Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[WestCoastDidds]

So many people looking towny, and because of all the neighborhoods I have a strange feeling of not wanting to lynch anyone.

Vote: Lekkit

I have no reason not to find them scummy at this point... I have a slight preference for them over Raptor because there was that one game one time that raptor was awesome on D2.

Hey! You take that back if you're referring to what I believe you are referring to! How could I have known 

I'm having a strange third-party read off Didds here, actually. Feels like she knows much more than she's letting us know, but not necessarily in a scummy way. Not lynching anyway, hoods do this.

But you have to admit, it does move Raptor up on the utility list over Lekkit, yeah?

No one seems scummy, everyone seems scummy. Trimming the fat, needs some sort of tie break, although I recognize that we have two more days to figure stuff out.

[EFHW]

Answer what?  I explained it all in detail, and someone even complained that I gave away too much information in my explanation.  But yes, the short of it is I wanted to catch someone in a lie.  (There was also the possibility that there could be shenanigans with the draft we didn't know, so that seemed like a useful thing to pick up on.)

I guess I always expect more of you.

Unvote

It doesn't bother you that the claiming was hurtful to town?

Town is hurt?  I don't buy it.

If there are any scum in r2, they are super pleased right now.

[ashersky]

Answer what?  I explained it all in detail, and someone even complained that I gave away too much information in my explanation.  But yes, the short of it is I wanted to catch someone in a lie.  (There was also the possibility that there could be shenanigans with the draft we didn't know, so that seemed like a useful thing to pick up on.)

I guess I always expect more of you.

Unvote

It doesn't bother you that the claiming was hurtful to town?

Town is hurt?  I don't buy it.

If there are any scum in r2, they are super pleased right now.

Super pleased?  Please explain.

At best, they know a subset of players with a possible subset of items. If you think that helps them so much that they are “super pleased,” you know more than the average player about something.

From my perspective, we gave scum very little.  Sure, r2 is smaller so the subset is smaller, but the items are still unknowns, as is who has what.

The absolute best case I can come up with is if I were scum, last to pick, and had exactly the right number of misses on my list to narrow the group’s items even more.  And then I still don’t know who got what.

[EFHW]

Ok, maybe some hyperbole there, but no one has explained to my satisfaction what benefit town received, or would receive if I claimed.

[MiX]

Ok, maybe some hyperbole there, but no one has explained to my satisfaction what benefit town received, or would receive if I claimed.

The end of the round claim, which is at least a minimal benefit to town as opposed to worth absolutely nothing for scum. No I'm not telling you what the benefit is, that would ruin the whole purpose of it.

At this point I'd love to see what the downside to ending it could ever be.

But you have to admit, it does move Raptor up on the utility list over Lekkit, yeah?

That would be true, if Lekkit wasn't my neighbor. I like what they're doing there, slight town points for it overall.

Vote: Jimmmmm for having fooled me before, not seeing anything especially towny from them, a few people who I need to reread are also ones I'm against lynching on a fundamental level, so Jimmmmm's a good lynch I believe, possibly the best.

[WestCoastDidds]

MIx, can you shed some more info about Lekkit? What are they doing that you like?

[MiX]

MIx, can you shed some more info about Lekkit? What are they doing that you like?

Sharing a lot of their thought process, asking for what I think about certain posts, being careful about their information and reads, cooperating...overall something that I really don't want to lose D1. I don't find them especially towny, but that's enough for a D1 pass for me.

[Lekkit]

I think Ash and e are most likely town. I would prefer not to lynch MiX, shraeye, Scolo or cayvie. Probably not faust either.

[cayvie]

...huh, I was going to ask WCD why Lekkit over raptor--my gut said that Lekkit was townier, between the two--and then I reread them.

I think if I was going to choose between those two, I would also vote Lekkit. Sure, raptor's said some scummy-sounding things (in particular that line of not wanting to look scummy) but at least raptor's shared opinions on things other than the setup.

It took until his most recent post for Lekkit to share an opinion about another player in this thread. I'm not exaggerating.

vote: Lekkit

[shraeye]

I think Ash and e are most likely town. I would prefer not to lynch MiX, shraeye, Scolo or cayvie. Probably not faust either.

