Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Swowl]

My name is Swan!

I like long walks on the beach and catching skum

[faust]

Oh and vote: Skumpy

[SirClemens]

And hello new guys. Want to tell us a bit about yourselves? We're always interested in prior mafia experiences and the like.

No experiences other than reading a few threads here.

[Xxraptorslayer96]

My name is Swan!

I like long walks on the beach and catching skum

Also those who don’t know, swan and I are ‘twin claim’ -
All it means is we know each other irl, not real twins.
I’m not sure how/if this impacts my reads on him in the game.

[Seprix]

My name is Swan!

I like long walks on the beach and catching skum

Also those who don’t know, swan and I are ‘twin claim’ -
All it means is we know each other irl, not real twins.
I’m not sure how/if this impacts my reads on him in the game.

This means you know him more than anyone else.. and vice versa. It could be an interesting dynamic.

[Witherweaver]

My name is Swan!

I like long walks on the beach and catching skum

Also those who don’t know, swan and I are ‘twin claim’ -
All it means is we know each other irl, not real twins.
I’m not sure how/if this impacts my reads on him in the game.

Is this the first game you've played?

[Xxraptorslayer96]

My name is Swan!

I like long walks on the beach and catching skum

Also those who don’t know, swan and I are ‘twin claim’ -
All it means is we know each other irl, not real twins.
I’m not sure how/if this impacts my reads on him in the game.

Is this the first game you've played?

No, this is the third.
I’ve played in M105 and M110
Both w/swan

[Swowl]

vote: skumpy for not already submitting a post about breaking the set up. Dude its been like 2 days.

[Swowl]

weather is nice here in Cali....

[Xxraptorslayer96]

weather is nice here in Cali....

It’s a bit chilly out..

[Swowl]

OK so I am trying super hard to break the set up and I am coming up blank.

Best possible thing I can think of I hate still - which is NEO claim. If we have a NEO we have a 50% chance of a doctor to proc them, and we can narrow Skum down to 2 potential roles. But even then, I don't think the 33% chance that we come back no NEO (helps skum more than town) combined with the 50% chance that if we have a doc with a neo really is worth stating out loud given the upside is all we do is narrow the skum PRs down to a 50-50 of Cop or Blocker.


I am so freeking bored guys someone say something.

[SirClemens]

I am so freeking bored guys someone say something.

Any idea how to move this game forward? I agree with you that a NEO claim would be bad, any claim would be bad this early in the game.

[Skumpy]

vote: skumpy for not already submitting a post about breaking the set up. Dude its been like 2 days.

Thanks for the reminder. PR's should definitely claim here, that'll make for an easy win.

But I didn't read the setup too closely. What I saw in my glancethrough was: potentially 2 roles, they know a little more about what other town roles are and are not in play, and can guess the scum role better. Not much else to say. Tough for scum to fakeclaim right now, not that that's going to factor into anything because claiming accomplishes nothing.

I had that written, then I started reading back Swan's post: a neo claiming narrows us down to A1 and B3. A1 sucks: scum kills neopolitan or even just roleblocks them. B3 is more interesting: scum can't roleblock neo and can't risk killing them because of the doctor. Is a 50/50 shot worth the risk it at this point? I'd say no. Doctor defense would be good to have, but no non-doctors have a better-than-50% chance of having a doctor with 'em. Best odds are for Neo.

TL:DR Don't claim. Not needed, not worth it.

I am so freeking bored guys someone say something.

OK. Don't vote me. And you spelled phreeking wrong.


Long day, I'm tired now.

[faust]

I am so freeking bored guys someone say something.

Any idea how to move this game forward? I agree with you that a NEO claim would be bad, any claim would be bad this early in the game.

Well you could tell us who you think is scum.

[faust]

Or we can get a nice wagon started on Skumpy. Already have two votes. The guy is scum, you've heard it here first.

[SirClemens]

I am so freeking bored guys someone say something.

Any idea how to move this game forward? I agree with you that a NEO claim would be bad, any claim would be bad this early in the game.

Well you could tell us who you think is scum.

Most players haven‘t done anything that indicates their alignment. DatSwan seems towny, not sure what to make of Skumpy‘s last post.

Or we can get a nice wagon started on Skumpy. Already have two votes. The guy is scum, you've heard it here first.

I guess I will sheep Vote: Skumpy

[SirClemens]

Or we can get a nice wagon started on Skumpy. Already have two votes. The guy is scum, you've heard it here first.

Wait, I know you are a really good player, but how can so few posts make you sure he is scum?

[Skumpy]

Or we can get a nice wagon started on Skumpy. Already have two votes. The guy is scum, you've heard it here first.

The term is skum, thank you very much.

Vote: faust

My first OMGUS! I always wanted one!

Luck's not going to make you town my first 3 games. And you know better than to lynch me based on opening posts.

And in the still-pretty-good-chance you're town:

1) It's a newbie game. It's a very different feel thusly far
2) I /inned on a /whim, not really expecting I'd be playing before that. I really wish I had kicked you out now.
3) I'm much further along in another game, I now understand what was meant by 'tough to pay attention to new games'
4) I'm more experienced and more relaxed, but that probably has more to do with the fact that I don't fear everybody as much as I would in M games.
5) I haven't had much time for anything. Period.
6) The flavor's fun. 110 is absolute garbage, I don't even really listen to Led Zeppelin anymore (still like/appreciate them though!)

PPE: Make of it that I was really really tired and wanted to go bed and now I'm sad I have to post more.
Sheeping and putting me at 2 votes from being lynched after 2 days is not a good look btw. It'll be even worse if I flip.

[SirClemens]

Town points for Skumpy and faust for getting this game going, I still like my vote on Skumpy.

[faust]

Luck's not going to make you town my first 3 games. And you know better than to lynch me based on opening posts.

Anyone abusing probablity like this derserves to be policy lynched anyway.

[faust]

Or we can get a nice wagon started on Skumpy. Already have two votes. The guy is scum, you've heard it here first.

Wait, I know you are a really good player, but how can so few posts make you sure he is scum?

Here's how this works:

Any post that you make will slide you mildly towards being town or being scum in my head. Some will barely do anything, but still a tiny bit. So, after a lot of posts, usually I have a decent idea about alignment. (Of course sometimes I get conflicting reads and am still unsure, and sometimes I misread people.)

Now we don't have a lot of posts, yes. But the posts we do have still put everyone in a camp of either tentatively town or tentatively scum. Thus, once everyone posted a few things, someone will end up the scummiest, even though compared to late-game reads it's still not going off much.

So, am I sure Skumpy is scum? Well, no. But he is the scummiest of the bunch of you, and so I am going to push his lynch. Since you need to create activity and discussion, it does not actually matter how strong your read is, you should push for some lynch, defend someone, or else do stuff that other people can agree or disagree with as this gets the game moving. This is why I usually push hard, no matter how much evidence there actually is.

[SirClemens]

That was quite insightful.

[Awaclus]

it does not actually matter how strong your read is

It also doesn't matter whether your read is genuine or fake, I might add.

[Witherweaver]

Vote: Skumpy

wagons!

[Xxraptorslayer96]

Wow is skumpy really L-1 already??
request vote count

Skumpy is being a lot less strange then the other games I’ve played with him. I don’t think he’s the most townie, but pushing the quick lynch does nothing here. I have no problem voting him. But at the very least we can keep him alive to see his interactions with other players.

request prods on Stevanzzo