faust, is raerae scummy or not?
I guess the best I can say is "somewhat". I don't like that way she is constantly asking for reasons for people voting her. She should rather convince people that she's town through her play. I admit that there may be just some playstyle difference at work here. Then there is the early MiX wagon, which has both ari and raerae on it. I do not think that two scum stay glued to the MiX wagon all Day, and I think ari is scum, which in turn makes raerae a bit townier. But then there is also her D1 wagon, which in comparison to the other wagons seems quite townie and avoided by scum - which would make her scummier. I also put some stock in the opinion of people who know her better - particularly you - and you seem to think that she's town.
Overall I come out at slight scum.
Man, this sounds scummy to me. But that doesn't mean it is scummy; this is what I'm wrestling with right now, and it's difficult.
The post also sounds genuine....but eeerrrg. Like, if ari is not scum (which I think he's not) and I wasn't vocal about my townread, then would raerae be a much bigger scumread from faust? These are valid opinions that he makes, but it just has the feel of "Ari first, but let's not forget that raerae is playing differently than I would." But this is from someone who I wouldn't think would fall for the weird=bad fallacy.
You picking up what I'm putting down, faust? other people? This is my not-black-and-white opinion about faust's not-black-and-white opinion.