Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Witherweaver]

Skumpy is being a lot less strange then the other games I’ve played with him. I don’t think he’s the most townie, but pushing the quick lynch does nothing here.

I would argue that it indeed does something, for example motivate you to make this post.

And just imagine how many more post/ content there would be if we wait closer till days end

If someone quickhammers them and they turn out to be town, we have an outed scum.

That's not how it works.

From my understanding, scum quickhammers to reduce discussion on that day. I think town would atleast post their intent before doing so.

There are a few players on this board I think you should meet.

[Witherweaver]

Lolz didn’t realize this was actually happening.

Unvote

This is scummy.

[Witherweaver]

Can someone voting skumpy layout there reasoning to lynch him so early in the day?

I believe there is scum on the wagon

This is probably either scummy or townie.

How many games have you played before?

[SirClemens]

Skumpy is being a lot less strange then the other games I’ve played with him. I don’t think he’s the most townie, but pushing the quick lynch does nothing here.

I would argue that it indeed does something, for example motivate you to make this post.

And just imagine how many more post/ content there would be if we wait closer till days end

If someone quickhammers them and they turn out to be town, we have an outed scum.

That's not how it works.

From my understanding, scum quickhammers to reduce discussion on that day. I think town would atleast post their intent before doing so.

There are a few players on this board I think you should meet.

?

[Awaclus]

Vote: raptor

[SirClemens]

Read list:

Towny:

• faust - He helped getting this game going and I like all his posts. Or he is just scum playing well.

Null - Towny:

• DatSwan - Was interested in getting this game going. Haven’t heard much lately.
• Xxraptorslayer96 - Asking good questions

Null:

• Witherweaver - Nothing much to see yet.
• Awaclus - Not much yet, but thinking of older games that is too be expecte(?)[l/i]
  

Scummy - Null:

• Seprix - Where is you content?
• stevanzzo - same question

Scummy:

• Skumpy - I voted him in the first place to generate discussion and each of his following posts convinced me to keep my vote there. And he ignores the fact that his wagon has spawned discussion.

 


PPE: Awaclus
 

[Xxraptorslayer96]

Can someone voting skumpy layout there reasoning to lynch him so early in the day?

I believe there is scum on the wagon

This is probably either scummy or townie.

How many games have you played before?

2

[Witherweaver]

Skumpy is being a lot less strange then the other games I’ve played with him. I don’t think he’s the most townie, but pushing the quick lynch does nothing here.

I would argue that it indeed does something, for example motivate you to make this post.

And just imagine how many more post/ content there would be if we wait closer till days end

If someone quickhammers them and they turn out to be town, we have an outed scum.

That's not how it works.

From my understanding, scum quickhammers to reduce discussion on that day. I think town would atleast post their intent before doing so.

There are a few players on this board I think you should meet.

?

For instance, Ashersky and PPS are notorious for quickhammering. Some other players are somewhat likely to. I always want to play that boldly, but I tend to get hesitant.

[Xxraptorslayer96]

I am alive.

also, joining the bandwagon.

vote Skumpy

I dislike this vote a lot but I feel like it’s because he’s new and just wants to feel like he’s contbuting

PPE:1

[Xxraptorslayer96]

Vote: Skumpy

wagons!

I’ll Vote: Witherweaver

Reasons:
-votes without stating reasoning
-isn’t contributing very much
-I would expect an experienced player to be trying harder to scum hunt.

[Skumpy]

Stupid Skumpy, which is what I am most of the team
And in the rare cases when I somehow get wagons, Salty Skumpy.
Some people (namely yourself) get sick of the first persona, and so vote it to make it finally shut up since it's always comfortable when its flying above suspicion. Then you get the second one.

Please do not presume to know what I think or why I vote and make completely unfounded assumptions on how I feel about your playstyle. I am not voting you because I "got sick" of your in-game persona, and claiming any such thing is a deliberate attempt to disqualify my legitimate scumread on you.

...this was phrased badly in the first place, then it got equivocated, and now even I'm not sure as to what I meant exactly. I'm going to drop this now unless people really really want me to break it down in depth.

Skumpy, how many games have you payed before?

1 finished, 1 in progress.

Vote: Skumpy

wagons!

I’ll Vote: Witherweaver

Reasons:
-votes without stating reasoning
-isn’t contributing very much
-I would expect an experienced player to be trying harder to scum hunt.

Another vote I get and am fine with. Verve were a ho twit because any wagon that's not on me is strictly better, and everybody trusts faust apparently. Which is a first in my limited experience, interestingly. If Raptor's scum, this is a huge improvement over your first game. If your town, it's a huge improvement over your last game (plz no modkill for compliments).

Lolz didn’t realize this was actually happening.

Unvote

This is scummy.

It's what I'd do as town. Or scum too probably, but that's why this is null.

@SirClemens' reads: I've never played with scum!faust before. But I know that to give him towncred for that is a bad call. Even if faust's town, you're severely underestimating scum ability. Unless you already know this.

Ignores the fact that my wagon has spawned discussion? No, that part is fantastic, I agree. What's not fantastic is the guinea pig who's generating discussion. Is there a reason you don't want to vote somewhere else and generate even more discussion? Like Witherweaver?