I'm liking that whole list except Scolapasta.  What's the hesitation there?

[shraeye]

Also. I want to know why people are jumping on the Scola wagon.

You think they shouldn't have?

Which brings me back to this unanswered question.  Add to it "why?"

[Lekkit]

Also. I want to know why people are jumping on the Scola wagon.

You think they shouldn't have?

Which brings me back to this unanswered question.  Add to it "why?"

Actually not sure I want to elaborate that too much. But to answer the first question. I don't think people should've just joined in without much questioning. The case is... Very flimsy at best.

[Lekkit]

For the record, MiX now knows my role.

[MiX]

For the record, MiX now knows my role.

Lekkit is town, you can go ahead and move to other wagons now.

[mail-mi]

For the record, MiX now knows my role.

Lekkit is town, you can go ahead and move to other wagons now.

Uh, role power has nothing to do with towniness or scumminess. This is nonevidence.

[MiX]

For the record, MiX now knows my role.

Lekkit is town, you can go ahead and move to other wagons now.

Uh, role power has nothing to do with towniness or scumminess. This is nonevidence.

Who said it's evidence? I'm just saying Lekkit's town. The level of confidence and reasons behind it are private.

On the other hand, we could move on other wagons, that would be much more productive.

[Lekkit]

On the other hand, we could move on other wagons, that would be much more productive.

This is very true.

Vote: mail-mi

[cayvie]

Intra-district reads summary

District 1
shraeye thinks scola is scummy
scola thinks shraeye is towny

District 2
faust has not expressed a direct opinion on glooble as far as i can find, but has shared info with him and hasn't pushed a case, so i'm guessing faust thinks he's towny (lots of posts tho, mighta missed it)
glooble thinks faust is towny

District 3
jimmmmm thinks e is towny
e thinks jimmmmm is towny

District 4
LaLight has not expressed an opinion on Ash
Ash thinks LaLight is towny

District 5
WCD thinks ADK is towny
ADK thinks WCD is towny

District 6
Lekkit thinks MiX is towny (at least, he "prefer not to lynch" MiX today)
MiX thinks Lekkit is towny

District 7
raptor has not expressed an opinion on mail-mi
mail-mi thinks raptor is scummy

District 8
cayvie thinks EFHW is towny
EFHW thinks cayvie is towny

did i miss anyone? did i misrepresent anyone? has anyone changed their opinion since they last posted about their neighbor?

LaLight, raptor, faust: do you have a read on your neighbor?

[cayvie]

oh gfd i had to go and use MLA formatting there when quoting and make everything strikethrough of course

[cayvie]

in case you missed it because of the strikethru:

raptor, LaLight, faust: do you have a read on your neighbor?

[scolapasta]

I actually lean scummy on Shraeye. Not in a way where I'd definitively say "Shraeye is scum", but they are on my short list.

[cayvie]

I actually lean scummy on Shraeye. Not in a way where I'd definitively say "Shraeye is scum", but they are on my short list.

you're absolutely right, my bad.

[Swowl]

Vote Count 1.7:


Mail-Mi (5): Jimmm, LaLight, E!, ADK, Lekkit
Ashersky (2): EFHW, scolapasta
Lekkit (2): WCD, Cayvie
LaLight (1):  MailMi
Scolapasta (1): Shraeye
RaptorSlayer (1): Glooble
Shraeye (1): RaptorSlayer
faust (1): Ashersky
Jimmmmm (1): MiX
MiX (1): faust

Not Voting (0):   

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

Deadline is 9:15pm Forum Time on March 24th. That is in just under 3 days!

[mail-mi]

On the other hand, we could move on other wagons, that would be much more productive.

This is very true.

Vote: mail-mi

Not productive. No one else gonna join me on LaLight?

[shraeye]

On the other hand, we could move on other wagons, that would be much more productive.

This is very true.

Vote: mail-mi

Not productive. No one else gonna join me on LaLight?

I'm not; so far he's LaLight-y.