- raerae asks for shraeye's reason for voting me, he doesn't give it, she's annoyed; this is so easily orchestrated by two scum wanting to look like they're interacting with each other, but really, why did raerae have to ask that? There's no way shraeye would simply answer, this was a waste of time.
This is a natural interaction, there is no reason to believe it was orchestrated. raerae's asking is meh, but this does not point towards them being a team.
- pushes for a shraeye!MiX scumteam, votes shraeye first then me; all the talk about shraeye's suspicious in itself: sure they know each other IRL but "he's dangerous as scum, exceedingly dangerous" is...excessive, then there's the "if shraeye flips scum MiX's next" which could very well be "if my scumpartner dies let's mislynch someone".
raerae does not early D1 make the plan to bus shraeye just to be able to lynch you afterwards. That conspiracy theory level analysis. You are taking what she said and try to fit it in your narrative but you don't consider alternative explanations.
- keeps throwing shade on me while voting for shraeye (#191 is a great example of this); easily explainable if you see that she's preparing to jump on my wagon.
I don't see a reason for scum to "prepare" jumping on your wagon. They can just do so if they want to, especially early D1. And again, you say something is explainable by your theory, but this is not actually evidence that your theory is true. Trump being president may be explainable by the world being secretly controlled by lizard people.
- more interaction between them that leads nowhere, now about shraeye's (new) case on me, admits he's right; a much better question to ask here would be "why did you pick 3 people to guess?" but that would make shraeye have to answer it; he eventually does, but not due to raerae.
shraeye as any alignment knows that as soon as he posts those 3 names, he's going to be questioned on why he chose them. A potential scumpartner would not need to avoid that question.
- votes for me, the tipping point? My interaction with shraeye...which would at best point to a shraeye!MiX team. She points out more, but most of it is sheeping other's cases...although they're right, I don't like how she swapped BECAUSE of a slip that could only exist in shraeye!MiX, for me this was an excuse to ditch her vote on shraeye and start pushing my wagon. This is all in #329.
If raerae decided to bus a scumpartner, then there is no real reason for her to back out here. It's not like the shraeye wagon got any kind of traction, she could have continued voting there safely.
- tells faust shraeye's case depended on me being scum...then why did she vote for shraeye? Again, this feels like creating interaction out of thin air.
Not sure what this is referring to.
- says her case on me is (and I quote) "shows knowledge of shraeye's intent pre-game". And...? Did she forget everything else she said? At this point she's voting for me because...what, the only person on shraeye's wagon is me? I would totally take that opportunity of scum bussing each other and lynch...the most dangerous one (note how, in her PoV, we're both bussing); she already admited shraeye's more dangerous...my answer? She wants an active player out of the game and a player whose meta she knows in.
Meh, if she really thought you are both scum then it makes sense for town!her to jump on the bigger wagon.
Author
Topic: M121: Philosophers Mafia Mafia (Game Over, Perfect Mafia Victory!) (Read 297161 times)