I'm now realizing that of the 4 people I haven't played with, 1 is MIA and 3 are voting for me. Go read M105, know this is standard me. Except for being at L-1 D1, that's a first. It is not hard to tell when I'm skummy. If there's doubt in your mind, the case is closed.

Also, talking is not scummy or Skummy, even when I have to talk in order to not get lynched. People who fly under the radar doing nothing is worth more attention. And there have been a lot of them so far. The focus is ridiculously misplaced, I've never seen a tunnel this hard, which is even more insane because it's on me. None of you have any alarm bells ringing, saying "maaaaaybe this is a really dumb decsion???"

@schadd: Vote is in the middle. Sorrry

[SirClemens]

I like Skumpy‘s latest post unvote

[SirClemens]

Vote: Seprix for lurking

[Seprix]

I am alive.

also, joining the bandwagon.

vote Skumpy

!!!!! The hell??? Why? I'll read this as an amateur mistake but this looks very bad for you.

Vote: Seprix for lurking

Work is a thing.

In other news, people tend to do weird stuff in the openings, and somehow that means we're supposed to be making reads. Uh okay then.

[Swowl]

Vote count 1.1

Seprix (1): Awaclus
faust (1): faust
Skumpy (4): faust, DatSwan, SirClemens, Witherweaver

not voting (3): Seprix, stevanzzo, Xxraptorslayer96

with 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. day 1 starts now and ends friday, december 8th at 13:00 forum time

mod notes

• prodding stevanzzo

mod quotes

That was my first phone post vote ever. I forgot it wouldnt bold automatically. And now its ruined and I need a new one 

Sweat: Van Dot

blegh. but i guess this is fine since nobody's usernames are uh isomorphic

Hey everyone!

I HIT RAVES

i shit, vera?

It's obvious, isn't it?

vote: schadd

to vote people: use bold - the big b at the upper left of the formatting stuff or

Code: [Select]

[b]vote: schadd[/b]
also i'm not a player! but that may have been intentional

So this is a while ago, but I would like to point out that Faust is voting for both himself and for Skumpy in this count...

[schadd]

Vote count 1.2

Skumpy (3): faust, Witherweaver, stevanzzo
Xxraptorslayer96 (1): Awaclus
Witherweaver (2): Xxraptorslayer96, Skumpy
Seprix (1): SirClemens

not voting (2): Seprix, DatSwan

with 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. day 1 ends friday, december 8th at 13:00 forum time

mod notes

• faust took the place of skumpy in the last vc, fixed. oh which swanda just pointed out.
• 's done, tom

mod quotes

quod mōtēs

[stevanzzo]

!!!!! The hell??? Why? I'll read this as an amateur mistake but this looks very bad for you.

Just keeping the vote at 4 so I could see who drops and/or who pushed him over the edge.

That being said, it's down to 3 by my count (probably wrong, I'm bad at counting.) so unvote.

As for it looking bad, sure. From the reactions earlier, unvoting makes it look worse.

[faust]

!!!!! The hell??? Why? I'll read this as an amateur mistake but this looks very bad for you.

Just keeping the vote at 4 so I could see who drops and/or who pushed him over the edge.

That being said, it's down to 3 by my count (probably wrong, I'm bad at counting.) so unvote.

As for it looking bad, sure. From the reactions earlier, unvoting makes it look worse.

Have you played mafia IRL before? Or other mafia experiences not on this site?

[Skumpy]

In other news, people tend to do weird stuff in the openings, and somehow that means we're supposed to be making reads. Uh okay then.

You'd be surprised. I don't really get it either, honestly. But you should vote just for the sake of making anagrams, it's fun.

Back to Stupid Skumpy now that my wagon has receded. But still suspicious of faust.

[faust]

Back to Stupid Skumpy now that my wagon has receded. But still suspicious of faust.

Don't worry, the feeling is mutual.

[faust]

@SirClemens' reads: I've never played with scum!faust before. But I know that to give him towncred for that is a bad call. Even if faust's town, you're severely underestimating scum ability. Unless you already know this.

"Never townread faust" is not a viable solution though. Hard as it may be, you have to figure out a way to read me.

[Swowl]

I am alive.

also, joining the bandwagon.

vote Skumpy

!!!!! The hell??? Why? I'll read this as an amateur mistake but this looks very bad for you.

Why exactly does this look bad for him from your perspective?

[Seprix]

I am alive.

also, joining the bandwagon.

vote Skumpy

!!!!! The hell??? Why? I'll read this as an amateur mistake but this looks very bad for you.

Why exactly does this look bad for him from your perspective?

Uh, because putting someone at L-1 without announcing it is bad, jumping on a bandwagon because "hahaha it's a bandwagon this is fun" is super duper scummy. Skumpy was at L-2 at that point, and that revote put him at L-1 again, completely unannounced, and for the scummiest reasons. It's so blatant that I'm willing to read it as an amateur mistake but geeeeeeeez

[Xxraptorslayer96]

I like Skumpy‘s latest post unvote

What about skumpys post made him go from bottom of your list to seprix being bottom?

[SirClemens]

I like Skumpy‘s latest post unvote

What about skumpys post made him go from bottom of your list to seprix being bottom?

It just made Skumpy move one tier up and I voted Seprix for lurking. He stopped doing that and stevanzzo is entitled to a day 1 pass as a newbie. So unvote