Ok, yeah. I guess it does make sense from a potential threat position.
That being said, the other potential scenario is simply scum didn't shoot because they knew my lynch would be an easy argument. If scum had successfully killed we would have 4 alive, no lynch today to set up lylo tomorrow.
Since a no kill happened (either through protection or just no kill), it could very well be posturing for lylo. Let's assume scum killed hydrad, no lynch, kill robz. Lylo is me, awaclus, space. Now lylo (if I get lynched) is robz, awaclus, space.
Space and awaclus are both in those scenarios, and they are where I am looking for scum. I think at a minimum (even if we lynch me) I want to have time and provide feedback on who I think is scum between them
Feel the need to point out again that yeah... your points are solid, but I would much rather flip it out between Space and Awaclus tomorrow (or whoever), and lynch you today. It is nothing to do with you or your play... it's just that it makes sense. If there is even a 1% chance in anyone's head saying "oh maybe such and such could happen and we could consider E! tomorrow..." then it is not worth letting you live.
I hate to beat a dead horse - but I purposely left PPS off my skum read list on the lynch list. So there is like 0% reason for skum to believe I would protect PPS (also considering my previous pushes on them). E! eliminating PPS just makes sense as Skum!E. It further "verifies" their role.
The absolute only other possibility that makes sense is that Robz is Skum, given I did not die last night... and that is like a bazillion times less likely than E!
All in all, it doesn't matter - there is only one correct play today and that is to lynch E!
To expand:
Skum!Space = Kills me. Why the hell not? like one reason, really?
Skum!Robz = Kills me. Or maybe Space to set up Town!E, but those are the only two options other than glhf Robz is king of skum.
Skum!Awaclus = Kills me. Again, why the hell wouldn't they?
Skum!E = Kills PPS as they were told to and reserves the vig shot to solidify the win. Or, I suppose, they dumbly shoot 2 people last night (one of which sure as shit wouldn't of been Robz)... so actually yeah no that doesn't make any sense.
Skum!Swan = Town!Doctor... because there is literally no other scenario at this point in which Robz is alive.
All of this adds up to an LCD of Swan/E!/Robz. If ya'll want to hash it out tomorrow that is cool.
But if we lynch E! and he is skum we win.
If we don't lynch E! and he is skum we lose.
If we lynch E! and he is town, we get another chance tomorrow.
Awaclus (or anyone) - poke holes in that please.