches.

Vote: skip and I'd like a claim from sudgy in their next post.

Oh no, one person voted for me, I have to claim!  Not happening, unless we're doing a massclaim or something.  I will say (since I've already hinted at it) that I started the game with an owl piece and gave it to Joseph.

I believe this to be true. I was given one N1 and first thing sudgy did D2 was ask if I received anything useful

[LaLight]

i gave a knife to sudgy

[mail-mi]

I like ADK's plan. I'll start. We're listing items we need right?

Blueberries
Rope
Camera
Glasses
Hat

Can you explain your though process on making these fake items?

Uh, I looked around the room, thought for a minute, and said what popped into my head? No other process than that.

[MiX]

I like ADK's plan. I'll start. We're listing items we need right?

Blueberries
Rope
Camera
Glasses
Hat

Can you explain your though process on making these fake items?

Uh, I looked around the room, thought for a minute, and said what popped into my head? No other process than that.

Why did you say Hat when you had a specific type of Hat?

[mail-mi]

I like ADK's plan. I'll start. We're listing items we need right?

Blueberries
Rope
Camera
Glasses
Hat

Can you explain your though process on making these fake items?

Uh, I looked around the room, thought for a minute, and said what popped into my head? No other process than that.

Why did you say Hat when you had a specific type of Hat?

Wasn't thinking about it, honestly.

[MiX]

I like ADK's plan. I'll start. We're listing items we need right?

Blueberries
Rope
Camera
Glasses
Hat

Can you explain your though process on making these fake items?

Uh, I looked around the room, thought for a minute, and said what popped into my head? No other process than that.

Why did you say Hat when you had a specific type of Hat?

Wasn't thinking about it, honestly.

One town down, 2 or 1 to go.

Who's town out of skip/sudgy/LL/scola/ADK?

[mail-mi]

I like ADK's plan. I'll start. We're listing items we need right?

Blueberries
Rope
Camera
Glasses
Hat

Can you explain your though process on making these fake items?

Uh, I looked around the room, thought for a minute, and said what popped into my head? No other process than that.

Why did you say Hat when you had a specific type of Hat?

Wasn't thinking about it, honestly.

One town down, 2 or 1 to go.

Who's town out of skip/sudgy/LL/scola/ADK?

If I had to rank those 5, id say (scum) ADK, LL, skip, sudgy, scola.

[jotheonah]

Joth, why did you give the notebook and not the codebook?

I finally wrote every claim, and this would complete my townread on you.

Neither does anything without the other, so I just picked one.

[MiX]

Joth, why did you give the notebook and not the codebook?

I finally wrote every claim, and this would complete my townread on you.

Neither does anything without the other, so I just picked one.

What is your role?

[A Drowned Kernel]

If mix is going to be this belligerent about it: I started the game with a magnifying glass, I gave it away N1, I'd rather not say to who

[MiX]

Everyone but Joseph has claimed to start with exactly 1 item. This seems to make sense. For me it clears the chance he's scum, although I'm fairly sure there's more items than what have been claimed.

For example, I can't find what Didds wanted. Maybe Swan had it?

[Joseph2302]

Everyone but Joseph has claimed to start with exactly 1 item. This seems to make sense. For me it clears the chance he's scum, although I'm fairly sure there's more items than what have been claimed.

For example, I can't find what Didds wanted. Maybe Swan had it?

Okay clarification needed: I started with 1 item, but it's not useful to me
Or anyone else based on what people have said

[MiX]

Everyone but Joseph has claimed to start with exactly 1 item. This seems to make sense. For me it clears the chance he's scum, although I'm fairly sure there's more items than what have been claimed.

For example, I can't find what Didds wanted. Maybe Swan had it?

Okay clarification needed: I started with 1 item, but it's not useful to me
Or anyone else based on what people have said

Do you still have it?

[jotheonah]

Joth, why did you give the notebook and not the codebook?

I finally wrote every claim, and this would complete my townread on you.

Neither does anything without the other, so I just picked one.

What is your role?

Not sure I want to claim yet, though I think I know why you’re asking. Suffice it to say I’m obviously not a GT.

[MiX]

Joth, why did you give the notebook and not the codebook?

I finally wrote every claim, and this would complete my townread on you.

Neither does anything without the other, so I just picked one.

What is your role?

Not sure I want to claim yet, though I think I know why you’re asking. Suffice it to say I’m obviously not a GT.

Do you have what you need, other than the notebook?