Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[raerae]

If you lynch me we will have extra free time to join a new game. This game is not being powned by a team that includes Ari and Debatepro with a coach.

We are losing in an epic way, this will be a perfect scum win, new players can’t pull this off.

So who's the team then?

[Debatepro]

And consider what a silver lunch does re: faust. Does it make him town? Do we consider a faust lunch tomorrow? I think it hurts us to kill one of them today IF we're willing to entertain the thought of them being a team.

Why does kicking the can down the road on the silver/Faust with the paradox you describe make it more likely we’ll discover the partnership?

The way this game has unfolded I think it requires great skill so I’m up for lynching one of SS, EFHW, or Faust.

PPE

[raerae]

And consider what a silver lunch does re: faust. Does it make him town? Do we consider a faust lunch tomorrow? I think it hurts us to kill one of them today IF we're willing to entertain the thought of them being a team.

Why does kicking the can down the road on the silver/Faust with the paradox you describe make it more likely we’ll discover the partnership?

The way this game has unfolded I think it requires great skill so I’m up for lynching one of SS, EFHW, or Faust.

PPE

I'm saying it's dumb to decide tomorrow whether or not they're a team. We need to decide today. One's flip simply can't tell us anything about the alignment of the other.

[Debatepro]

@raerae. What is your take on EFHW?

[EFHW]

And, for what it's worth, when I suggested an EFHW lynch at the beginning of the day I was fishing, hoping scum would see it as an easy lynch since the IC suggested it.  Clearly they are clever devils.  That is highly disappointing.

[silverspawn]

I really don't understand what faust has done to deserve the town cred you're all giving him. been right about Joseph? What about all the people he's not been right about?

This is just another one of those games where faust is scum and will live to the end.

If the EFHW lynch was bait, his handling of her looks particularly bad imo.

[EFHW]

@raerae, I'm in.

[raerae]

I guess we're waiting to hear from faust then? Unless Ari wants to come back to the light?

[silverspawn]

Lynching debatepro will most likely result in us losing the game right there.

[raerae]

And town can blame me for that if they need somebody to blame. I'm doing the best I can with what I have and guilt trips aren't going to sway me.

[faust]

I guess we're waiting to hear from faust then? Unless Ari wants to come back to the light?

Mh, I really don't think ari and Debate are scum together. In what possible world do two newbie scums tunnel a third newbie for basically all of D1?

[faust]

And I don't think we can afford to play games like trying to lynch scum's PR. We should lynch whatever player has the highest chance of flipping scum, and that is silver by a mile.

[faust]

And if you do want to play the PR game, it's not like silver received any serious suspicion from either Debate or ari, so he may be the PR just as much as Debate in that team.

[raerae]

EFHW, Uncle, sounds like we need to have that talk about whether or not they're a team. Or we could just lynch Ari and be in the same boat tomorrow.

[faust]

I will be forever grateful if you do listen to me this time! #guilttrip

[EFHW]

I guess we're waiting to hear from faust then? Unless Ari wants to come back to the light?

Mh, I really don't think ari and Debate are scum together. In what possible world do two newbie scums tunnel a third newbie for basically all of D1?

That kind of reasoning gets us in trouble. Who knows what newbies would do? They're new!

[EFHW]

And if you do want to play the PR game, it's not like silver received any serious suspicion from either Debate or ari, so he may be the PR just as much as Debate in that team.

Silver and Debate's reaction to raerae's proposal makes me think she is right about the PR. Of course, they can just kill me if we get the ninja (if there is one), but then they have wasted a possible mislynch and left an IC alive (silver's reasoning).

[EFHW]

The way this game has unfolded I think it requires great skill so I’m up for lynching one of SS, EFHW, or Faust.

Maybe the team is Debate, ari, Eddie!

[Debatepro]

And if you do want to play the PR game, it's not like silver received any serious suspicion from either Debate or ari, so he may be the PR just as much as Debate in that team.

Silver and Debate's reaction to raerae's proposal makes me think she is right about the PR. Of course, they can just kill me if we get the ninja (if there is one), but then they have wasted a possible mislynch and left an IC alive (silver's reasoning).

What is the PR proposal? I’m reacting to my name being dropped.

[EFHW]

Naw, you two cool.  I'm pretty sure it's you, me, EFHW, and faust.  I'm pretty sure they're (Ari and silver) protecting Debate (notice how he's getting about as much suspicion as me and EFHW?) so I think that means he's got the PR, or at least the one they want to protect the most.  Which is why I'd prefer his lynch today.  You game?

[faust]

I guess we're waiting to hear from faust then? Unless Ari wants to come back to the light?

Mh, I really don't think ari and Debate are scum together. In what possible world do two newbie scums tunnel a third newbie for basically all of D1?

That kind of reasoning gets us in trouble. Who knows what newbies would do? They're new!

Well by that reasoning noone would ever be able to have any sort of read on a newbie.

[raerae]

I guess we're waiting to hear from faust then? Unless Ari wants to come back to the light?

Mh, I really don't think ari and Debate are scum together. In what possible world do two newbie scums tunnel a third newbie for basically all of D1?

That kind of reasoning gets us in trouble. Who knows what newbies would do? They're new!

Well by that reasoning noone would ever be able to have any sort of read on a newbie.

Which is kinda true, honestly.

[faust]

I guess we're waiting to hear from faust then? Unless Ari wants to come back to the light?

Mh, I really don't think ari and Debate are scum together. In what possible world do two newbie scums tunnel a third newbie for basically all of D1?

That kind of reasoning gets us in trouble. Who knows what newbies would do? They're new!

Well by that reasoning noone would ever be able to have any sort of read on a newbie.

Which is kinda true, honestly.

They are harder to get a read on, that much is true. But I've found wagon analysis to be a useful tool for that because it really does not depend that much on personal playstyle.

[raerae]

I guess we're waiting to hear from faust then? Unless Ari wants to come back to the light?

Mh, I really don't think ari and Debate are scum together. In what possible world do two newbie scums tunnel a third newbie for basically all of D1?

That kind of reasoning gets us in trouble. Who knows what newbies would do? They're new!

Well by that reasoning noone would ever be able to have any sort of read on a newbie.

Which is kinda true, honestly.

They are harder to get a read on, that much is true. But I've found wagon analysis to be a useful tool for that because it really does not depend that much on personal playstyle.

I've been on every lunch this game, does that make me scum?

[silverspawn]

And I don't think we can afford to play games like trying to lynch scum's PR. We should lynch whatever player has the highest chance of flipping scum, and that is silver by a mile.

If you are in fact town, then I'll come back to this next time you express a confident and incorrect scum read on me. You did the same thing just last game.